Kentucky Senate race development

I’m not sure that I understand what you mean by compromise. Do you refuse to vote unless the canidate meets your exact specifications?

My voting record wouldn’t help clear up the meaning of the term compromise. This might:

"Compromise doesn’t mean ‘learn and change, when you’re wrong’, it means giving up an idea you know is correct in favor of an idea you know is incorrect, for the sake of joining someone’s cause or having them join yours. " (me, a couple of hours ago)

If you want a reason why I wouldn’t vote for Rand Paul, my reason is exactly the same as Kyle Haight’s in Post #9, and David’s a few posts earlier.

No sir, YOUR argument was in fact that a minority of people unwilling to compromise would solve the problem. Go back and read what YOU wrote.

Yes, I know I said that, and I stand by it. (that an uncompromising capitalist minority would facilitate some uncompromising Capitalist candidates, not that it’d help solve all our problems).

But my argument for why compromise is irrational was the other thing, the thing you still haven’t addressed even though I said it twice already.

And furthermore I did NOT assert that all lack of compromise was bad, only that lack of compromise was not necessarily good, as you appear to be assuming.

I know, and you’re wrong about that , and your argument in favor of that position is flawed. No compromise is rational, or good. All compromise is irrational, and bad, for the reason I mentioned twice now.

I’m not sure that I understand what you mean by compromise.

I’ll take this as an opportunity to mention, again, and recommend, Dr. Peikoff’s talk, “Why Should One Act on Principle,” available (free) on one’s “Registered User” page at the Ayn Rand Institute.

From the site, on the speech:

“Dr. Peikoff demonstrates that principles are the only tool that can make the questions of human life answerable. He dissects the pragmatists’ charge that principles are “simplistic,” clarifying why principles are indispensable to a conceptual consciousness and why moral principles are absolutes. This talk was delivered at the Ford Hall Forum in 1988.”

Dr. Peikoff’s chews the issue of compromise and the ill consequences that flow from a compromise of principles, namely, that a compromise of a principle is a complete rejection of that principle.

The talk is about an hour. Below it is a half-hour Q&A which followed the talk.

IMO, not voting for a candidate like Paul is not an absolute for Objectivists. There is a context where I could imagine voting and maybe even campaigning for Paul, namely if he were running against a candidate who was likely to win and was comparable to Adolf Hitler or Mao Zedong, i.e. if the alternative is TEOTWAKI. That is plainly not the case here. What we have is an unprincipled candidate in a pool of unprincipled candidates. It seems to me a greater danger is posed by a candidate who is (unjustifiably) associated with “acting on principle” and give the appearance of supporting valid political principles.

The simple fact that he believe that scientific fact is determined by legislative fiat puts him in the category of actively-dangerous people.

He fails the moron test. Continuing with his anti-choice position… “I would support legislation, a Sanctity of Life Amendment, establishing the principle that life begins at conception. This legislation would define life at conception in law, as a scientific statement.”

The follow on legislation would set pi = 3 and declare that the Sun revolves around the Earth is a scientific statement.

Bob Kolker

The abortion quote does seem to be implying that Mr. Paul is trying to support anti-abortion arguments from a non-religious standpoint - as if that’s some conceit towards enlightenment. And that does fail the moron test.

But just as you would choose a man of wavering principles over Hitler, so you might choose a man who wavers on some principles for the sake of those principles he does not waver on.

Seriously, until the government is in the business of only guarding objective rights - even then to some extent - people will disagree on what precisely the government should do and how. Having a principle and losing because nobody supports it is stupid.

Instead, I’d like to find someone who 1) says what their principles are 2) includes what they think they can get away with in terms of governance - ie some things just won’t be accepted by the constitutional process and the american people 3) and focus relentlessly on areas where they can make a difference. As long as a candidate is consistent with this from the beginning, and maintains the same set of rules, they are perfectly acceptable.

Right now, I want to see candidates who are willing to fight for two things: cutting spending and taxes as much as possible (inclusive is rejection of further healthcare etc. nonsense), and driving for school choice. Those two policies alone would make a tremendous difference, to the point of making other issues more or less irrelevant until the next election cycle. There is enough consensus that we should sort of fight terrorists, and that abortion will remain legal, etc. that I’m just not as worried about those issues. But there is not a consensus at all, that we need fiscal responsibility in the federal and state governments now or else. I’m not willing to sit alone in my basement with 8000 packs of ramen noodles and a shotgun while everyone upstairs figures out what’s next after they f%%&ed up the country.

Is there any other kind of politician to choose from?

Peter Schiff is pretty damn close. He’s running for CT Senator as a Republican. Look into his commentary on everything from social issues to the economy to foreign policy… he’s the best we’ve got. A pro-choice, capitalist, non-religious entrepreneur with sensible foreign policy views.

