Kentucky Senate race development

I discovered this in the news this morning from Rueters:

http://www.reuters.com/article/pressReleas…2009+BW20091104

BOWLING GREEN, Ky.–(Business Wire)–

Bowling Green ophthalmologist and long-time taxpayer activist Rand Paul is

leading the field for the Republican nomination for United States Senate,

according to the latest poll results. The survey, conducted by ABC affiliate

WHAS out of Louisville, shows Dr. Paul beating former frontrunner and beltway

insider pick Trey Grayson 35-32 percent.

The son of Ron Paul is out in front early in the Republican primary and leading all Republican and Democratic candidates in recent polling. Can this be considered a postitive development?

I discovered this in the news this morning from Rueters:

http://www.reuters.com/article/pressReleas…2009+BW20091104

The son of Ron Paul is out in front early in the Republican primary and leading all Republican and Democratic candidates in recent polling. Can this be considered a postitive development?

I think so. Rand Paul has some of the more desirable positions of his father but is not pro-life, I believe. And seriously, what non-crap candidates have we seen from the Repugs in awhile? If someone like Rand Paul can win as a Republican the party may not be completely worthless after all.

I think so. Rand Paul has some of the more desirable positions of his father but is not pro-life, I believe. And seriously, what non-crap candidates have we seen from the Repugs in awhile? If someone like Rand Paul can win as a Republican the party may not be completely worthless after all.

Eh. Sorry, but he’s definitely pro-life.

http://www.randpaul2010.com/issues/a-g/abortion-2/

I believe life begins at conception. I recognize the most basic function of government is to protect life. It is unconscionable that government would facilitate the taking of innocent life. I strongly oppose any federal funding for abortion and will always vote to protect life.

He’s just as confused as his father with respect to the abortion issue. Luckily for us, though, he has a much better foreign policy position than his dad:

Defending our Country is the most important function of the federal government. When we are threatened, it is the obligation of our representatives to unleash the full arsenal of power that is granted by and derived from free men and women.

Our supreme law, the Constitution, enumerates certain powers for the federal government. Primary among them is national defense.

The Constitution explicitly grants Congress the power to declare war. As James Madison wrote, “The Constitution supposes, what history demonstrates, that the executive is the power most prone to war. The Constitution has, therefore, with studied care vested that power in the legislature.”

However, in the face of an imminent nuclear attack or in response to an assault, the executive [Presidential] branch can and should make military responses without Congressional authority. After 911, an immediate raid by 10,000 Special Forces on camps in Afghanistan would have been justified by the executive, even if the decision was made in secrecy.

But, any military action that takes more than a few days or weeks to organize and is directed against a country’s government should require a declaration of war. When Japan attacked Pearl Harbor, Congress met and declared war within 24hrs.

Congress has had plenty of time to declare war on Afghanistan and Iraq. As a member of Congress, Dr. Rand Paul would have demanded and voted in the affirmative for a declaration of war with Afghanistan. He would have demanded and voted against a declaration of war with Iraq.

He fails the moron test. Continuing with his anti-choice position… “I would support legislation, a Sanctity of Life Amendment, establishing the principle that life begins at conception. This legislation would define life at conception in law, as a scientific statement.”

He fails the moron test. Continuing with his anti-choice position… “I would support legislation, a Sanctity of Life Amendment, establishing the principle that life begins at conception. This legislation would define life at conception in law, as a scientific statement.”

That’s legislation proposed & written by his father:

http://www.covenantnews.com/abortion/archives/034987.html

Ron Paul’s Sanctity of Life Act of 2007: H.R. 2597

2007-2008 (110th Congress) > H.R. 2597

A BILL To provide that human life shall be deemed to exist from conception.

That’s legislation proposed & written by his father:

http://www.covenantnews.com/abortion/archives/034987.html

Sounds similar in concept to the Personhood amendment in Colorado that Diana Hsieh fought so effectively against.

Does a “pro-life” stance override anything else a candidate stands for? Seems that in most other respects he’s quite sound.

Seems that in most other respects he’s quite sound.

Not for the right reasons, I’m afraid. The Pauls are populist libertarians - dead and simple.

Does a “pro-life” stance override anything else a candidate stands for? Seems that in most other respects he’s quite sound.

A ‘pro-life’ position on abortion generally means that a politician allows his political policies to be driven by his religious faith, i.e. that he thinks his faith justifies using force against others. Even if they don’t see the conflict between that and the advocacy of individual rights, the conflict still exists and will have consequences.

Are we willing to let the perfect become the enemy of the good?

Are we willing to let the perfect become the enemy of the good?

Are candidates who support mixed policies on a corrupt foundation an example of the good?

