Kim Jong Launches Missiles!

Problem is that in this thread we have an individual who claims to adhere to Objectivist principles, yet allows for the indiscriminate killing of innocent civilians of allied states. It’s individuals like this that misinterpret the philosophy and give it a bad name.

Where in the Philosophy of Ayn Rand is the right of self-defense limited by the possibility of unavoidable harm to civilians in allied states? Consider this: the President of the United States is empowered by law to order the shooting down of a commercial aircraft that has been hijacked and poses an imminent danger to Americans in their homes and offices. Are you in accord with the exercise of this option? What if the airliner is from an allied nation such as Belgium and is full of citizens of that nation? Would you favor shooting it down in that case?

If the answer is “yes,” then you have in effect endorsed, in a certain circumstance, the “killing of innocent civilians of allied states.” If the answer is “no,” then you are not in agreement with Ayn Rand’s statement that “Nobody has to put up with aggression and surrender his right of self-defense for fear of hurting somebody else, guilty or innocent. When someone comes at you with a gun, if you have one ounce of self-esteem, you will answer him by force, never mind who he is or who is behind him.” http://www.aynrand.org/site/News2?page=New…cle&id=5138

Note that the above statement is not qualified by any clause mentioning “innocent civilians of allied states.”

Of course they’re different. In the first instance, proper self-defense would entail instantaneous death for the human shields. In the second case, proper self-defense would entail only a bit of fallout which can be avoided by staying indoors, duct taping plastic sheets over the windows, and stocking up on bottled water and iodine pills. The Israelis have been distributing these pills for years. Japan and S. Korea should do the same. After the war’s over, we’ll make the North Korean government pick up the bill for it.

So now your qualifying the defense with the term proper? What is proper now? What are the boundaries that you can go beyond for it to not be proper anymore? How much damage is too much? Turning the entire country into balsite glass as you’ve said we should do is within the bounds of proper? Or would just dropping one bomb on the capital be enough? Or would a ground invasion to remove the military be enough?

No, you are evading reality by the ostrich-head-in-the-sand refusal to confront the genuine threat posed by Korean commies with their nukes and ICBMs.

What nukes and what ICBMs? Do we have any real proof they have nukes other than they say they do? They’ve proven their missile system is something to be desired and has no capability of reaching the US.

Perhaps you mean “Objectivist ethics”? We should never bomb Berlin, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Baghdad or even a single apartment building as long as we have other choices. When other options do not exist, we should not hesitate to knock the holy crud out of them. As we did in World War II, and as the Philadelphia police did in 1985 when they bombed the headquarters of a violent black radical organization. http://www.philly.com/mld/inquirer/news/sp…es/11590721.htm

That bombing was a huge black eye on Philly, and in no way was the way the police handled the situation justified. There were many other options available. If we allowed for acts such as this from our government, next they will simply bomb a bank if it’s being held up.

That is from an essay, “What Is Capitalism?” written in the 1960s. In 1972 Rand clarified her position. In response to a question about the inadvertent killing of Russian citizens opposed to the Soviet regime in a potential war between the U.S. and the U.S.S.R., Ayn Rand said, “When someone comes at you with a gun, if you have one ounce of self-esteem, you will answer him by force, never mind who he is or who is behind him.” http://www.aynrand.org/site/News2?page=New…cle&id=5138 Similarly, I say, when someone comes at you with a missile, you will answer him with force, never mind who is standing within range of the fallout.

Once again she confines that answer to the context of people inside Russia in a war with Russia. Piekoff keeps Rand’s wording from her proper government essay in the OPAR, he did not open it up to indiscriminate killing of anyone, nor did Rand. He confined the use of retaliatory force ONLY to a government and only then because they have objective rules for using that force, not indiscriminate use. A favorite example of placing the blame for killing of innocents is the man with a gun to your head saying kill that person over there. You could kill that person, and ethically blame it on the man with the gun, but you could not then go and kill the 50 people standing in the area and blame it on the man with the gun.

