Men & Women, Love & Sex

How does it work the other way? What do men look for in women, then? This is where the problem of definitions comes up. Are there specifically “female” attributes, other than Rand’s defintion of femininity (i.e., the worship of metaphysical masculinity)?

The mind of course is the biggest attractor–for either sex in regard to the other–or should be. But as for specifically female attributes, I would say beauty is one. The female form is a beautiful one. The male form is not so much beautiful as it is inspiring in some heroic way, which is a different kind of beauty, I suppose.

I think on the male part it is a worship of

  1. her mind

and

  1. her femininity.

A relationship is an exchange of the masculine and the feminine as well as an exchange of values. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with the conclusion that Carla deduced:

They both worship eachothers minds and the values those minds hold, and the female worships the male’s masculinity and the male worships the female’s femininity. It’s not that the male worships her because she worships him, but for the reasons that she does so.

I think the difference between Instinct and Reflex is simple: An instinct leads to a certain behaviour, reflex creates a certain uncontrollable physical movement.

Animals have instincts and reflexes. Man has only reflexes. We have no universal code of behaviour that is irresistable and uncontrollable.

I think the difference between Instinct and Reflex is simple: An instinct leads to a certain behaviour, reflex creates a certain uncontrollable physical movement.

It is important here to emphasize that an instinct is considered to be an undefined innate cause of complex behavior, whereas a reflex is a rather specific physiological response to a stimulus.

Animals have instincts and reflexes.

I do not consider instincts to be any more meaningful when applied to animals, than when applied to man. The complex behavior of animals is explainable in terms of identifiable mechanisms that interact with the environment, not by any supposed innate cause called an instinct.

We have no universal code of behaviour that is irresistable and uncontrollable.

True, except for our love of women, fast cars, and dogs. :lol:

True, except for our love of women, fast cars, and dogs. :lol:

Yes, and in that order.

Furthermore, if femininity is to worship masculinity, what is a man’s relationship to a woman? That is, does he, as a man, worship her femininity? That clearly doesn’t make any sense, for to do so would, by Rand’s definition, mean that he worships her worship of him. Why doesn’t Rand talk about heroine-worship? Frankly, I don’t think she believed such an attribute could exist.

The essence of femininity is hero-worship; the essence of masculinity is heroism.

To be a hero is to be successful in life as a man: to create wealth, to overcome evil, and to have a beautiful and lovely woman as a partner in life.

Thus, the things that a man looks for in a woman is beauty (including sexual attractiveness), loveliness, and partnership in his efforts to create wealth and overcome evil. The better a woman is at these things, the greater her chances of winning the heart of a heroic man. A woman who excels at these qualities is a heroine, and her man will, perhaps not worship, but certainly adore and admire her for it.

The essence of femininity is hero-worship; the essence of masculinity is heroism.

CapFor, I think what you’re saying may be the most accurate interpretation of Rand’s point of view (that I’ve heard), but I’m finding it extremely uneven.

From this line alone, the essence of masculinity–heroism–is “to be a hero”; that is, to live as a hero. Fine. But that femininity is to worship such a hero seems to mean that the man acts and the woman worships. Now, I’m even reminding myself of feminists here, but that’s not what I’m trying to get at. What I mean is: The definition of masculinity seems to cover everything in a man’s life; while the definition of femininity could (I think) only refer to part of a woman’s life–her romantic life. Perhaps this lopsidedness is acceptable, but something seems very out of order about it to me.

To be a hero is to be successful in life as a man: to create wealth, to overcome evil, and to have a beautiful and lovely woman as a partner in life.

This is exactly what a woman should want, too (changing “beautiful and lovely woman” to “handsome and strong man”).

Thus, the things that a man looks for in a woman is beauty (including sexual attractiveness), loveliness, and partnership in his efforts to create wealth and overcome evil. The better a woman is at these things, the greater her chances of winning the heart of a heroic man. A woman who excels at these qualities is a heroine, and her man will, perhaps not worship, but certainly adore and admire her for it.

Placing the woman in the position of “partner” here seems to imply that the woman is a secondary supporter to her lover’s primary goals, is this what you are saying?

As a woman–rather, as a human–I strive to be productive, to create wealth, to gain knowledge, and to overcome evil. I do not wish to be a partner to a man who is doing this, I wish to do it myself. Of course, if I find that being a partner–in a different sense–to anyone, man or woman, will further my goals, I will engage in such a partnership for that reason alone.

I may be misinterpreting your words, but it seems to me that your definitions place the woman in the place of “assistant”–she may be indispensable to the man, but still, she is not the primary mover in the goals she is working towards.

At this time, unfortunately, I have not formulated a full definition of my own, but in my view, a relationship between a man and a woman is one essentially of equals. Each has his or her own goals, and perhaps they work together, but only for the sake of furthering goals they both believe in, not because one is a man and one is a woman. I am not implying, of course, that the man and the woman are of equal physical strength or necessary equal in other ways, but that they treat one another equally, with neither playing any sort of “assistant” role.

