I always liked Ducktales as a child. The whole story of Uncle Scrooge coming from Scotland and earning his fortune through hard work really appealed to me (an immigrant myself). Little did I realize I was on my way to finding Objectivism. Here’s a question…is an Objectivist made or born? Are there certain things that had to happen in their life to lead them there or could anyone become an Objectivist if they just read Ayn Rand?
I think a lot of the reasons why I loved Ayn Rand’s works were because I already had the foundations for it (from my parents, school, books and events that happened in my life). Please don’t misunderstand this as determinism. I obviously don’t believe in fate. But I do think that there are certain things that happen in people’s lives that lead them in certain directions. I would like to hear everyone else’s thoughts. Did you watch certain cartoons…did you always like science…etc?
My husband, though he is really intelligent and has good values, says will never be an Objectivist (yes…he’s read the books). I think it is because he doesn’t have the same background that I do. At least that is the only reason I’ve been able to come up with.
…is an Objectivist made or born? Are there certain things that had to happen in their life to lead them there or could anyone become an Objectivist if they just read Ayn Rand?
The Jesuits used to say (paraphrasing), “Give me a child for his first seven years and you can do what you want with him after that.” I think there’s a lot of truth to the idea that the first few years of a person’s life have tremendous impact on the rest.
There can be many reasons why a particular person would simply never become an Objectivist. But a child who is a strong valuer, who trusts his mind, and who asks questions about everything shows good promise as a future Objectivist. Whether that promise lasts into adulthood is another matter.
I think there are some things that have to emerge early. An element of pride has to be present early, and I suspect it’s even more important than the other aspects early on. For example children with pride may grow up with a bad start, uneducated, poor, but the pride will drive them to develop their reason, independence, etc., as they grow. Conversely, a child may be taught by their parents to be honest, productive, rational, but without pride, they could abandon virtues over time.
Most Objectivists are not children of Objectivists, and I think many if not most came from early environments at least somewhat hostile to Objectivism.
I worry about this with my 3-year old. There are some things I can do to help her become a great person, but I think there are some things I can’t and shouldn’t try to control.
As I mentioned in another thread, I read Atlas Shrugged at age 9, but that wasn’t the key factor in me later becoming a student of Objectivism. I think the key was the pride that led me to decide, “this summer I’m going to read an even bigger book, the longest novel I can find in the library.”
I think it would be very hard for somebody who doesn’t have at least some of the Objectivist values already to become an Objectivist. For instance, I know a person who I know will never become an Objectivist. Why? He lacks the virtues of rationality, self-esteem, and independence of thought. There are many corrolaries to these virtues but, if you are lacking in those three, it is nearly impossible to reach the person with reason.
Well, if you’re a true Objectivist, then you would believe that we are born tabula rasa, meaning that you have no ideas, Objectivist or otherwise. I think it’s all about how you’re raised and socialized. Conscious choice enters at the appropriate level of maturity. While I’m not an Objectivist, I have strong leanings in that direction, yet I was raised as a Christian. However, my parents, despite being Christian, are very individualistic. My first words, and no I am no making this up, were “I need money.” My parents gave me a few coins and I went and put them in my room. My next words were “I need mo money.”
Well, if you’re a true Objectivist, then you would believe that we are born tabula rasa, meaning that you have no ideas, Objectivist or otherwise. I think it’s all about how you’re raised and socialized. Conscious choice enters at the appropriate level of maturity. While I’m not an Objectivist, I have strong leanings in that direction, yet I was raised as a Christian. However, my parents, despite being Christian, are very individualistic. My first words, and no I am no making this up, were “I need money.” My parents gave me a few coins and I went and put them in my room. My next words were “I need mo money.”
I think it would be very hard for somebody who doesn’t have at least some of the Objectivist values already to become an Objectivist. For instance, I know a person who I know will never become an Objectivist. Why? He lacks the virtues of rationality, self-esteem, and independence of thought. There are many corrolaries to these virtues but, if you are lacking in those three, it is nearly impossible to reach the person with reason.
That’s sort of a pessimistic view. Before somewhere either my freshman or sophomore year of college, I was a hopelessly fundamentalist Christian. I wasn’t all that devout, but I had a habit of burying my head in the sand whenever someone challenged my faith. I am no longer a Christian and have strong Objectivist leanings.
As I mentioned in another thread, I read Atlas Shrugged at age 9…
Everytime I start to think I’m smart, someone says something like this. I thought it was a big deal that my 16-year old cousin is reading The Fountainhead. Did you actually understand it?
Well, if you’re a true Objectivist, then you would believe that we are born tabula rasa, meaning that you have no ideas, Objectivist or otherwise. I think it’s all about how you’re raised and socialized. Conscious choice enters at the appropriate level of maturity.
Two people can come from the same parents and the same background and end up being entirely different philosophically. My older sister always said that a good person should put others needs first. I always thought she was on drugs. And guess what? Now she is! But that’s not the point.