I agree. That’s why I applaud the U.S. for making sure that the number of people in Japan who did not deserve to be consumed in the atomic blasts there was kept to a bare minimum. I’m certain we’ll exercise the same caution when we launch our birds towards North Korea.

But if we have a right to kill them indiscriminately why should we care if we warn them or not? What use is caution?

Of course, we’ll win it. We’ll just keep bombing the commie creeps till they cry “uncle” or cease to exist. It’ll take a couple of weeks at most. Suicide? No way. Suicide would be waiting until Kim and his buds get several hundred nukes and a quiver full of accurate, long-range ICBMs. That would be suicide. As for my means, retaliatory force is always justified.

Yes, I see. We’ll just nuke Russia and China and in a few weeks it will all be over. No chance that anything will happen to the US. Killing over half the human population to subdue Kim will be well justified.

So now your qualifying the defense with the term proper? What is proper now? What are the boundaries that you can go beyond for it to not be proper anymore? How much damage is too much? Turning the entire country into balsite glass as you’ve said we should do is within the bounds of proper? Or would just dropping one bomb on the capital be enough? Or would a ground invasion to remove the military be enough?

Proper self-defense is having a handgun in your home locked and loaded. Improper self-defense is forgetting where you put the dang gun. “Too much damage” is like piling on in football. Once a building is destroyed, you can’t really destroy it again. I never said that all of North Korea should be turned into glass, just those areas above the cozy little bunkers where the korcoms are hiding. Bombing one building ain’t enough. The reason why we lost in ‘Nam is that we were too stingy with our ordnance. We should have hammered Hanoi, broken the dikes, and starved the whole region. If we’d used nukes as Barry AuH20 suggested, Charlie would have surrendered the next day.

What nukes and what ICBMs? Do we have any real proof they have nukes other than they say they do?

If you’re the teller of a bank and a man comes to your window to demand cash, would you first make him prove that the gun was loaded? Would you ask him to fire a round into the ceiling to demonstrate that the gun works?

They’ve proven their missile system is something to be desired and has no capability of reaching the US.

So should we wait until they can drop a payload into San Francisco Bay before taking any action?

That bombing was a huge black eye on Philly, and in no way was the way the police handled the situation justified. There were many other options available. If we allowed for acts such as this from our government, next they will simply bomb a bank if it’s being held up.

It was a heroic action with just the right touch of shock and awe. You may have noticed the conspicuous absence of violent radical black groups in the years since.

Once again she confines that answer to the context of people inside Russia in a war with Russia. Piekoff keeps Rand’s wording from her proper government essay in the OPAR, he did not open it up to indiscriminate killing of anyone, nor did Rand. He confined the use of retaliatory force ONLY to a government and only then because they have objective rules for using that force, not indiscriminate use

In the Ford Hall Q & A, Ayn Rand was asked a question about Soviet Russia, but her answer contained a general principle about aggression and the moral response to it. She said, “When someone comes at you with a gun, if you have one ounce of self-esteem, you will answer him by force, never mind who he is or who is behind him. If he is out to destroy you, that is what you owe to the sanctity of your own life.”

She did not say, “When you are living in the Soviet Union and someone comes at you with a gun . . .”

It would be absurd to infer that the word “you” in her response applies exclusively to Soviet citizens.

A favorite example of placing the blame for killing of innocents is the man with a gun to your head saying kill that person over there. You could kill that person, and ethically blame it on the man with the gun, but you could not then go and kill the 50 people standing in the area and blame it on the man with the gun.

Agreed. So what we do is first kill the man with the gun to our head (Kim Jong Il).

But if we have a right to kill them indiscriminately why should we care if we warn them or not? What use is caution?

A matter of politeness. It’s like putting up a sign in a convenience store to let pacemaker patients know that microwave ovens are operating on the premises. That way you get fewer corpses on the floor, and it’s generally better for business.

Yes, I see. We’ll just nuke Russia and China and in a few weeks it will all be over. No chance that anything will happen to the US. Killing over half the human population to subdue Kim will be well justified.