I had to write this post rather quickly, so please do ask me to clarify if there’s anything I’ve left amiss, and do let me know if /how I’ve misintepreted your post.

Rand’s definition of femininity being what it is, I’d like to ask what is wrong with the following two-part statement:

A. In order for a woman to be feminine, she needs to look up to a man, and…

B. It is not necessary for a man to have a woman in order for him to be masculine.

No matter how many qualifiers are tacked onto Objectivist definitions of sex/gender roles (“the woman looks up to the man but not from an inferior position ,” etc.), there would still seem to be an imbalance between the two sexes.

Am I incorrect if I say that “being feminine” is “acting in accordance with ones nature as a human female,” or that “being masculine” is “acting in accordance with ones nature as a human male?” If my definitions hold up, then how can the nature of one sex depend on the worship of an individual of the opposite sex while the other sex’s nature require no such dependence, without it being plainly stated that the two sexes are not, for lack of a better word, “equal?” If A requires B but B does not require A, then how can they be on the same level?

I’m a little ashamed to be asking these same kinds of questions again, especially given the helpful and insightful comments from Ms. Speicher and others on another related thread here.I’d just really like to know whether or not my hesitance to embrace the Objectivist outlook on sex roles is simply a manifestation of the last shred of my public-school indoctrination stubbornly refusing to exit my brain. :lol:

Or failing that, I’d like to be confident that I do in fact understand the Objectivist outlook on sex roles-- because as it is, everything I read seems to say, “Mens’ nature is to be heroic, womens’ nature is to look up to men.” If that’s the case, then I can’t possibly imagine what it’s like to be a woman and to be told that in order for me to act in accordance with my nature I must find a heroic man and look up to him-- the whole “every individual is an end in his/herself” thing would seem to fly in the face of that.

Not long ago, Betsy explained here that Rand’s definition of femininity applied ONLY to a woman’s relationship to a man, and not to her individual identity. The problem I’m having is that other Objectivists don’t consistently make that distinction, and more importantly, that the accepted definition of masculinity seems to apply not only to a man’s relationship to a woman, but to everything about his life. The equation would look like “Masculinity > Femininity.” Unequal. So, are men ends in themselves all the time, while women are ends in themselves except in their relationships with men?

Oops-- It looks like Carla nailed the point of my long, rambling post right here:

What I mean is: The definition of masculinity seems to cover everything in a man’s life; while the definition of femininity could (I think) only refer to part of a woman’s life–her romantic life. Perhaps this lopsidedness is acceptable, but something seems very out of order about it to me.

That’s more or less what I was trying to say. I would only add that if there is indeed a lopsidedness, then why is it acceptable?

Yes, and in that order.

The main problem is combining all three. The first fits well into the second, but the third keeps scratching the leather! :smiley:

True, except for our love of women, fast cars, and dogs. :smiley:

You forgot man’s true best friend - the remote control. :slight_smile:

Now, I’m even reminding myself of feminists here, but that’s not what I’m trying to get at. What I mean is: The definition of masculinity seems to cover everything in a man’s life; while the definition of femininity could (I think) only refer to part of a woman’s life–her romantic life. Perhaps this lopsidedness is acceptable, but something seems very out of order about it to me.

I think you have to very clear on the context here. Miss Rand is referring to feminity as a basic psychological state, how a woman sees herself in relationship to man. Ayn Rand makes clear that in every important respect the woman should be the intellectual and moral equal to her man. Her feminity is the recognition of a metaphysical distinction, one which embodies all the value she places on man and which she primarily reserves for the particular man she loves.

You forgot man’s true best friend - the remote control.  :slight_smile:

Do they make one to turn on women?

Rand’s definition of femininity being what it is, I’d like to ask what is wrong with the following two-part statement:

A. In order for a woman to be feminine, she needs to look up to a man, and…

B. It is not necessary for a man to have a woman in order for him to be masculine.

No matter how many qualifiers are tacked onto Objectivist definitions of sex/gender roles (“the woman looks up to the man but not from an inferior position ,” etc.), there would still seem to be an imbalance between the two sexes.

There is, but it is not a matter of superiority and inferiority. It is a matter of difference. Men and women have different sexual natures.

Am I incorrect if I say that “being feminine” is “acting in accordance with ones nature as a human female,” or that “being masculine” is “acting in accordance with ones nature as a human male?”  If my definitions hold up, then how can the nature of one sex depend on the worship of an individual of the opposite sex while the other sex’s nature require no such dependence, without it being plainly stated that the two sexes are not, for lack of a better word, “equal?”  If A requires B but B does not require A, then how can they be on the same level?