No compromise is rational, or good. All compromise is irrational, and bad, for the reason I mentioned twice now.

Compromise is OK as long as both parties agree and as long as you are not compromising on the principle involved. Dr. Peikoff illustrates this in the Ford Hall Forum lecture that Trebor linked to. The example he gives is (paraphrasing): “If the owners of Ford Hall Forum want me to talk for an hour but I only want to speak for half an hour, then it is OK to compromise on 45 minutes. But, if they want me to give a lecture on Zen Buhdism, then that is unacceptable.”

But we are talking about politicians here, all of whom hold the wrong principles, so you have to go on a case by case basis, as I think David Odden is suggesting. I’d say it is probably advisable to vote for almost anyone willing thwart the leftist agenda of Obama and the Dems, at least for the next two years.

"Compromise doesn’t mean ‘learn and change, when you’re wrong’, it means giving up an idea you know is correct in favor of an idea you know is incorrect, for the sake of joining someone’s cause or having them join yours. " (me, a couple of hours ago)

This sounds more like the definition of “capitulation” to me.

But just as you would choose a man of wavering principles over Hitler, so you might choose a man who wavers on some principles for the sake of those principles he does not waver on.

I would not support a quivering candidate only on the grounds that I have not yet observed him quivering on a particular point that I agree with. When a man appears to stand on some principle but embraces contradictions, then his principles have no real value to you – if you believe in free enterprise and contradictions, then you can also support something that is contrary to free enterprise. Basically, there is a serious matter of trust involved here: why should we trust that his future conduct is predictable?

At the moment I don’t see any reason to consider Paul better than the opposition; after the primary, things could be different. So perhaps if Paul is the Republican candidate and a flaming fundamentalist socialist is the Democrat then Paul could be the lesser of two evils.

I’d say it is probably advisable to vote for almost anyone willing thwart the leftist agenda of Obama and the Dems, at least for the next two years.

It’s also important to apply the Palin sniff-test. A monkey-wrench in the Obama “juggernaut” would be nice, though it seems that he’s not as unstoppable as seemed to be the case a year ago. But it would not be good to support a candidate whose principles derive from almighty god.

My voting record wouldn’t help clear up the meaning of the term compromise. This might:

"Compromise doesn’t mean ‘learn and change, when you’re wrong’, it means giving up an idea you know is correct in favor of an idea you know is incorrect, for the sake of joining someone’s cause or having them join yours. " (me, a couple of hours ago)

If you want a reason why I wouldn’t vote for Rand Paul, my reason is exactly the same as Kyle Haight’s in Post #9, and David’s a few posts earlier.

Those are reasons he is not ideal but not reasons that he is the worst candidate possible. There is an implicit assumption in your view, that it would be impossible for his opponent to be worse. If you can’t vote for a candidate with mixed principles than there is no justifiable way to vote in almost any election.

IMO, not voting for a candidate like Paul is not an absolute for Objectivists. There is a context where I could imagine voting and maybe even campaigning for Paul, namely if he were running against a candidate who was likely to win and was comparable to Adolf Hitler or Mao Zedong, i.e. if the alternative is TEOTWAKI.

I would add,

…Or if their opponent shares the same mixed principles on abortion and not free markets as is the case with Trey Grayson.

Peter Schiff is pretty damn close. He’s running for CT Senator as a Republican. Look into his commentary on everything from social issues to the economy to foreign policy… he’s the best we’ve got. A pro-choice, capitalist, non-religious entrepreneur with sensible foreign policy views.

I’m familiar with Peter Schiff but he is not running against Rand Paul.

Those are reasons he is not ideal but not reasons that he is the worst candidate possible. There is an implicit assumption in your view, that it would be impossible for his opponent to be worse. If you can’t vote for a candidate with mixed principles than there is no justifiable way to vote in almost any election.

I’d still vote if there was something specific I was looking to prevent. (For instance, voting for Scott Brown helped prevent that “super-majority” the dems were gonna use to cause a lot more damage than they can now, for one year)

But that doesn’t make Scott Brown a better candidate that that silly lady he won against, in the overall context of advancing the cause of freedom. If anything, his pretense that he is fighting for freedom makes him worse. Same is true for Rand Paul, but even more so.

I’m familiar with Peter Schiff but he is not running against Rand Paul.

Your question did not ask about politicians who ran against Rand Paul, so I think my answer was appropriate.

Your question did not ask about politicians who ran against Rand Paul, so I think my answer was appropriate.

I apologize for my lack of clarity then. I meant respond to Jake’s comments regrading Rand Paul specifically, which has a certain context which I mistakenly viewed as self-evident.

Are we just going to go on exchanging questions in a never-ending series?

Do you think it would be a good idea to continue?