You haven’t offered any reason for us to suppose the Chicoms and the Russians are going to stick their necks out for Kim and his basketcase country.

You haven’t offered any reason for us to suppose the Chicoms and the Russians are going to stick their necks out for Kim and his basketcase country.

Not for North Korea. The fact that America would have displayed its willigness to use nuclear weapons enmass to ensure total and complete vicotory, would mean that the leadership in Moscow and Beijing will realize that the US has had a fundemental policy change. They would reach the conlclusion that since they know that they are not on the US’s list of allies, they their very survival is threatened. And so will feel that they have no choice but to stop Washington with maximum force before more harm is done to them.

The day we get an operational anti-ballistic shield is a day I look forward to.

Secondly, the first obligation of a U.S. government is to defend U.S. citizens–not South Koreans, not Taiwanese, not the unfortunate “innocents” who might be caught in a crossfire. The grotesque concept that one must never wage a war of survival as long as an “innocent” might be harmed is one of the most self-crippling, self-abnegating notions ever devised in our post-Kantian world.

While thinking about this issue today, I came the conclusion that its ridiculous to write off Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan the way that you do. I am enriched by those countries in so many ways, economically, socially, personally. I would argue that almost every American is as well. It is desierable to maintain them. The US economy would be unecessarily harmed by their loss, and Americans would be wrongfully deprived. This is not the same as a museum in Baghdad with cultural artifacts which unfortuantely may have to fall victim to our artillery, that is unavoidable. I know that we can avoid having to subject Japan and South Korea to unecessary fallout, and unecessary nuclear weapons from the DPRK.

The day that those nations also get an anti-ballistic missile shield will also be a very good day, the sooner the better.

Proper self-defense is having a handgun in your home locked and loaded. Improper self-defense is forgetting where you put the dang gun. “Too much damage” is like piling on in football. Once a building is destroyed, you can’t really destroy it again. I never said that all of North Korea should be turned into glass, just those areas above the cozy little bunkers where the korcoms are hiding. Bombing one building ain’t enough. The reason why we lost in ‘Nam is that we were too stingy with our ordnance. We should have hammered Hanoi, broken the dikes, and starved the whole region. If we’d used nukes as Barry AuH20 suggested, Charlie would have surrendered the next day.

The problems with Vietnam and Korea where far and beyond just the amount of ordinance we used, I’m not even going to go into those issues right now. The point of discussion is not about how much ordinance is used, but the excessive and indiscriminate use of ordinance without any regard to who it damages. If we are to totally wipe out North Korea and make sure it can never threaten us, what stops us from just bombing the whole country? You say we’d be in our moral rights to do it, what would make us not?

If you’re the teller of a bank and a man comes to your window to demand cash, would you first make him prove that the gun was loaded? Would you ask him to fire a round into the ceiling to demonstrate that the gun works?

There is a difference between a man brandishing a gun in front of you and saying that he had a gun on him. In N Korea’s case, all available evidence that I can find released to the public says they are several years off from being able to do anything of the sort to be a direct threat to us, far from some immediate threat that demands immediate annhilation. We have time to prepare a proper attack plan, not resort to whatever means we can.

So should we wait until they can drop a payload into San Francisco Bay before taking any action?

Before we resort to nuking the country, yes. I’d rather have us try the other options available to us. It is a pre-emptive strike, not an act in self defense.

It was a heroic action with just the right touch of shock and awe. You may have noticed the conspicuous absence of violent radical black groups in the years since.

It was far from heroic, there was no heroism involved. What was noticed was a definite fear and distrust of the police force in Philly. America is not a terror regime.

In the Ford Hall Q & A, Ayn Rand was asked a question about Soviet Russia, but her answer contained a general principle about aggression and the moral response to it. She said, “When someone comes at you with a gun, if you have one ounce of self-esteem, you will answer him by force, never mind who he is or who is behind him. If he is out to destroy you, that is what you owe to the sanctity of your own life.”

She did not say, “When you are living in the Soviet Union and someone comes at you with a gun . . .”

It would be absurd to infer that the word “you” in her response applies exclusively to Soviet citizens.