Are candidates who support mixed policies on a corrupt foundation an example of the good?

Is there any other kind of politician to choose from?

Is there any other kind of politician to choose from?

Are we just going to go on exchanging questions in a never-ending series?

Is there any other kind of politician to choose from?

The reason why we don’t have a single good candidate is because everyone seems to agree that political compromise is the only solution. If even a small minority of the people rejected that, there would be some good candidates. They wouldn’t win, so it wouldn’t matter much, but still: citing the absence of uncompromising candidates as reason to compromise is not very logical.

The reason why we don’t have a single good candidate is because everyone seems to agree that political compromise is the only solution. If even a small minority of the people rejected that, there would be some good candidates.

Well, NO, actually… unless of course that “small minority” happens to be refusing to compromise on something that it is *rational* to refuse to compromise on.

We have a far left and a far right that refuse to compromise on, respectively, (leftists) more statism such as government healthcare, and (rightists) abortion already, and they are making matters worse. Much worse. A politician who is willing to compromise can surely be finagled into compromising in a bad way, but he can also be willing to compromise in a good way when he sees it’s in his best interest. Better one of those than a hardcore non-compromiser like US Senator Bennett (D-CO) who is willing to lose his re-election if only he can ram health care down our throat.

Be careful not to make the same mistake as the Libertarians, that brag they are the “Party of Principle” as if that *alone* is a good thing. I hated that slogan even when I was a Libertarian. Party of WHAT principle? The Communist Party is ALSO a “Party of Principle”.

They wouldn’t win, so it wouldn’t matter much, but still: citing the absence of uncompromising candidates as reason to compromise is not very logical.

Well, NO, actually… unless of course that “small minority” happens to be refusing to compromise on something that it is *rational* to refuse to compromise on.

We have a far left and a far right that refuse to compromise on, respectively, (leftists) more statism such as government healthcare, and (rightists) abortion already, and they are making matters worse. Much worse. A politician who is willing to compromise can surely be finagled into compromising in a bad way, but he can also be willing to compromise in a good way when he sees it’s in his best interest. Better one of those than a hardcore non-compromiser like US Senator Bennett (D-CO) who is willing to lose his re-election if only he can ram health care down our throat.

Be careful not to make the same mistake as the Libertarians, that brag they are the “Party of Principle” as if that *alone* is a good thing. I hated that slogan even when I was a Libertarian. Party of WHAT principle? The Communist Party is ALSO a “Party of Principle”.

The fact that there are people who are wrong and refusing to learn and change their minds is not an argument in favor of compromise. Compromise doesn’t mean ‘learn and change, when you’re wrong’, it means giving up an idea you know is correct in favor of an idea you know is incorrect, for the sake of joining someone’s cause or having them join yours. How exactly is that ever *rational*?

The fact that there are people who are wrong and refusing to learn and change their minds is not an argument in favor of compromise. Compromise doesn’t mean ‘learn and change, when you’re wrong’, it means giving up an idea you know is correct in favor of an idea you know is incorrect, for the sake of joining someone’s cause or having them join yours. How exactly is that ever *rational*?

The fact of the matter is you claimed that if only a small minority of people *didn’t* think compromise was a good thing, we’d have better candidates. Fact is, a small minority already refuses to compromise, on *both* ends of the alleged spectrum–meeting your stated condition… and we are much the worse for it.

It matters *greatly* what it is that they won’t compromise on.

The fact of the matter is you claimed that if only a small minority of people *didn’t* think compromise was a good thing, we’d have better candidates. Fact is, a small minority already refuses to compromise, on *both* ends of the alleged spectrum–meeting your stated condition… and we are much the worse for it.

It matters *greatly* what it is that they won’t compromise on.

Your argument (that groups A and B are refusing to compromise, and A and B are bad, therefor refusal to compromise is bad) is logically invalid. Mine, where I explain why rational compromise is a contradiction in terms (because if person A rationally concludes X, he cannot rationally abandon that conclusion in favor of something B proposed) is yet to be challenged. My money is on it staying that way.

No sir, YOUR argument was in fact that a minority of people unwilling to compromise would solve the problem. Go back and read what YOU wrote.

And furthermore I did NOT assert that all lack of compromise was bad, only that lack of compromise was not necessarily good, as you appear to be assuming.

The reason why we don’t have a single good candidate is because everyone seems to agree that political compromise is the only solution. If even a small minority of the people rejected that, there would be some good candidates. They wouldn’t win, so it wouldn’t matter much, but still: citing the absence of uncompromising candidates as reason to compromise is not very logical.

I’m not sure that I understand what you mean by compromise. Do you refuse to vote unless the canidate meets your exact specifications?