This is my response to some socialists on another forum. Please tell me if you think I hit the nail on the head or not. My name is ^Guardsman^, btw
Where does one draw the line on allowed personal freedoms and the betterment of society?
I give you personal freedom and rights when applied to crime.
The personal rights of criminals appear to be at the forfront, as the laws are infringing on their personal freedom. Never mind the betterment and productivity of the society, pay attention to the rights of the individual.
My point being, when the rights and personal freedoms of the individual takes precedence over the society and it’s prosperity, things tend to get messy.
Okay, society is comprised of many many indiciduals, correct? How can something be good for “the public” while still conflicting with an individual’s rights? This individual is part of the public. Personal rights of “criminals” are there for the wrongfully accused. You are innocent until proven guilty, and to treat otherwise is to assume, and to assume makes an ass out of you and me (hahaha play on words).
One should consider the words of the Late great JFK. “Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country”
I take this to mean, sure enjoy your liberties and freedoms, but not at the expense of the society.
With that assumption, you are saying that rights are granted to you by the government, which violates the concept of rights. Rights are absolutes. You have a right to Life (to prolong and enhance by your own effort), Liberty (to have your freedoms protected from those who would take 'em away) and Property (a right to keep what you earn).
JFK’s quote assumes that government grants you your freedom, which is wrong, ESPECIALLY from a president that should be abiding by the US Constitution which contradicts directly with that quote
Therein, I find from observation, is the problem with Capitalism and open-free markets. What’s to stop a person from ammassing a large amount of wealth and power and infringe the rights of others by screwing them over? Squeezing out the little guy. With a govt. controlled market, it is ensured that everyone gets a fair chance.
Whats to stop such a person? This is where a responsible government comes in. First, understand that capitalism is a system of contracts. You give me A, I give you B, and we stay loyal to this agreement or mutually withdraw. If such a person were to attempt to screw everyone over, the government must pursue legal action against such a person, as he violated the property rights of the other individuals.
Gov’t controlled markets make sure the little guy has a chance at the expense of the big guys. The big guys, who make our skyscrapers, our planes, our electricity, our defenses, our food and our factories, these are the people who are extorted by the government so Joe Schmoe can get a university education, based on the assumption that since he could not achieve his own moral value on his own (which would be gaining a good education), others must be extorted to provide for him. Thats slavery.
Remember Pol Pot’s communist regime? He started by killing all the “big guys”, all the people taking the country into a progressive future. The scientists, the literate, the inventors, all felled by the muscle of the almighty worker
As well as the blaise attitude that health care should be parcelled out as a commodity. That Old age pension should be a nerchandise. You end up, in a free market with minimal govt. control, a group of people who with money can afford the best treatment and will be well taken care of in the old age.
Leaving the less successful desperate to eke out a meager living, fighting for survival. Lords ruling over the peasants.
As we know “they who have the most gold makes the rules”
Such a statement you said above would be circumvented by a government that protects property rights. You assume a capitalist system would defraud people, but fraud is a violation of property rights and should be punished by the government.
“they who have the most gold makes the rules” wouldn’t apply in a minarchist state. A government should have 3 primary responsibilites: To provide a police and military to protect the property rights of the individual, to provide a court system for which to handle disputes in a rational matter, and a government to lay down the law and punish violations of law (preferably a system based on a strictly interpreted form of the US Constitution, IMHO)
personal self interest over collective betterment. A very dangerous concept.
I prefer much, the socialist concept. An elected body of representives, answerable to the collective, but at the same time ensuring that the society is taken care of, that it progess’s, and not at the expense of the commom people.
Answerable to the collective. The collective is a majority, correct? Using that definition, the 51% would be allowed to utterly exploit the other 49% because more people, the collective, said so.
If I’m not correct in that analysis, what is to say the “collective” is fit to run everything. People with no formal education working as janitors and whatnot are allowed to say how whole factory chains should be run? People who cannot provide food even for themselves when free are supposed to be able to ration food wisely to everyone else? A collectivist government would end only in a miasma of short sightied decisions intent on catering to he who shouts the loudest.
A republic, which abides by an Objective code of laws, would be obliged to protect the rights of those 49% or those people who go against or would not benefit from the collective. And if thats not the case, people should be allowed to bear arms as to protect their property that others have unrightfully claimed the privellege to seize.
Capitalism breed eliteism. Elitsim breeds resentment. Resentment breeds anarchy and violence. These are a detriment to any progressive, forward thinking society.
All people should have access to good health, safe haven, and qaulity life. Not just the select few who can afford it.
Its not capitalism that breeds elitism. Its he who has the most force. Elitism can be bread in a total slave society, a society of giant government, or an anarchist region, just because the uppermost class wields all the force. When you have a government that intervenes against the INIAITION (not the retaliation against) of force, this elitism cannot be bred.
(The current version of the forum software does not properly format posts that have more than 10 quotations. So, I have split the post into two. That has made it easier to read. The second part is below. - SoftwareNerd)