She used the analogy in the context of what was being discussed. If she were alive, I’d love to see what her response would be to the question should we bomb all of Europe because Russia is in part of it.

Agreed. So what we do is first kill the man with the gun to our head (Kim Jong Il).

But you said that any deaths incurred are the fault of the aggressor, so why would it be wrong to kill those 50 people? it would be the aggressors fault. What stops you from killing them?

A matter of politeness. It’s like putting up a sign in a convenience store to let pacemaker patients know that microwave ovens are operating on the premises. That way you get fewer corpses on the floor, and it’s generally better for business.

If we’re out to kill them, why be polite, what’s the point? If their deaths aren’t on your hands, who cares?

You haven’t offered any reason for us to suppose the Chicoms and the Russians are going to stick their necks out for Kim and his basketcase country.

The point is not that China would attack us if we attacked N Korea. That is a very real possibility though, since they’ve done so in the past and can not be overlooked. The point is that China would attack us if we caused severe damage to China and Chinese civilians in China when we attacked N Korea, just as Russia would attack us if we caused harm to their citizens in their country when we attacked. Your solution is to nuke them too. My solution is to attack N Korea in such a way as to make sure that doesn’t happen.

Not for North Korea. The fact that America would have displayed its willigness to use nuclear weapons enmass to ensure total and complete vicotory, would mean that the leadership in Moscow and Beijing will realize that the US has had a fundemental policy change. They would reach the conlclusion that since they know that they are not on the US’s list of allies, they their very survival is threatened. And so will feel that they have no choice but to stop Washington with maximum force before more harm is done to them.

Nonsense. Both Moscow and Beijing opposed U.S. intervention into Serbia, a close Russian ally, but did nothing to interfere with U.S. and NATO forces there in 1999. Not even after we bombed the Chicom’s embassy and killed three of their citizens! To suppose they’d put their lives and fortunes on the line for a broken-down runt like North Korea is laughable.

The day we get an operational anti-ballistic shield is a day I look forward to.

In the meantime, we have to rely on offensive weaponry.

While thinking about this issue today, I came the conclusion that its ridiculous to write off Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan the way that you do.

Who’s writing them off? I’m proposing that we rescue them by beating up the neighborhood bully.

I am enriched by those countries in so many ways, economically, socially, personally. I would argue that almost every American is as well. It is desierable to maintain them.

All the more reason we should take down the bully and drop-kick his head till he stops moving.

The US economy would be unecessarily harmed by their loss, and Americans would be wrongfully deprived. This is not the same as a museum in Baghdad with cultural artifacts which unfortuantely may have to fall victim to our artillery, that is unavoidable. I know that we can avoid having to subject Japan and South Korea to unecessary fallout, and unecessary nuclear weapons from the DPRK.

What loss are you talking about? If we wait until the Korcoms have a healthy supply of nukes and missiles, Japan and South Korea will be licking their new master’s jackboots. Then, my fine Mr. Strangelove, you’ll see the real loss when they disappear behind a new Bamboo Curtain.

The day that those nations also get an anti-ballistic missile shield will also be a very good day, the sooner the better.

No doubt. But those nations haven’t even appropriated funds for such a shield. In the meantime, Li’l Kim has a weapons acquisition program that puts Nazi Germany’s to shame.

The problems with Vietnam and Korea where far and beyond just the amount of ordinance we used, I’m not even going to go into those issues right now. The point of discussion is not about how much ordinance is used, but the excessive and indiscriminate use of ordinance without any regard to who it damages. If we are to totally wipe out North Korea and make sure it can never threaten us, what stops us from just bombing the whole country? You say we’d be in our moral rights to do it, what would make us not?

Concern for the overburdened U.S. taxpayer. Nukes don’t come cheaply. A nuke saved is a nuke earned. http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/nati…323_bomb15.html

There is a difference between a man brandishing a gun in front of you and saying that he had a gun on him.

And the difference between a working warhead and a non-working warhead is no more obvious than the difference between a loaded gun and an unloaded gun. So shouldn’t the teller make the robber demonstrate the gun fires real bullets before handing over the cash?

