Let’s not forget we are talking about Massachusetts here. You cannot extrapolate to America from the state that hates America the most.
This was my point essentially in my initial reply, although I don’t know if Mass hates the country any more than several other including Cali., NY, and my own great state of Michigan.
Overall the voters and taxpayers should vote with their feet. Luckily we still have the freedom to move within the United States (although maybe Taxachusetts may outlaw this soon as well) and businesses and businessmen should start looking at other options as far as new places to do reside.
This is a little off-topic but I read a story a couple of years ago how Mass tried to sue New Hampshire and force them to enact an alcohol tax because they claimed that they were “losing revenue” because their residents were crossing state lines to buy their alcohol in N.H. since there is no tax. It’s insane. :dough: I’ve used that emoticon a lot today…
The full impact of the law will be clear once people have studied the (145-page) bill. For, now, after skimming some of it, here is my summarized understanding of the plan [E&OE]:
Of a population of 6.3 million, MA has about 530K people with no health-insurance and who are nevertheless not covered by the government’s “MassHealth” scheme. I’m guessing these are people who aren’t poor enough to qualify for government [Medicaid] coverage, but are poor enough not to afford their own coverage.
Chances are that many of these people do without some healthcare and go to emergency rooms for other healthcare. Sometimes serious health problems bankrupt these people; but, often costs end up being paid for by the government or by private insurers to whom costs are “passed”.
The new plan hopes to do the following
Cover an additional 92,000 children under “MassHealth”, by raising the eligibility from 2-times the poverty level, up to 2-times ($38,000 for a family of 2, $48,000 for a family of 3, etc.)
Cover an additional 210,000 people under a new scheme, named “Commonwealth Care Health Insurance Program” (CCHIP), which will be a state-run health-plan. [see below]
To ensure that people are covered, the law mandates that all citizens must have coverage. If they do not have it through their employers, or through Medicaid etc., they will have to get it privately or through CCHIP. Those who do not will forfeit the Mass State Tax exemption. (From what I can tell, the exepmtion is $3500 and the tax-rate is 5.3%; so, this is a penalty of about $185 for the year.) In later tax-years (2008?) the penalties for not buying coverage will be much more steep
This new Commonwealth Care Health Insurance Program will work as follows:
Those at 1-time the poverty level or below will pay ZERO premium and have ZERO deductible (est. 65,000 individuals)
Those under 3-times the poverty level will pay will pay premiums on a “sliding scale”, according to their ability to pay. The state will subsidize the rest. They will have a ZERO deductible (estimated 150,000 individuals)
Others [215,000 individuals], who are not eligible at these income-levels, and who do not currently have employer coverage will have to buy their own coverage, as stated above.
Each employer of more than 11 people [or the equivalent of 11 full-time workers, in terms of hours], will pay $300 [well $295] per employee [or per 2000 employee hours] per year, to the plan. This will be known as the “Fair-share” charge.
The government will record healthcare subsidies and uncovered charges provided to employees of such employers. If the total charges for in any year are over $50,000, the employer will have to pay a “Free Rider Surcharge”. The amount of the surcharge depends on how many other employees were employed, how much healthcare they used, and so on. The exact calculations are yet to be set forth. (I’m fuzzy on the details here; it might have purposely been left a bit fuzzy.)
To ensure that people are covered, the law mandates that all citizens must have coverage. If they do not have it through their employers, or through Medicaid etc., they will have to get it privately or through CCHIP. Those who do not will forfeit the Mass State Tax exemption. (From what I can tell, the exepmtion is $3500 and the tax-rate is 5.3%; so, this is a penalty of about $185 for the year.) In later tax-years (2008?) the penalties for not buying coverage will be much more steep
I’m still trying to figure out the math but I think I’ve got a decent grasp. I still think it may very well be a LOT cheaper to just cut all your employees healthcare. My employer has close to 2000 employees and we have a self administered health plan. Actually, doing that is a bit risky but if your company is relatively young and you don’t have a large number of expensive claims, it’s much cheaper and better for everyone. I think the cost per employee for a couple is around $200 or $300 a month. The company I seem to remember picks up the overwhelming majority of the cost still.
So I can’t see why an employer from a straight fiscal standpoint wouldn’t cancel private insurance. Mind you, that is completely ignoring the costs associated with having sick employees who get poor state run healthcare, the added cost to out-of-work time associated with either state run clinics/hospitals and the handful of private doctors that would accept the insurance. One of my clients says a good 30% of his staff does nothing but deal with private insurance companies. Forget about dealing with medicare/medicaid. Actually, having decent private healthcare would be a real selling point.
That’s one of the reasons so many doctors are tranistioning to ala carte healthcare for their patients. Like Canada is experiencing now, the wealthy who can afford ala carte or traveling to the US for treatment are getting good treatment. I wish people would realize that added government controls just result in an
Let’s not forget we are talking about Massachusetts here. You cannot extrapolate to America from the state that hates America the most.
