I wanted to create a thread to discuss what objective standards, if any, exist for laws codifying public decency. Specifically, I think it would be most interesting to focus on situations where:
* Certain “offensive” behavior is not explicitly forbidden. For example, when one rents a home, it does not state in the lease that one cannot masturbate on one’s front lawn during daylight hours or display a menagerie of visually shocking, mutilated animals on one’s property.
* One is generally engaging in this offensive behavior on one’s own property or in a public venue such as a street that is crowded with pedestrians. Thus, being unwelcome on private property is not an issue to this intended discussion.
* No clear physical bodily harm or property damage to any witnessing party is incurred.
Should such laws exist? How would they be justified? Should one be legally permitted to wander around a downtown area in nothing but an open bathrobe? Should one be allowed to just keep a rotting trash heap on one’s front yard in a residential neighborhood? Should one be legally permitted to blast loud music in a downtown area?
I think the answer to all of these is no, but I am curious to how one should justify this answer.
Anyway, I apologize if this thread is redundant. I have quoted a pertinent post by Dan Edge’s from a thread from current events below. Please note that he is being quoted in the context of whether parents should be permitted in having sex infront of their children.
I agree that objective standards are needed here. I haven’t reached a conclusion on this issue, but I lean towards the view that it is child abuse to force your children to watch pornography. I also think it would be abuse to force your child to watch scenes of torture or extreme violence. I’m trying to hash out what my gut is telling me. I think I need to understand the concept of legal consent more fully, and how it applies to children. In many contexts, it would be illegal to have sex in plain view of others without their consent. Children are not old enough to give that consent. Here’s my reasoning:
In American law, it can be a punishable offense to play music so loud that it affects your neighbors (assuming you are in a residential neighborhood). Even though you are acting on your own property, your actions affect other people’s property. It is assumed that your neighbors do not consent to this noise unless consent is expressly given. Loud music (beyond a certain volume) is thought to be outside the realm of acceptable sounds coming from a house in a residential neighborhood.
The same principle applies to actions which affect senses other than hearing. If you move into a residential neighborhood and begin producing chemicals that create a god-awful smell, for instance, this could be considered a nuisance to your neighbors. Your neighbors could seek a court order forcing you to stop. If you hung a mutilated horse corpse in your front yard, this could be considered a visual nuisance, and the court could force you to move it. When you move into a residential neighborhood, there is an implicit consent that you will not do these sorts of things.
If you moved into an industrial neighborhood, then it would be assumed that you consent to the smells, sounds, and sights associated with that kind of neighborhood. You couldn’t move in to such a neighborhood and immediately report the chemical company next door as a nuisance. Your case would be thrown out of court. When you move into a residential neighborhood, however, it is understood that you must gain the neighbor’s consent before taking actions that would impact their sensory experience of their own property in a negative way. This, I believe, is the spirit of nuisance laws, and they are ethical laws.
By this principle, it could be considered a nuisance to have sex in your front yard in a residential neighborhood. Doing this is similar to playing excessively loud music; you must gain the consent of all surrounding property owners who could be affected by this kind of action. The same is true for other “public” places.
Consider a Burger King restaurant. It is implied that Burger King consents for you to walk onto their property during normal business hours, placing orders, using their bathrooms, and many other things. However, Burger King could prosecute you if you and your wife walked in and started having sex on the counter. It is implied that they do not consent to this kind of action, even if they fail to post a “No Shirt, No Shoes, No Service” sign. For this to be legal, you would have to gain the consent of the Burger King owner. Further, if you get a job at Burger King and agree to a one year employment contract at Burger King, you do not necessarily give your consent to work in the nude, or be exposed to nude co-workers or customers.
I have offered evidence for the case that in many contexts, it would be a punishable offense to have sex in plain view of others without their consent. It is clear that children are incapable of consent in the adult sense of the word. In some contexts, a child’s powers of consent are delegated to his parents (eg., a parent can legally “ground” a child). In other contexts, consent is considered to be withheld until the child is old enough to decide for himself (eg., neither the child nor the parent can consent to sex with the child). What is the difference between these two contexts? I don’t have the time to go into it right now. But consider: If a child’s consent is required in order in order to have sex in plain view of him, then is this a consent delegated to the parents? Or is this consent assumed to be withheld until the child is of appropriate age? My gut tells me the latter.
–Dan Edge