“ANNAPOLIS, Md. - Maryland legislators voted Thursday to enact a first-in-the-nation requirement that Wal-Mart Stores Inc. spend more on employee health care. The measure, touted as a money-saver for the state-supported Medicaid program, takes effect despite the governor’s veto of the bill.”
Apparently the bill doesn’t say Wal-Mart specifically, but that’s who it’s pointed at:
“The bill requires companies with more than 10,000 Maryland employees to spend at least 8 percent of their payroll on employee health care or pay the difference into the state’s Medicaid fund. Of the state’s large employers, only Wal-Mart spends less than 8 percent on health care.”
Please God don’t let this survive an equal protection challenge, assuming Wal-Mart has the stones to fight.
Regarding the equal protection challenge, I have a post here that describes the framework a little bit. Simply put, to prevail on an EPC claim under federal law Wal-Mart would have to show that the challenged law is not “rationally related” to a “legitimate governmental interest.” Though it’s not completely a rubber stamp, this standard is pretty deferential to legislatures.
I haven’t thought of what other grounds Wal-Mart might have on which to challenge.
I voted in the poll on the page you linked. The question was " Should Wal-Mart be required to pay for health insurance for employees who cannot afford it?" Out of 7811 responses, 70% said that “Yes, large companies who do not help pay for health care are taking advantage of Medicaid.”
If Wal*Mart does not fight this, they’d set a dangerous precedent. Also, the way it is framed – to target them – it is not something they can shrug off as hitting their competitors equally and therefore not eroding their relative competitiveness.
Businesses are run by people with typical ethics. They think that giving customers a good deal is good, but not in the ethical sense. To be considered really moral, they invoke other things (see this list).
I think these businesses really do not know how to fight back. They firmly think that the good they do outweighs the bad/ However, in framing the issue like that, and accepting that (in their minds), they give the enemy the sanction he needs.
Problem is that the 8% may not be very high. If Wal*Mart looks at their Maryland based payroll and health and see that it is already 6%, they may be tempted to take the pragmatic approach. However, I think their top management that can see beyond that, to the longer-term possibility of further raises.
Other large firms would be wise to contribute to the fight.
I was wondering: as a work around could Wal-Mart or the Board of Wal-Mart set up a subsidiary company or a new company not under the Wal-Mart umbrella and use that company to hire, pay and fire employee’s? Basically let Wal-Mart outsource some of the jobs to themselves, just enough to keep thier state payrolls under 10,000 people. Either way it sucks but this could possibly give them a way out.
Also, if this law prevails - today it’s 10,000 employees and 8%, tomorrow it’s 1,000 employees and 10%, and the day after that it’s 10 employees and 20%. And not just Maryland, but other states as well. Once a principle has been established the rest is just a matter of time and mere quantities. Let’s not forget that the original income tax was 1% of everything over $1,000,000, which was more like $100,000,000 in today’s money.
"We believe that everyone should have access to affordable health insurance. This legislation does nothing to accomplish that goal. "There are 786,000 uninsured people in the state of Maryland and less than one-half of one percent work for Wal-Mart. Clearly, the legislators who voted for this bill have let down hundreds of thousands of Marylanders in need.
"More than three-fourths of Wal-Mart associates have health insurance. And every Wal-Mart associate in Maryland – both full-time and part-time – can become eligible for health coverage that costs as little as $23 per month.
"This vote was never about health care. This was about partisan politics in the Maryland gubernatorial race. In allowing a bad bill to become a bad law, the General Assembly took a giant step backward and placed the special interests of Washington, D.C. union leaders ahead of the well-being of the people they serve. And that’s wrong.
"The American people know that catering to the special interests does nothing to help the 46 million uninsured individuals in this country. Now is the time for legislators across the country to work together to find real solutions to the health care challenges facing every state, every business and every working family.
“It’s time for Washington, D.C. union leaders to stop their attacks, and let working families decide where to shop and work.”
If it is going to cost an employee $23 a month, then it would cost Wal*Mart something similar to pick up the tab. They might be tempted to do so, without much more of a fight.
Edited to add: I wonder if Wal*Mart offers HSAs, at least fighting back structurally.
“The bill requires companies with more than 10,000 Maryland employees to spend at least 8 percent of their payroll on employee health care or pay the difference into the state’s Medicaid fund. Of the state’s large employers, only Wal-Mart spends less than 8 percent on health care.”
The way it is worded, it looks like it would simply force a larger percentage of employee salaries to be in the form of health care. Not that it would make them pay more money out to employees overall. (unless they refuse to spend 8 percent on health care)
Lost in all this is the fact that every percentage point put into health care is necessarily taken out of wages, bonuses, or pensions. So the employee would receive ZERO from this arrangement; they’d just have less spending money. Tell that to a healthy person who doesn’t need more health care but can’t pay the rent.
I am so sick of this national obsession with health care. Whatever happened to CASH?!? With cash, you can spend it on health care if need be. But “health benefits” don’t pay the rent or put food on the table.
