In Objectivism, ‘truth’ or certainty or any knowledge whatsoever is in extricably linked to a context, whatever that may be. Objectivism rejects any form of a priori, or non-contextual knowledge while also rejects any attempt at subjective knowledge or ‘truths’ apart from the facts of reality.
But surely you believe that, in all possible contexts, the law of non-contradiction applies.
This is one point in Objectivism I don’t agree with. We must agree that there are certain propositions which are either true or false simply by the meaning of the proposition. For instance, ‘There is a round square.’ Contrary to Peikoff’s response to the tautology, ‘All bachelors are married males,’ there is no way to deny that there is a round square by saying that the class of round objects includes no squares. You cannot go through the entire class of round objects, ideal or otherwise, and discover that none of them is a square. The class is far too large. Nor need you do so. The falsity is contained in the meaning of the proposition. What it means to be round and what it means to be a square are mutually exclusive. The same is true of any sentence of the structure, ‘P is true, while at the same time not-P is true in the same sense.’
My question to Peikoff’s response to ‘All bachelors are married males,’–in which he contrasts this statement with the statement ‘All bachelors are less than nine-feet-tall,’–is how do you know what a bachelor is? If the way to determine the truth or falsity of such a sentence is to go through the list of bachelors and find out what properties some, all, or none share, what is your list of properties that allows you to distinguish a bachelor from a fire hydrant? Surely you must know that, if and only if, something is an unmarried male then it is a bachelor. But it is not the case that if and only if something is less than nine-feet-tall, then it is a bachelor. The property of being an unmarried male is an essential, defining, necessary, and sufficient property of bachelors, so you know in advance of knowing anything else about the class of bachelors that they are unmarried males. You need not investigate the matter any more than to understand the proposition. On the other hand, there is nothing contained in the meaning of the word ‘bachelor’ to restrict height, except insofar as, perhaps, ‘bachelor’ refers only to men, and ‘man’ might have some height restrictions (For instance, would we consider a group of beings who are like us in all ways except 50-feet-tall to be humans? My guess is, no.).
And I don’t find that this contradicts anything essential in Objectivism. That there are, in a sense, walls around the realm of our knowledge is nothing terribly earth-shattering. We recognize that humans are limited. One limit is that we cannot think outside the realm of logic–that to try to do so is senseless folly, and an attempt to renounce our humanity. It is like trying to prove existence by non-existence, prove consciousness by means of unconsciousness. We simply must accept these walls as a home, rather than a foe. To yearn for knowledge of the non-logical is a mark of existentialists. As such, I reject the Kantian interpretation that this invalidates a priori truth. To try to judge logic as anything other than true is to try to get some kind of “objective” (small ‘o’), non-human perspective on it, in which you stand neither inside nor outside of logic, but rather you stand above everything and look down upon it to make a judgement–by what means if not logic? To me, this is the beginning of existentialism itself. Something from a nothing. Nothingness as a genuine reality and recourse. In my judgement, the Objectivist answer to the analytic/synthetic dichotomy is not to reject the categories of knowledge, but to reject that one or the other, or both are not true knowledge.