In N Korea’s case, all available evidence that I can find released to the public says they are several years off from being able to do anything of the sort to be a direct threat to us, far from some immediate threat that demands immediate annhilation. We have time to prepare a proper attack plan, not resort to whatever means we can.

Prior to India’s successful detonation of a nuclear device in 1974, the U.S. intelligence community was certain that India was years away from joining the nuclear club. http://www.gwu.edu/~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB187/index.htm

As for “proper” attack plans, the best ones are those that leave the enemy in tiny pieces long before you send in ground forces. The problem with Iraq is that three years ago there was way too little shock and not nearly enough awe.

Before we resort to nuking the country, yes. I’d rather have us try the other options available to us. It is a pre-emptive strike, not an act in self defense.

I keep asking, what other options? “Diplomacy Only Encourages North Korea’s Belligerence.” http://www.aynrand.org/site/News2?JServSes…ws_iv_ctrl=1021

Pre-emptive strikes against a potential predator are not only legitimate but essential acts of self-defense. http://www.prodos.com/archive049Preemptive…ristStates.html

It was far from heroic, there was no heroism involved. What was noticed was a definite fear and distrust of the police force in Philly. America is not a terror regime.

Any action that destroys an anarchistic organization is heroic. The Objectivist Philadelphians I know cheered at the news that that a vile nest of left-wing vipers had been permanently removed from their midst.

She used the analogy in the context of what was being discussed.

Ayn Rand stated a general principle of self-defense. The onus is on you to show why this principle should be applied only to the defunct Soviet Union and to no other situation.

If she were alive, I’d love to see what her response would be to the question should we bomb all of Europe because Russia is in part of it.

Stawman. No one in this thread has advocated the bombing of non-hostile nations. Furthermore, in her lifetime Ayn Rand 1) enthusiastically supported a strong U.S. defense, including its powerful nuclear arsenal and 2) would have been well aware that nuclear weapons, even our own, produce fallout that might unavoidably rain on non-hostile populations.

But you said that any deaths incurred are the fault of the aggressor, so why would it be wrong to kill those 50 people? it would be the aggressors fault. What stops you from killing them?

  1. Frugality. Bullets don’t come cheaply. 2) Waste of time. If the fellow pointing the gun at my head now has a bullet between his peepers, I don’t have to stand around popping off random passersby.

If we’re out to kill them, why be polite, what’s the point? If their deaths aren’t on your hands, who cares?

Live South Koreans buy more U.S. goods than dead ones.

The point is not that China would attack us if we attacked N Korea. That is a very real possibility though, since they’ve done so in the past and can not be overlooked. The point is that China would attack us if we caused severe damage to China and Chinese civilians in China when we attacked N Korea, just as Russia would attack us if we caused harm to their citizens in their country when we attacked. Your solution is to nuke them too. My solution is to attack N Korea in such a way as to make sure that doesn’t happen.

We only have to nuke China if it sticks its nose in. But the Chicoms, knowing that a little fallout will cause far less harm than a torrent of U.S. missiles aimed at Beijing, will wisely stay the heck out.

Nonsense. Both Moscow and Beijing opposed U.S. intervention into Serbia, a close Russian ally, but did nothing to interfere with U.S. and NATO forces there in 1999. Not even after we bombed the Chicom’s embassy and killed three of their citizens! To suppose they’d put their lives and fortunes on the line for a broken-down runt like North Korea is laughable.

We didnt use nukes in Serbia, and both powers had no interests in that region. Russia was far to concerned about recovering from their time as Communists to be able to seriously contemplate stopping NATO, and Beijing can have diplomatic protests, but really don’t care about that mess in the Balkans enough to go to war over it. For a government that routinely kills its own people for political purposes, a few lost diplomats is hardly a matter of concern for Beijing.