I voted in the poll on the page you linked. The question was " Should Wal-Mart be required to pay for health insurance for employees who cannot afford it?" Out of 7811 responses, 70% said that “Yes, large companies who do not help pay for health care are taking advantage of Medicaid.”
Not good, but I take some consolation in the fact that the survey is non-scientific. I don’t listen to MSNBC, and I think most people who do would be inclined to vote for more government controls.
Also, keep in mind that’s a blue state.
Hope I don’t have on rose colored glasses here. :lol:
p.s. I listened to Edwin Locke’s lecture on Wal-Mart in which he said he was in contact with management about defending them against unions.
It is the voters who have created the current situation, where cash is often not better than health-care. There are two main thrusts to this:
Laws that treat company-funnelled contributions to health-care as pre-tax.
Laws against rational discrimination
1. Tax-breaks & other laws: Viewed in an individual case, the effect of the tax break may seem like a certain percent (say 20% - 30%). However, it’s more than that. By consistently pushing the healthcare industry away from individual consumer choice, voters have created a situation where the whole industry is now geared to that framework. Doctors are known to turn down patents who are willing to pay cash, if they don’t have insurance. Hospitals practice discriminatory pricing that is not there simply because they’ve freely negotiated with insurance firms. Rather, voters have created a situation where it is inconvenient for the hospitals to work outrside the insurance-firm framework. Consequently, if you get a procedure at a hospital and say you will pay for it privately, you will typically be billed about 3 times what someone else’s insurance firm will be billed. [i have seen private bills as high as 8 times what is billed to insurance firms.]
Hospitals are forced to treat people who come to their emergency rooms and have no money. They build in an expectation of non-payment into their prices, and pass the buck on to insured people. Indeed, in the Wal-Mart case, the view of some businessmen is this: if WalMart is forced to divert more payroll to health-care, that keeps some people off mediaid; but, it also lessens the free-riders who land up in hospitals, do not pay, and have their expenses billed (effectively) to private insurers.
In short, the voters’ push toward group healthcare has resulted in a status quo where cash is not king, and many special interests have been created. MSAs didn’t put a dent in that. Hopefully, HSAs will have an impact. They’re the only type of incremental change that could improve the system structurally.
2. Rational Discrimination: Voters do not like the idea of people being denied insurance for rational reasons – e.g. if they have some disease. Without the ability to discriminate, insurance firms figure that the only way to prevent “self-selection” by consumers is to restrict their coverages to groups that are defined in such a way that does not pre-dispose them to a considerably higher incidence of health-costs..
Rush Limbaugh had a pretty good commentary on this subject. This is one area where Rush shines: free markets. He loves the free market and is very passionate about it. If he’d only drop that religion!
RUSH: Yeah, that was my original idea, to tell them to do that, just leave, just go to some state right on the border of Maryland and open the store there and so forth. I think we’ve talked about this at great length on this program. This is nothing else, it’s nothing other, than a government-sanctioned rape. This is a government-sanctioned rape of an American business. Maryland lawmakers bucked the will of the Republican governor and the nation’s largest retailer yesterday voting to become the first state to effectively require that Wal-Mart spend more on employee health care. We just had hearings into all-powerful Supreme Court, you gonna take away a woman’s right to choose, you going to do that, and you going to do this. What the hell is going on in the state of Maryland?
It won’t happen, but I’d love it if Walmart fired all of its MD employees and pulled their operations out of the state. The company should send everyone a little note with their last paycheck telling them they can thank the state legislature for being on the unemployment rolls.
Maybe a more workable solution would be to have Walmart simply cut every employee’s pay by the amount of the increased healthcare expense. A note telling them to thank the state legislature for the pay cut would still be fitting.
Ultimately the voters of MD are responsible for this kind of thing. It’s not as if this is the first indication that MD voters favor socialism. After all, MD is the state that has given the US Senate Babs Mikulski and Paul Sarbanes, not exactly two consistent supporters of individual freedom and limited govt.
The way it is worded, it looks like it would simply force a larger percentage of employee salaries to be in the form of health care. Not that it would make them pay more money out to employees overall. (unless they refuse to spend 8 percent on health care)
Lost in all this is the fact that every percentage point put into health care is necessarily taken out of wages, bonuses, or pensions. So the employee would receive ZERO from this arrangement; they’d just have less spending money. Tell that to a healthy person who doesn’t need more health care but can’t pay the rent.
I am so sick of this national obsession with health care. Whatever happened to CASH?!? With cash, you can spend it on health care if need be. But “health benefits” don’t pay the rent or put food on the table.
Idiots!
Inspector,
I completely agree with your sentiments here. The obsession with everyone having health insurance is what has driven the cost up. Insurance payments to health care providers are essentially fixed by the government. Insurance payments to health care providers are based on Medicare fee schedules which are determined exclusively by the Federal government. Every private insurance company bases its provider reimbursements on Medicare rates. Since these fees are completely controlled by the government, they are NOT the source of health insurance premium increases. The cause of increases is exclusively a result of what health insurance companies think they can charge. If more money is infused into the health insurance market by health insurance “mandates,” it increases health insurance demand. As a result, it increases the price.