I have a brother who is big into collectivist thinking and ‘social justice.’ He knows that this is antithetical to everything I believe in so we simply don’t talk politics. We were raised in the same environment though. I have to believe that nature sometimes precludes nurture.
That’s sort of a pessimistic view. Before somewhere either my freshman or sophomore year of college, I was a hopelessly fundamentalist Christian. I wasn’t all that devout, but I had a habit of burying my head in the sand whenever someone challenged my faith. I am no longer a Christian and have strong Objectivist leanings.
I also came from a fundamentalist background but realized much later that I already had some of the Objectivist values in me.
For example: I remember having a heated arguement with the pastor of my church because he was using an irrational arguement to try and wish away one of those difficult passages in the Bible that fundys want to ignore without truly explaining it (his response was, “That was then and this is now!” i.e. truth is not static).
Of course, bear in mind this is only my own experience and I can’t really speak for anyone else on the matter.
I used to have serious problems with the way my fellow Christians would argue too. I have an essay (that’s actually the first chapter in a book that I’d like to write at some point) about my journey through Christianity that I’ve considered posting in the member’s essays sections…I just don’t know if it’s good enough to post it yet.
Everytime I start to think I’m smart, someone says something like this. I thought it was a big deal that my 16-year old cousin is reading The Fountainhead. Did you actually understand it?
Your intelligence doesn’t depend on others being stupid.
I have a brother who is big into collectivist thinking and ‘social justice.’ He knows that this is antithetical to everything I believe in so we simply don’t talk politics. We were raised in the same environment though. I have to believe that nature sometimes precludes nurture.
I don’t know if this describes my sister or not, b/c she doesn’t really get into politics, but she does strike me as being a hippie, and I know she voted for Kerry. I love my sister to death, but don’t think I could have a political conversation w/ her without ripping her head off.
Is that last statement sort of antithetical to Objectivist epistemology? I agree with the Lockeian view that there are no innate ideas. We have innate mechanisms that allow us to form ideas…that’s one reason why some people are smarter than others–they have better cognitive mechanisms. But that doesn’t mean that they are born with better ideas…just that they are born with better abilities to discover those ideas.
As I mentioned in another thread, I read Atlas Shrugged at age 9, but that wasn’t the key factor in me later becoming a student of Objectivism. I think the key was the pride that led me to decide, “this summer I’m going to read an even bigger book, the longest novel I can find in the library.”
That’s awesome! Just curious–was Atlas Shrugged in your elementary school library, or was this a public library you went to?
I used to have serious problems with the way my fellow Christians would argue too. I have an essay (that’s actually the first chapter in a book that I’d like to write at some point) about my journey through Christianity that I’ve considered posting in the member’s essays sections…I just don’t know if it’s good enough to post it yet.
I’ll be watching for it. I’m always quite interested to hear perspectives from other ex-Christians.
I don’t know if this describes my sister or not, b/c she doesn’t really get into politics, but she does strike me as being a hippie, and I know she voted for Kerry. I love my sister to death, but don’t think I could have a political conversation w/ her without ripping her head off.
Is that last statement sort of antithetical to Objectivist epistemology? I agree with the Lockeian view that there are no innate ideas. We have innate mechanisms that allow us to form ideas…that’s one reason why some people are smarter than others–they have better cognitive mechanisms. But that doesn’t mean that they are born with better ideas…just that they are born with better abilities to discover those ideas.
Aside from intelligence differences, I was thinking more along the line of preference for thinking as opposed to feeling. Someone who prefers logic might look at a hungry person and say he jacked off his money and opportunities and therefore got what he earned. A more emotional person might say oh look this guy is hungry. He is *unfortunate* (as if people just luck up on results). It is my opinion that collectivists are more emotional than logical and I was postulating that there might be an inherent preference to personality type.
I’ll buy that. It’s not an issue of innate ideas, it’s an issue of innate personality. I still think there is a large “nurture” component to personality, though.
I view accepting Objectivism as almost a series of tests. As you learn more about it, you learn a lot of things that defy social conventions and traditional ideas. So, neglecting those that become “Objectivists” to be “different,” it takes independence and intellectual honesty to oneself. I don’t think the subjects one is interested in matter that much as such–philosophy applies to everything. I definitely see how math/science interests would keep one more logical and open to reason than a field like literature (and university English departments) would, but I don’t think the subject is the root cause.
I think the most important quality is independent thought (or the propensity to discover how to think independently). Environmental influences can definitely impact this, especially over long periods of time, but a significant amount of it comes from within.
Aside from intelligence differences, I was thinking more along the line of preference for thinking as opposed to feeling. Someone who prefers logic might look at a hungry person and say he jacked off his money and opportunities and therefore got what he earned. A more emotional person might say oh look this guy is hungry. He is *unfortunate* (as if people just luck up on results). It is my opinion that collectivists are more emotional than logical and I was postulating that there might be an inherent preference to personality type.
Or the “feeling” person might just get really pissed off at the bum for wasting his life and yell at him.