Using nuclear weapons on the Asian mainland however, scares the hell out of Beijing, using them enmass to guarantee that every unit hiding under a hill and mountain is killed, will raise serious concerns in Moscow and Beijing. Do you think that the Chinese people (who these days are more nationalistic and are becoming more fascist then communists) are just going to want their government to sit idle as America rains down hell fire? Do you think that the PLA’s generals, who are already itching for a war with America, will be able to tolerate just standing by? Russia would have less incentive then China, but Mr. Putin is no friend of ours and he has a slight stake in this issue. With America showing a new lack of restraint with regards to their nuclear arsenal, Moscow will have a very strong incentive to react and do something about it.

If anything, fighiting any sort of conventional war with North Korea is less likely to get Beijing involved then the pounding the penninsula with weapons. (which is what we would need to do if we want to destroy the army with missiles for reasons about North Korea’s defensive strategies which have been brought up already) Beijing would lack the pretext to be able to use nuclear weapons against us, and though I expect that they will try and take North Korean territory as well, which is a problem, they certainly wont extend the war further then necessary on that front. They try and do something about Taiwan, but we have an American fleet there to force them to declare a full war on us, something they do not want to do because they know that will bring a full response.

We have to remove North Korea’s existance. This is a given. Its important how we do it.

How long have you been involved in Objectivism? Recent discovery, or for a longer period of time? (I wont hold either against you, just curious)

Concern for the overburdened U.S. taxpayer. Nukes don’t come cheaply. A nuke saved is a nuke earned.

  1. Frugality. Bullets don’t come cheaply. 2) Waste of time. If the fellow pointing the gun at my head now has a bullet between his peepers, I don’t have to stand around popping off random passersby.

Live South Koreans buy more U.S. goods than dead ones.

So in your view of ethics, when defending yourself, keeping the costs down, and make sure we still have some people alive to trade with are what determines where the extent of collatoral damage rather than human life?

And the difference between a working warhead and a non-working warhead is no more obvious than the difference between a loaded gun and an unloaded gun. So shouldn’t the teller make the robber demonstrate the gun fires real bullets before handing over the cash?

What non working warhead?

Prior to India’s successful detonation of a nuclear device in 1974, the U.S. intelligence community was certain that India was years away from joining the nuclear club.

So we no longer go off of what we can objectively determine, we only go off what we feel. I feel N Korea has nukes and is going to shoot them at us, lets nuke them all. We couldn’t figure out that India was close, so we obviously can’t figure out N Korea is close, so lets kill them because they might be.

As for “proper” attack plans, the best ones are those that leave the enemy in tiny pieces long before you send in ground forces. The problem with Iraq is that three years ago there was way too little shock and not nearly enough awe.

Fine, bomb them a bunch first. There’s ways of doing it without nukes and without pissing off neighboring states or killing their population.

I keep asking, what other options?

I gave one.

Pre-emptive strikes against a potential predator are not only legitimate but essential acts of self-defense.

No they aren’t. Potential does not make it so.

Any action that destroys an anarchistic organization is heroic. The Objectivist Philadelphians I know cheered at the news that that a vile nest of left-wing vipers had been permanently removed from their midst.

The ends never justifies the means

Ayn Rand stated a general principle of self-defense. The onus is on you to show why this principle should be applied only to the defunct Soviet Union and to no other situation.

Every instance you’ve put links to (btw, knock that off, I don’t have time to go through all that stuff trying to figure out how it supports what your saying. Make your points.) use that justification in the context of people within the confines of the enemy state. None of them are using it to justify indiscriminate killing.

Stawman. No one in this thread has advocated the bombing of non-hostile nations.

You have advocated that we can bomb non-hostile nations. You have said it does not matter what we do to the surrounding nations, it would be N Koreas fault. We could bomb S Korea, Japan, China, it does not matter if we thought it was in defense of a N Korea threat. We are justified in killing anyone we want to if we feel threatened.

We only have to nuke China if it sticks its nose in. But the Chicoms, knowing that a little fallout will cause far less harm than a torrent of U.S. missiles aimed at Beijing, will wisely stay the heck out.

Um, yeah, that is not how the real world works.