In other words, the “price” of health insurance is NOT rising because of increased “costs” (with the exception of pharmaceuticals.) It’s rising because of increased demand for health insurance. Insurance companies have essentially fixed costs, due to the relationship of provider reimbursements to Medicare fee schedules. In contrast, the premiums they charge businesses and consumers are largely unregulated. The increase in health care “costs” is due exclusively to insurance companies charging higher premiums to increase profits. Again, it is NOT because of increased payments to providers. Price increases are a “demand” issue, not a “cost” issue. By artificially increasing the demand for health insurance through private mandates (as well as government employee provided health insurance), the price has skyrocketed while the costs have increased little.
All that being said, the Walmart issue creates a different problem. Without a health care insurance mandate, Walmart forces the government to subsidize the health care expenses of its employees. In effect, it’s receiving a taxpayer-funded giveaway by allowing the government to pick up the tab for the health care of its employees. As such, it seems reasonable to mandate that they contribute to either the state Medicaid fund or provide private insurance.
I don’t like the idea of health insurance “mandates” at all. It drives up the cost of health insurance. However, it’s even worse when a company receives an indirect government subsidy by allowing the state to pick up the tab for its employees’ health care. It’s even worse when it’s an extremely profitable, competition-stifling, American job killing company like Walmart.
Without a health care insurance mandate, Walmart forces the government to subsidize the health care expenses of its employees. In effect, it’s receiving a taxpayer-funded giveaway by allowing the government to pick up the tab for the health care of its employees. As such, it seems reasonable to mandate that they contribute to either the state Medicaid fund or provide private insurance.
How is Walmart different from any employer that doesn’t provide healthcare benefits to its employees? I don’t see why they should be singled out in Maryland. Hell, why not just require every single employer to provide health insurance? And how about a requirement to pay workers a living wage as well? Something on the order of say $75,000 or $80,000 per year maybe? Why not make it $100,000 per year? The cost of living keeps increasing and I’m sure people who work at Walmart must be having a hard time making ends meet.
I don’t like the idea of health insurance “mandates” at all. It drives up the cost of health insurance. However, it’s even worse when a company receives an indirect government subsidy by allowing the state to pick up the tab for its employees’ health care. It’s even worse when it’s an extremely profitable, competition-stifling, American job killing company like Walmart.
You seem to be attacking Walmart because the state of MD has a screwed up system of providing govt. subsidies for health care. You also call Walmart “extremely” profitable. I wonder if you’re aware that the company’s net income, which was in the range of $10.8 billion on $305 billion of sales, is about a 3.5% return on sales? Walmart has also created far more employment and wealth in this country than it has “killed”.
I think his point is that WalMart has not subsidized it enough. His point is that the government is subsidizing Wal*Mart by giving Mediaid to Wal*Mart employees. (sigh!)
I think his point is that WalMart has not subsidized it enough. His point is that the government is subsidizing Wal*Mart by giving Mediaid to Wal*Mart employees. (sigh!)
Without a health care insurance mandate, Walmart forces the government to subsidize the health care expenses of its employees. In effect, it’s receiving a taxpayer-funded giveaway by allowing the government to pick up the tab for the health care of its employees.
It’s like a person beating his wife while saying: “See what you’re making me do!”
Dropping the metaphor… People who hold this view are saying that if Wal*Mart gives poor people jobs, it is also obligated to give them whatever else the government would give them if they were jobless. Yes, “absurdly false” is accurate.
I don’t like the idea of health insurance “mandates” at all. It drives up the cost of health insurance. However, it’s even worse when a company receives an indirect government subsidy by allowing the state to pick up the tab for its employees’ health care.
This problem has a very easy solution. The government should simply end all forms of support for health care. That way, each company has to decide for itself whether it will offer a health plan as a recruitment inducement, and there could be realistic labor competition between e.g. Target and Walmart with each employer offering the best possible health benefits at the lowest cost.
I was wondering: as a work around could Wal-Mart or the Board of Wal-Mart set up a subsidiary company or a new company not under the Wal-Mart umbrella and use that company to hire, pay and fire employee’s? Basically let Wal-Mart outsource some of the jobs to themselves, just enough to keep thier state payrolls under 10,000 people. Either way it sucks but this could possibly give them a way out.
Would not it be poetic justice if Wal-Mart did the same thing they did when the Canadians tried to push unions on them: close the shops and move?
I can almost see this happening: Maryland without Wal-Mart. Certainly would be a case of Atlas Shrugging. :rolleyes:
I lived in Maryland for 16 years and this kind of nonsense doesn’t surprise me, former mayor Glenn Denning (Democrat) was known as “the governor of the dead” because that is where he got most of his votes from. Next to Chicago the entire state of Maryland has one of the most corrupt political systems in the country (yes, I think they’ve even got New Jersey beat) and also one of the most idiotic, simpleton-ridden, moronic population in the entire Union. Frankly I’m surprised that they actually elected my former Representative (the current Mayor, who is actually a decent man) as the current Governer.
If I was Walmart I would do exactly what Rush Limbaugh recommend they do, and afterward I’d send a letter to the Maryland legislature telling them to kiss their sales tax base goodbye.