Yet another reason the term “Masshole” should remain in use. When I take my trip out there in a couple months, I’ll have to put on an extra coat of statist-block.
Hmmm…so no high deductible plans allowed…so they are cutting out choices, so they will only have high premium insurance plans…not very smart.
Interesting article.
Unbelievable. I lived in NH for most of my life, but at one point, had health insurance on a MA plan…it was crazy to deal with. I wonder how many companies close to the NH border will finally jump ship and go up to the income tax and health insurance tax free zone. NH has its own set of problems, but at least it doesn’t smack businesses and individuals down for not having health coverage (yet…I hope that is never!)
Here’s some horror stories from the model country when it comes to totally “Free” healthcare - Sweden:
A man got his leg amputated because a hospital failed to treat him in time. The man, who suffered from diabetes, received no treatment despite the obvious risk of gangrene that followed from his poor blood circulation. The subsequent investigation, set up by the hospital’s owner, put out a warning to the two doctors involved, stating that the man would still have his leg had he been treated in time.
A hospital has on its own account investigated into the possibilities of premature deaths among patients waiting in line for a by-pass surgery. For those that aren’t lucky enough to end up in what the hospital determines to be the “fast lane,” the waiting time is about 4½ months. It was found that during the 4 years of 1995–1998, 77 patients died while waiting in line. The conclusion of the study was that perhaps the hospital needs to coordinate its activity on a national level with other hospitals of the same ownership. In that way, they would be able to better judge who were going to end up in the fast lane (and, thus, who wouldn’t).
After having had to wait for a long time, a man was told by a hospital that he had cancer and that the tumor was malignant. It could neither be treated by surgery nor in any other way. – This tumor will kill you, he was told. He was offered the necessary pain relief. Fortunately, the man was very wealthy. He just got on a plane and flew to a place where these kinds of tumors could be treated. He had surgery in a couple of days, and instead of the prospect of death after only 45 days in the care of the first hospital, he now can look forward to many more years of living.
When it was time to give the twin birth, a pregnant woman and her husband, living in a small town, were told that there were no beds available at the hospital. This particular hospital was in the neighboring town, since they had already earlier been refused to give birth in their hometown. However, the hospital had made a general promise that they should be able to give birth somewhere. They were taken to the famous hospital in a larger city about 150 km away, but also there they were refused to give birth, despite the fact that it had the same owner. Instead the hospital sent them abroad by helicopter to another hospital with a different owner, but with which the first hospital had some kind of agreement. When they finally arrived, it turned out that the twins were stillborn.
After this tragic event, the hospital refused to fly the couple back to their home country or hometown. The hospital only arranged for helicopter in emergencies, and when the necessary care in relation to a child’s birth is finished, the hospital has no obligations, they where told. Instead, the unfortunate couple had to arrange with flight tickets back home. Normally, deceased persons are generally transported in a sealed zinc coffin in the trunk of the airplane, but as the couple didn’t want it that way, they instead were provided a small coffin that was put in a bag. The airline company, that happened to be the property of the owner of that foreign hospital, acted courteously and left two rows clear in front of the grieving couple. Well back home, the hearse the hospital had promised didn’t arrive, so the couple had to take a taxi to get all the way home.
The subsequent investigation, set up by the hospital’s owner, reached the conclusions that the behavior of the hospitals, from a medical point of view, had been correct. In retrospect, the investigation could also conclude that the quality of the reception when the couple arrived back home with the flight could have been better. Another conclusion was that the outcome of the birth itself wasn’t affected by the fact that the couple had been sent to a hospital in another country, but that this admittedly must have been strenuous for them. Finally, the investigation stated that the hospital had to find new routines for how to handle complicated international flights in general.
You can’t go to a private doctor in Sweden, even if you could still afford to do it after paying 102% taxes - private practices are illegal down there…
There’s also the example of the U.K. – there are people from there who go all the way to India to be treated. One can understand someone from the U.S. getting treated elsewhere, to save money. However, when someone turns down a free operation and flies a few thousands of miles from home, one can conclude that they aren’t thrileld with their free healthcare.
However, when someone turns down a free operation and flies a few thousands of miles from home, one can conclude that they aren’t thrileld with their free healthcare.
You get what you pay for… (and not even that, in this case, because you are paying some serious taxes for crap service)
This isn’t limited to Mass. Here in Arkansas the governor decided socialist health care would be a great idea and began legislation to get the ball moving.
We are already 49th in everything except taxes, there we are around 11th per capita, thanks in part to this former Babtist preacher’s stance that those who have money have a responsibility for paying the ways of those without, no matter why they are without. After all, that is what Jesus would want.
He is a Republican, and he is running for president.
This is only the begining. Too many parasites in this nation will give their support to those who promise the unearned wealth of others, while those who know it is evil will remain silent out of fear of being called raciest, or cruel, or un-Christian, for polititians not to take advantage.