Notes on “Art of Thinking” by Dr. Leonard Peikoff
applying Objectivist epistemology to one’s own thinking
topics covered intensively elsewhere (OPAR, Understanding Objectivism) omitted {from this course, not the Notes}
Lecture I Volition as a means to clarity
LectureII Thought as Integration - Hierarchy
LectureIII Thought as Integration - Essentials
LectureIV Thought as Integration - Principles
LectureV Certainty
LectureVI Thinking vs. Writing
Lecture I Volition as a means to clarity
Volition is exercised in the choice to focus
Volition is also involved in changing the method of thought
Merely perceiving new material does not blast out old contradictory material
ex. Learning typing when you already have a long established 2-finger technique. Old technique is automatized, must bull through discomfort and disorientation while learning the better method.
definition of Objectivity is “volitionally adhering to reality by following certain rules of method, a method based on facts and appropriate to man’s form of cognition” {from OPAR}
This point then is an application of the principle of Objectivity.
Clashing Contexts - when only one of two contradictory contexts can be active in the mind.
After thoroughly learning and proving to oneself that only one of the contexts is correct, an act of will is/could still be required to banish previously automatized knowledge.
Do not entertain or indulge doubts from an invalid context, when you know that context and the feelings of doubt are invalid.
Disintegrate falsehoods while integrating truths.
Feelings of plausibility can be wrong. When they are, suppress them (acknowledge then set aside, not repress which is refusal to acknowledge)
ex. LP’s grad school experience shuttling between pragmatist context of school and Objectivist context of Ayn Rand.
ex. LP’s ten years of saying “existence exists” before feeling the clarity of its refutation of Descarte’s Cogito statement.
ex. Student knew religion was irrational but had memories, experiences of concretes, emotional pull of interacting with religious people who were ‘reasonable’. Counter:
*method of proselytizing distinguished from content of doctrines
*man is conceptual so arguments are required, even dictators have propaganda
Then use will.
This technique is an application of Objectivity, so it cannot be used to make yourself believe any old thing.
This is not an attack on “Devil’s Advocate” argumentation, which is a very useful method when still trying to reach complete understanding.
One cannot achieve clarity on a new context by continually reviewing and attending to the old.
One point/context can be proved even though neither/none are felt convincing. Suppress the wrong context until the correct context is automatized.
Learning one new principle will not disable a prior context.
Divided context is like a doctor treating himself. Don’t let patient have equal time operating on the doctor.
There is no neutral or earlier ground upon which to resolve the contradiction between contexts.
Parallel: grieving for the dead. Reminders keep coming up because you automatically relate things to the now missing person. Fact of the death is not enough to stop your brain from working in that way.
Free will is clinging to a known truth in the face of your own doubts, because of evidence.
Faith is clinging to an idea in the face of your own doubts, lacking or in spite of evidence.
Intrinsicist demands faith.
Subjectivist is skeptic, indulges feelings of doubt.
Objectivist willfully adheres to the truly known.
Audience questions:
Binswanger: Don’t dismiss a question unless it comes from a wrong context. LP -When you have intellectual certainty you can identify the premises of a question.
Locke: Application to psychotherapy. Not therapist’s fault you don’t drop your bad ideas and habits. LP - Deautomatization is a goal of therapy, achieved by disintegration.
Some guy: Debating as learning? LP - Interact with other people holding the opposing context while gaining intellectual certainty, and after you have clarity. In the middle stage of shunning the false context, don’t engage in debate.
Applications:
Origin and Edge of the Universe questions.
Primaries. “Everybody hates primaries”
Free will. “why did he choose that choice?”
“Why?” can be asked incorrectly.
“How do you know you aren’t wrong?” Skepticism.
Reiteration of correct context is necessary but not sufficient. Banishment of wrong context is required.
Delayed gratification involved here. Achieving clarity can take time.