I cannot disagree more with the idea that the Coen brothers (or this movie) are nihilistic. Maybe you have to look at it in the context of other Coen brothers movies, to understand that they are going for a dark sense of humor, with this whole psichopatic character, who murders without feeling guilt. I certainly found Bardem’s character funny, just like the psichopats in Fargo or The Ladykillers.
Warning! Spoilers ahead**.**( the blackout thing is hard to read, skip my post if you haven’t seen the movie yet. I do recommend it.)
Not to mention the fact that every single Coen movie I saw is a morality tale. In other movies the evil characters all die, usually killed by off by the psichopath, who then dies by the hand of Justice, be it a cop or faith. (in Ladykillers Hanks dies by accident, if I remember correctly)
In “No Country for Old Men” they do shake it up a bit, but Brolin’s character(and Harrelson’s too, if I remember correctly) most definitely pay for their sins at the hands of Chigurh, whom I see as an agent of faith, which the Coen brothers tend to equate to justice. (hence the coin toss) It is the right kind of justice though.
As for the ending, its open to interpretation. Mine is this:
Chigurh was an “angel of death”, part of nature rather than a human being. He’s basically an automaton (or an animal, incapable of judgment)
The fact that he makes it is a social commentary. Our society doesn’t have the ability (or more likely the right, knowing the Coen brothers) to stop this kind of evil anymore.
I’m leaning toward this explanation for good reason: I know Coen brothers films. You cannot be nihilistic, or amoral, and have a fight between good and evil in every single movie, at the same time. The Coen brothers have proven themselves many times before, including in this movie, and they deserve the benefit of the doubt with this open ending. I wish I had seen the movie more recently, and been able to have more details to back up my theory. The critics who call them nihilistic simply don’t have the knowledge to judge this film properly.
[edit]
Spoilers over.
To sum it up. for those who don’t want spoilers:
The Coen brothers find evil interesting, but also funny (ridiculous) and above all: pointless, destined to fail.