I’d never noticed this topic before, and it’s interesting you should reawaken it. I’ve been having the same discussion over Facebook with a friend of mine. I’ll copy and paste the most relevant parts here:
but how can it be selfless when the reasons for doing such acts are probably too for personal gain… However, there must be a small part of us that recognises that these events and doing things that are considered “selfless” by others and can illicit rewards, whether these be from alliances of reciprocal altrusim (you scratch my back, ill scratch yours -theory) to even rewards of a monetary value. Therefore we may look selfless, but really aren’t we just watching our own backs and looking after number one, which is ultimately selfish by then using this money, or knowing we have allies if times ever got rough. You see this every day too Rory, why do in office blocks every day do we see people suck up to their bosses.
There must be some reason that people do such acts which you consider to be “selfless” otherwise if they were of no reproductive or survival value they would have most certainly been eliminated from our “psyche”, especially of course as some selfless acts can be dangerous to the individual. Why if i wanted to keep myself alive (the most important thing evolutionary psychologists would say) would i save someone from a burning building?? surely by doing this i put myself at risk of death. Well how about if it was because the next day if i save the woman my name is plastered around the press and im celebrated by my peers, thus the act illicits rewards such as a raised status and admiration from my peers. We know this by watching it happen to others as i said by the media, or back in the days where these behaviours stemmed via word of mouth.
My Response:
What you’re missing here is the importance of values: that selflessness and altruism are concerned with men somehow producing some sort of values for other men, as their primary goal in life, as the good, and that men creating for themselves is evil.
“Personal gain” is irrelevant. That’s not what I’m talking about. Every action is to fulfil some desire, of course - the problem is what men desire, what men value; and if, indeed, they even know what sort of value they’re seeking. Does a man value, living for himself, for the thriving of his own existence, by pursuing human values (such as work, productivity, creativity, etc); or does he live off of other people, looting and mooching money, never having an original thought, taking everything by force - living as a sub-human, as a brutish animal.
The key point here is that a selfish action - by the definition I have given - is one which furthers rational values. Anything else, is not done with one’s long-term interests in mind, and is thus not done for one’s self, but is done for the destruction of oneself.
“I scratch your back, you scratch mine” is not universally selfish or selfless - what matters is the degree to which it is done. Do you destroy your own values whilst supporting someone elses? Do you invest more than you recieve back? Ultimately, the question is, are you sacrificing something to get something of lesser value from the other person? That is selflessness.
Selfishness is the trading of value for value - and could be well defined, but not accurately, in the ‘scratch my back, scratch yours’ context.
And back to this idea of humility - words have meaning! If someone lives their life, trying to impress others by debasing their own value - that IS selfless! What you’re describing is the thought process of millions of people - “If I self-deprecate myself, people will think I’m ‘honest’ and ‘human’ and will like me more”. Any action committed with a goal towards gaining a disingenuous favour, is second-handed - is selfless.
"There must be some reason that people do such acts which you consider to be “selfless” " Yes, there is - it is the fact that man is not some slave to his genes, constantly acting in the name of survival and reproduction - it is the very fact that man has the choice, between survival and death! Men can choose to take actions furthering their life, or take actions debasing and lessening their lives.
It is this choice, and as I have argued, the want of men for to conquer other men, that has lead to the parasitic behaviour known as altruism.
And again, your example of the burning building - going in, risking your life, just to gain favour with members of the public - that is a selfless action! The goal of it was not to promote your own values, but to sacrifice your highest value - your LIFE - for the sake of the approval of others.
Approval is NOT a virtue, nor a value. It is certainly a standard for judging certain things (such as democractic elections), but a VALUE it is not. A man canot live for the sake of pleasing others, and I think it’s quite accurately explained by Ford, when he stated that if he made what other people wanted, he’d simply make carriages with more horses, rather than cars.
The common dictum of economics is a fact of reality - producers set the demand, not the public.