They try and do something about Taiwan, but we have an American fleet there to force them to declare a full war on us, something they do not want to do because they know that will bring a full response.

To clarify, we currently have written legislation where we promise Taiwan’s survival so Beijing does not provoke us there (unless they feel somehow that we would not uphold that commitement) changing our nuclear posture to an offensive, rather then currently a defensive one, would signal to the world that our intent to use nuclear weapons to remove enemies is now policy, which will provide greater incentive for the Chinese to hit the US before they themselves get hit.

We didnt use nukes in Serbia, and both powers had no interests in that region. Russia was far to concerned about recovering from their time as Communists to be able to seriously contemplate stopping NATO, and Beijing can have diplomatic protests, but really don’t care about that mess in the Balkans enough to go to war over it. For a government that routinely kills its own people for political purposes, a few lost diplomats is hardly a matter of concern for Beijing.

If Russia and China had had no interests in Serbia’s fate, they would not have protested NATO intervention there–yet vehemently protest they did. Protests, of course, are cheap compared to all-out nuclear war. When the choice is nukes over Pyongyang or nukes over Moscow or Beijing, Russia and China will wisely choose protest over annihilation.

Using nuclear weapons on the Asian mainland however, scares the hell out of Beijing, using them enmass to guarantee that every unit hiding under a hill and mountain is killed, will raise serious concerns in Moscow and Beijing. Do you think that the Chinese people (who these days are more nationalistic and are becoming more fascist then communists) are just going to want their government to sit idle as America rains down hell fire? Do you think that the PLA’s generals, who are already itching for a war with America, will be able to tolerate just standing by? Russia would have less incentive then China, but Mr. Putin is no friend of ours and he has a slight stake in this issue. With America showing a new lack of restraint with regards to their nuclear arsenal, Moscow will have a very strong incentive to react and do something about it.

If the Chicoms were concerned about public opinion, they would have ended their dictatorship long ago. In any case, you can count on the number of people in China and Russia yearning to risk nuclear armageddon over worthless N. Korea as next to nothing. On the other hand, we should entertain no doubt that the enemies of the United States, the greatest, freest, most noble country on earth, would like nothing better than to see a rogue state like N. Korea launch a war of nuclear terrorism against the Land of the Free and the Home of the Brave.

If anything, fighiting any sort of conventional war with North Korea is less likely to get Beijing involved then the pounding the penninsula with weapons. (which is what we would need to do if we want to destroy the army with missiles for reasons about North Korea’s defensive strategies which have been brought up already) Beijing would lack the pretext to be able to use nuclear weapons against us, and though I expect that they will try and take North Korean territory as well, which is a problem, they certainly wont extend the war further then necessary on that front. They try and do something about Taiwan, but we have an American fleet there to force them to declare a full war on us, something they do not want to do because they know that will bring a full response.

Fighting a conventional land war in Asia would play right into the hands of the enemy. We lost Korea in 1953 and Vietnam in the 1975 precisely because we didn’t use nukes, because we altruistically cared more about the enemy than our own soldiers. I say, “Never again! Korea delenda est!”

We have to remove North Korea’s existance. This is a given. Its important how we do it.

Yes. That means we have to take advantage of our strength, which is possession of the most powerful weapons on earth, weapons created when the mind of man is free to pursue its highest aspirations. To fight war any other way is sacrifice, surrender and suicide–and is unworthy of the nation that spilled its precious blood at Concord, at Lexington, at Gettysburg, at the Marne and at Omaha Beach..

How long have you been involved in Objectivism? Recent discovery, or for a longer period of time? (I wont hold either against you, just curious)

Twenty years.

So in your view of ethics, when defending yourself, keeping the costs down, and make sure we still have some people alive to trade with are what determines where the extent of collatoral damage rather than human life?

No, as an Objectivist, I rank human life above all other values. My human life, that is.

What non working warhead?

The one that will be vaporized once our long, smooth missiles penetrate North Korean air space and spurt great gobs of hot nuclear plasma all over the place.

So we no longer go off of what we can objectively determine, we only go off what we feel. I feel N Korea has nukes and is going to shoot them at us, lets nuke them all. We couldn’t figure out that India was close, so we obviously can’t figure out N Korea is close, so lets kill them because they might be.

Check your premises. It is not a case of feelings. It is a matter of recognizing that taking all threats seriously decreases one’s odds of being victimized. For example, would you forbid U.S. air marshals to shoot anyone aboard a plane who claims to have a bomb or gun unless said weapon has first been objectively determined to work?

Fine, bomb them a bunch first. There’s ways of doing it without nukes and without pissing off neighboring states or killing their population.

We tried the conventional approach in Japan. It didn’t work. Only after a second Japanese city was flattened by the A-Bomb, did the enemy finally come to his senses. Thank Einstein for the A-Bomb! It saved over a million American lives. And thank Edward Teller for the H-Bomb! It will save millions more when we drop it on North Korea.

I gave one.

Sorry. Try again. Objectivism rejects the morality of self-sacrifice, including the sacrifice of a million U.S. soldiers in an Asian land war.

No they aren’t. Potential does not make it so.

If that were the case, no one would be justified in shooting at a man waving a gun and making threats. Your policy of craven appeasement would result in placing moral men at the mercy of the nearest cutthroat.

The ends never justifies the means

Yes, and when a killer is in a position where defense against him can only be accomplished by actions which place innocent people at risk, then taking such actions is supremely moral.

Every instance you’ve put links to (btw, knock that off, I don’t have time to go through all that stuff trying to figure out how it supports what your saying. Make your points.) use that justification in the context of people within the confines of the enemy state. None of them are using it to justify indiscriminate killing.

You have not shown why a risk to people in neutral or allied countries trumps the exercise of self-defense while a risk to people in enemy states does not. If a terrorist is holding a baby and threatening your life, you have the right to kill the baby if that is the surest way to eliminate the threat. It would not matter if the hostage is a N. Korean baby, a S. Korean baby, or even an American baby.

You have advocated that we can bomb non-hostile nations. You have said it does not matter what we do to the surrounding nations, it would be N Koreas fault.

In fact, I argue that we must take the best route to secure our lives and freedom from sea to shining sea, even if that means that some harm may come to our allies. Incidentally, this has been part of U.S. defense policy for decades. Tactical nukes would have been deployed by NATO forces if the Soviets had invaded Western Europe, even though such weapons might have carried unfortunate side effects for the people of Germany, France, et al.

We could bomb S Korea, Japan, China, it does not matter if we thought it was in defense of a N Korea threat. We are justified in killing anyone we want to if we feel threatened.

Strawman. In fact, I never called for the bombing of S. Korea, Japan, or China.

Um, yeah, that is not how the real world works.

Prove it.

Never again! North Korea delenda est!

Wow. I didn’t mean to start such a controversial thread. Only partially on-topic: Kathy Griffin came back to Larry King last night (Monday). <grin>

-Q

PS: To add something of substance: I’m sure there’s a perfectly effective way to take out Baby Kim’s government without putting Japan at risk of collateral damage. I think the value Japan adds to American lives is worth at least a little effort in that direction. And I don’t know the numbers, but I would like to see something on the actual risk of fallout from modern nuclear devices.

To add something of substance: I’m sure there’s a perfectly effective way to take out Baby Kim’s government without putting Japan at risk of collateral damage. I think the value Japan adds to American lives is worth at least a little effort in that direction. And I don’t know the numbers, but I would like to see something on the actual risk of fallout from modern nuclear devices.

Very well, let Japan invade North Korea with its battle-hardened troops, destroy North Korea’s nukes, topple its government and subdue the population while a pro-Western government is being formed. If Japan will not undertake this invasion, the United States of America, land of the Pilgrim’s Pride, has every right to terminate the North Korean branch of the Axis of Evil in the quickest, most efficient manner possible. That is to say,

As for fallout, ground bursts produce a great deal of fallout, air bursts relatively little. Ground bursts would only be required in the case of buried underground targets such as weapons stashes or military bunkers.