Maybe making an analogy will explain it. Let’s say Joe sells Mike some milk for $1. Which was worth more, the money or the milk? Who got the short end of the deal? The fact is, they BOTH got more than they put into the deal and they both benefitted because they each wanted different things. Joe wanted the money more and Mike wanted the milk more.

Likewise in romance, men and women want different things. The man wants to possess the woman and the woman wants to be possessed.

I’d just really like to know whether or not my hesitance to embrace the Objectivist outlook on sex roles is simply a manifestation of the last shred of my public-school indoctrination stubbornly refusing to exit my brain.  :slight_smile:

I doubt it. I suspect it’s because feminine psychology is something that’s so different it’s hard for a guy to identify with. I just got an e-mail from a fellow I discussed this with over ten years ago. At the time he was dubious about what I had to say. Since then he has had a lot more experience with women and he thanked me for helping him make sense of it all.

Not long ago, Betsy explained here that Rand’s definition of femininity applied ONLY to a woman’s relationship to a man, and not to her individual identity.  The problem I’m having is that other Objectivists don’t consistently make that distinction, and more importantly, that the accepted definition of masculinity seems to apply not only to a man’s relationship to a woman, but to everything about his life. 

It DOES. That’s the main difference between men and women.

As MAN – i.e., as a human being – both men and women are value pursuers. Men are value pursuers ALL the time. Women are value pursuers in everything EXCEPT their romantic lives. In love, they are the value PURSUED.

The equation would look like “Masculinity > Femininity.”  Unequal.  So, are men ends in themselves all the time, while women are ends in themselves except in their relationships with men?

You learn fast. :smiley:

the Objectivist outlook on sex roles

I don’t have too much to add at this moment, but I wanted to respond to this one tiny point in Geoff’s post. I’ve heard before–and I believe, have seen discussed on this board before–that Rand’s discussion of masculinity and femininity are properly in the realm of pschology, not philosophy. Moreover, her explicit statements regarding the subject (in "About a Woman President) were basically side commentary. Given these two points, Rand’s views on the subject are just that–her opinions–and not an essential point of her philosophy. Therefore, while many Objectivists may agree with her, her writings on this subject do not represent the Objectivist viewpoint.

In other words, we can call ourselves Objectivists, or students of Objectivism, and yet disagree with Rand on this point.

Betsy and Stephen have pretty much done my replying–and better than I would have–so let me just add one point:

When I say “partnership,” I do mean partnership: The man and the woman both have the same goal–the creation of wealth–and their relationship is a trade which allows them to work towards that goal more efficiently. The particular skills they bring into the partnership will depend on the individual man and woman, but from what we know about the nature of men and women in general, we can say that the man’s contribution is likely to include his physical strength and that “confidence” Bearster has mentioned on the Woman President thread, while the woman’s contribution will likely include (but not be limited to!) her beauty and pleasantness, her capacity to bear children, and similar things.

So the leading partner is likely to be the man–that doesn’t make the woman any less heroic than he is, for the same reason that a star programmer isn’t any less heroic than his project manager: What she does is essential, and she does it extremely well.

A. In order for a woman to be feminine, she needs to look up to a man, and…

B. It is not necessary for a man to have a woman in order for him to be masculine.

To be a hero is to be successful in life as a man: to create wealth, to overcome evil, and to have a beautiful and lovely woman as a partner in life.

I don’t remember where I’ve read this exactly, but I remember that when somebody asked AR if what a man felt for a woman wasn’t Woman Worship she said she guessed it was…

Can anyone refresh my memory?

You learn fast.

Heh, if only. :slight_smile: Thank you, though, for explaining it in further detail. I’m not yet sure how to wrap my brain around the imbalance there, but I’m still holding out hope and trying my best…

I’d only like to ask one more thing (for now): Capitalism Forever, you said-- “To be a hero is to be successful in life as a man: to create wealth, to overcome evil, and to have a beautiful and lovely woman as a partner in life.”

I take this to mean that I can’t be a hero (“be masculine”) without having a woman as my partner in life, unless we apply the same logic to this as we applied to “being feminine,” that is, the characteristics we’re naming and defining are only relevant to a man’s relationship to a woman… in which case, it seems kind of redundant to say, “In order for me to be a hero-- the characteristics of which include having a woman-- I must be in a relationship with a woman.”

…or are we all agreeing that “femininity” applies only to her relationships and “masculinity” applies to everything in his life? If that’s the case, I should be able to be a masculine hero even if I’m single and don’t have a beautiful and lovely woman as a partner in life.

Right?

(I’ve got to apologize for the constant “what? huh? duh? what do you mean?” that I’m pulling here… it’s just that I’m trying to attack this thing from every angle to convince myself it’s airtight. When I first read “About A Woman President” a few years ago, it was (and still is) the ONLY piece of Rand’s writing that I found myself actively disagreeing with.)

Do they make one to turn on women?

They do; it comes in the form of a little bit of chivalry and a sincere smile.

Nice shoes don’t hurt, either. :slight_smile: