On the question of free-will vs. determinism

There has been some discussion here about free will and it

touched a raw nerve in me for I have had similar conversations

when I get in a philosophical mood . The conversation usually

centers on the question of whether Homo Sapiens has Free Will

or not. Few ask what is meant by the term. I suppose they think

it’s so obvious so self explanatory that it’s not worth talking or

even thinking about.

The discussion invariably ends with a demonstration. Someone

picks up an object and drops it from one hand to the other and

says "This proves I have Free Will, I can hold it in my hand or

I can drop it. If I drop it it’s not because anything made me,

in fact I could have held on to it but I just didn’t feel like it".

When asked why he didn’t feel like it the only answer your

likely to get is “I just didn’t!” as if that explained everything.

If I point out that I was the cause of the demonstration by bringing

up the subject in the first place, anger sometimes results.

To say “I can do anything I want to” is not an expression of absolute

freedom but a severe restriction on it for the clear implication is

“I can do nothing I don’t want to”.

We feel certain that we are totally in control of our actions

yet when someone acts in a way we don’t understand we still ask

“Why did you do that?” by which we mean what CAUSED you to

do it. At the same time we pretend that our will is completely

independent of external factors as if our behavior has no cause

although if this was true our conduct would be totally random.

No concept in Philosophy has been analyzed as poorly or has

greater practical implications.

This confusion largely stems from the enormously powerful

intuitive feeling that we are not robots and that our minds are

not deterministic. Indeed modern Physics has shown, by way of

Heisenburg’s Uncertainty Principle and Bell’s Inequality, that

some things happen for no reason, in other words they are truly

accidental. No one has shown that this element of chance extends

to the workings of the mind but it seems likely that at least to

some degree that it does. I maintain that randomness, whether it

exists in the human brain or not, has much to do with the

question of determinism but nothing to do with volition.

Intuition should not be dismissed lightly especially when it’s

almost universally held. But what is this intuition trying to tell us?

People differ greatly over this but I think we can find a minimal

definition of free will that almost everyone can agree on ;

and that is a feeling of choice. This sensation of autonomy

is a crucial aspect of our internal life so any successful

theory of the Will must explain the source of this emotion.

Let’s simplify things to their essentials. Imagine a world in

which the environment was so simple it could be predicted with

complete accuracy. Doubtless we would find such a place boring

and unpleasant but I don’t think we would feel like robots.

Thus the origin of the sensation of autonomy can not be external.

What does it mean to “feel like a robot”? I think that if you

could always forecast your own behavior and thoughts with

complete accuracy then you would feel like a robot. Uncertainty

is at the root of freedom and choice. I hope to show that even

in a predictable habitat and even ignoring whatever effects

quantum uncertainty has on the macro-world, it is impossible,

even in theory, to entirely foresee ones own conduct.

For the mind to totally understand itself it must form a perfect

internal model of itself. The model must not only describe the

rest of the mind in every detail but it must also depict the

model itself with a micro model. This micro model must represent

the rest of the brain and the micro model itself with a micro

micro model. This path leads to an impossible infinite regress.

Both the brain and the model must be made up of a finite number

of elements. If we are not to lose accuracy the components of

the brain must have a one to one correspondence with the elements

of the model. But this is impossible because the brain as a whole

must have more members than the part that is just the model.

This argument does not hold if the mind is infinite, that is if

it has an infinite number of segments. It would be possible to

find a one to one correspondence with a proper subset of itself;

for example you CAN find a one to one correspondence between the

set of odd integers with the set of all integers. Thus an

infinite intellect could predict all its actions without error.

So we are lead to the interesting conclusion that man has free will

but GOD if SHE exists does not.

Let me suggest a thought experiment; a man is walking down a

road and spots a fork in the road far ahead. He knows of

advantages and disadvantages to both paths so he isn’t sure if

he will go right or left, he hadn’t decided. Now imagine a

powerful demon able to look into the man’s head and quickly

deduce that he would eventually choose to go to the left.

Meanwhile the man, whose mind works much more slowly than the

demon’s, hasn’t completed the thought process yet. He might be

saying to himself I haven’t decided I’ll have to think about it,

I’m free to go either way. From his point of view he is in a

sense correct, even a robot does not feel like a robot but from

the demon’s viewpoint it’s a different matter, he simply deduced

a purely mechanical operation that can have only one outcome.

But is it really a purely mechanical operation, what about the

uncertainty principal? I don’t see how it effects matters one

way or another. It says that some things can happen for no cause

and thus are truly random, but happenstance is the very opposite

of intelligence and even emotion.

Things either happen because of cause and effect or they don’t

and if they don’t then they are by definition random and have

nothing to due with volition. Those who claim that this is the

source of the will must also believe that a nickel has free will

when you flip it. This topic muddies the question but does

not change it.

In my example the demon did not tell the man of his prediction,

but now lets pretend he did. Suppose also that the man, being of

an argumentative nature, was determined to do the exact opposite

of what the demon predicted. Now our poor demon would be in a

familiar predicament. Because the demon’s decision influences

the man’s actions the demon must forecast his own behavior, but

he will have no better luck in this regard than the man did and

for the same reasons. What we would need in a situation like

this is a mega-demon able to look into the demon’s head. Now the

mega-demon would have the problem.

As a final variation let’s make our demon have an infinite mind.

Now our demon would be able to have full self knowledge yet

because of the man’s decision to be contrary he still can not

say what he will do, even if he knows what it is. So under

certain circumstances there are some things that even a limitless

mind can not do, it can not communicate with us freely.

Perhaps we should return to earth now because unlike some

esoteric controversies in philosophy this topic has some

practical applications. Don’t worry that a duplicate of you will

not REALLY be you because the copy will feel like a robot, he won’t.

If the copy thinks you have survived, then you have. Also,

in the matter of criminal law the general public and lawyers in

particular have some strange ideas about the purpose of

punishment. They seem to feel that if someone has derived

pleasure in a evil way, it is the law’s duty to somehow balance

the books by making the lawbreaker suffer. The cliche about

man being responsible for his own actions is merely a

rationalization for sadism. This leads to endless convoluted

irrelevant arguments reminiscent of the medieval one about pins

and dancing angles. What was the mental state of the lawbreaker?

Did he grow up in a good home as a child? Did he undergo a lot

of strain as a adult? Is there anything physically wrong with

his brain? Was he in full control of his faculties? And even a

question that philosophers fight about to this day "does he know

the difference between right and wrong?". Little wonder that the

legal system is hopelessly backlogged.

The only logical or moral reason for punishing a wrongdoer is to

prevent a similar crime from happening; it’s the difference between

justice and vengeance. Making an evil person suffer just for the

fun of seeing him in pain is pointless and cruel, after all a

bad man suffers just as intensely as a good man.

It would seem to me that everything, and I mean absolutely

everything, happens because of cause and effect OR it does not

happen because of cause and effect. If it is the first then it’s

mechanistic and if it’s the second then it is by definition random,

I don’t see any third possibility. So if people have “Free Will”

then so does a cuckoo clock or a pair of dice. Actually I think

Free Will is one of those ideas that is so bad it’s not even wrong.

John K Clark

Yes, capforever, there are certainly some attributes that I posess that I do not control. I cannot choose to be 3’ tall (at least, not without a leg-ectomy!) and it is reasonable to conclude that my height has nothing to do with my ability to choose to think or evade, or the outcome of that choice. This is the argument for saying that not all of a man’s attributes or characteristics affect the outcome of his choices. Everyone has a lot of characteristics that are inessential in the context of a discussion of volition.

The problem that causes most determinists to go off course is that they try to say “These attributes (genes, +/- reinforcement, childhood, take your pick) cause a man to think or not.” It is clear that we do not know enough about how the human mind works to say specifically which attribute(s) cause one’s choice to go one way or the other. In fact, since so much of the brain’s activity is on a microscopic - even subatomic - level, it seems to me that the limits set by the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle imply that it is impossible to ever say exactly what those characteristics are. We don’t even have words to describe them. (After all, without a means of measuring something, at least implicitly, how could you possibly form a concept?) Our best means of understanding the inner workings of the human mind continues to be introspection and inferrence from observation. And, since you can’t “get outside your mind and take a look around,” it makes sense that the choice of whether or not to think is irreducible, at least in practice. Nevertheless, if I make a choice (as I know that I do through direct introspective observation,) then the outcome is determined by me. Since I am my attributes, the outcome of the choice is determined by my attributes, whatever they may be. Since I cannot both have and lack the same attribute at the same time in the same respect, I know that my choices are predetermined, just like everything else in the universe.

(John: Despite the mystics in modern physics, the HUP does NOT show that things ever happen for no reason. That was Heisenberg’s interpretation of his principle. The principle is true - his interpretation is invalid. It states that we are incapable of measuring them, as doing so by any means known to us would disturb them significantly. If you smack an electron with a photon to take a snapshot of it, you push it away from where it was. Just the way of things. This isn’t an exception from the law of identity, merely a limitation of beings of our size looking at very small things. Do not be so arrogant as to confuse an epistemological limitation with a metaphysical fact. “If I can’t learn it, then it must not exist”? Come on.)

Nonetheless, Identity tells us that these attributes, whatever they may be, are something and not nothing. At any given time, man will either have or lack any of these attributes, and not both.

Yes, it is the sum of its attributes at any given time, but it can influence the way these attributes develop over time.

Yes, indeed! That’s what’s so unique and cool about life, isn’t it?

Inanimate objects may change over time (in fact, all of them do, tho they may do so very slowly - entropy says so.) Only living entities change in a specific goal-directed manner - generally towards preserving their lives. (Hence “life is self-generated, self-sustaining action.”) Conscious living organisms (from slugs to humans) take this to another level. Not only do they change in this self-sustaining manner, they also respond to information in order to do so, and have some sort of consistent “map of the world” that they use in this process. Granted, for a slug, the “map of the world” is hardcoded in their nervous system and instincts, created purely through evolution’s great heuristic. For a dog, it is a little different, and one could argue that a dog’s mental picture is a response to experience as much as it is a result of instinct, but still, it’s not anywhere near being what we would call “volitional.”

Man, in processing information about the world, is able to also change the information processing mechanism to a very significant degree. We can cast our mental gaze upon our “map of the world,” thus making the map itself something else that affects how we build the map. We can thus change our attributes (at least, those that are relevant to this discussion,) and thus learn from experiences in a way completely unlike a dog - because we can learn from the experience of learning, and thus aim our changes in the direction that we think they should go.

Just because we cannot predict something does not mean that it is not predetermined. Even if something changes over time, it still is what it is at every moment. (This is why there is no “change” apart from a “changing entity.” Metaphysically, there is just an entity. At another point in time, there is a different entity. “Change” is our epistemological way of “connecting the dots,” - but what exists at any moment is the entity, and it always is what it is.)

Far from implying that man is a powerless pawn to outside factors, these facts imply that a man has nearly total control over his life, his character, and his choices. (After all, these things are determined by his attributes, and he IS his attributes.) This implies the need for moral accountability (since man is resposible for his choices, and cannot blame them on other factors,) for rationality (the need of a chosen method of thinking,) and for independence (our basic nature demands that we take responsibility for our lives if they are to continue,) and all that other good stuff in philosophy. It follows from the axioms of identity and existence that man has volition, and yet also is a predetermined (though not always predictable) entity.

Thus an infinite intellect could predict all its actions without error. So we are lead to the interesting conclusion that man has free will but GOD if SHE exists does not.

Well, I don’t know whom you got your definition of free will from, but the inability to predict one’s actions is certainly not what Objectivists call free will. A bottle of water cannot predict its own actions, but that doesn’t mean it has free will.

Free will (and this is my definition) is when a conscious, intelligent entity defines certain aspects of its own nature independently, on its own initiative. In other words, when an entity acts not as a mere agent of the rules of physics, but on its own behalf.

Note that both versions of this definition require you to abandon your (I take it) materialist view of the world. You have to think about the meaning of words like “conscious,” “intelligent,” “define,” “independently,” “initiative,” as well as the ones I mentioned earlier on this thread: “power,” “control,” and “can.” These words do not make sense in a materialistic, physics-only world. In fact, in a purely material world, you wouldn’t even be conscious of my writing these things to you, because the very definition of the spiritual is “that which is related to _conscious_ness.” But yet, people do use these words and they do seem to have definite meanings which everyone apparently understands. Why is that?

(As an aside, may I ask if you are a feminist?)

Don’t worry that a duplicate of you will not REALLY be you because the copy will feel like a robot, he won’t. If the copy thinks you have survived, then you have.

Fine, then I’ll just clone you and kill you. I’ll give the clone twenty bucks for your letting me do this. Is that a deal?

(Before you make your decision, talk to some identical twins.)

" Well, I don’t know whom you got your definition of free will from"

I made it up.

“the inability to predict one’s actions is certainly not what Objectivists call free will. A bottle of water cannot predict its own actions, but that doesn’t mean it has free will.”

Why not? By my definition a bottle of water does have fre will, I don’t claim my definition is terribly useful but at least it’s concrete, consistent and is not a hindrance to productive thought, something no other definition of the term has.

“Free will (and this is my definition) is when a conscious, intelligent entity defines certain aspects of its own nature independently, on its own initiative. In other words, when an entity acts not as a mere agent of the rules of physics, but on its own behalf.”

On my own behalf, of my own free will, I consciously decide to go to a restaurant.

Why?

Because I want to.

Why ?

Because I want to eat.

Why?

Because I’m hungry?

Why ?

Because lack of food triggered nerve impulses in my stomach, my brain

interpreted these signals as pain, I can only stand so much before I try to

stop it.

Why?

Because I don’t like pain.

Why?

Because that’s the way my brain is constructed.

Why?

Because my body and the hardware of my brain were made from the information

in my genetic code (lets see, 6 billion base pairs 2 bits per base pairs 8 bits per byte that comes out to about 1.5 geg, compress it into a zip file and you could burn it on to a CD). The programming of my brain came from the

environment, add a little quantum randomness perhaps and of my own free will

I consciously decide to go to a restaurant.

“Note that both versions of this definition require you to abandon your (I take it) materialist view of the world. You have to think about the meaning of words like “conscious,” “intelligent,” “define,” “independently,” “initiative,” as well as the ones I mentioned earlier on this thread: “power,” “control,” and “can.” These words do not make sense in a materialistic, physics-only world. In fact, in a purely material world, you wouldn’t even be conscious of my writing these things to you, because the very definition of the spiritual is “that which is related to consciousness.” But yet, people do use these words and they do seem to have definite meanings which everyone apparently understands. Why is that?”

Conscious" and “intelligent” have a lot of meaning for me, independently," and "initiative” a bit less, “free will” none at all. And asking for a definition of definition makes no sense at all, if you can understand the question you don’t need at ask it.

“then I’ll just clone you and kill you. I’ll give the clone twenty bucks for your letting me do this. Is that a deal? (Before you make your decision, talk to some identical twins.)”

A clone (a twin is just a natural clone) is not good enough because it would not have any of my memories, but if you have a matter duplication machine that can record the position and momentum of every atom in my body to the accuracy allowed by the uncertainty principle and then use generic atoms to build a copy of me then yes, it’s a deal, give me 20 bucks and you can kill the original. As a matter of fact for all I know you may have already done so last night.

"As an aside, may I ask if you are a feminist?

No.

John K Clark [email protected]

Jonkc, do not confuse free will with “ability to do anything, including actions contrary to one’s nature”. Just because I can’t hold my breath long enough to kill myself or flap my arms and fly, it does not mean I don’t have free will. Free will is simply the ability to choose among alternative courses of actions.

Let’s use that absurd example of yours:

I’m going to the restaurant.

Why?

Because I’m hungry.

No, that’s not the right answer. One’s hunger doesn’t determine one’s action of going to the restaurant. Millions in third world countries go hungry every year. Do they go to the restaurant?

No. Not if they couldn’t.

Alright, then, WHY are you going to the restaurant?

Because I want to eat.

Wrong, again. Millions in the past wanted to eat but starved, did they go the restaurant?

No.

Answer the question!

Because I feel a pain called “hunger”, meaning my body needs more food.

Didn’t you understand my previous examples? Again, WHY ARE YOU GOING TO THE RESTAURANT!?

Because I choose to!!!

Why?

Because I’m hungry.

Wrong. Hunger does not compel one to–in particular–go to the restaurant. Hunger compels one to seek food, but not necessarily to go to a restaurant.

Why a RESTAURANT? Why not your own KITCHEN, a GROCERY STORE, or any other kind of store that sells food?

Why not STEAL a food? Why not GROW your own food?

Why not any other act that can get you food?

BLANK OUT.

POINT: hunger compels one to seek food. How you do it, when you do it, where you do it, from whom or from what you obtain it, with what means you do it, and so on, THOSE ARE UP TO YOU!!! *YOU* CHOOSE among ALL the nearly infinite alternatives when it comes to getting food.

In fact, you can even choose not to seek food despite your hunger. You can end that pain by killing yourself.

THAT is an example of free will.

Why not? By my definition a bottle of water does have fre will, I don’t claim my definition is terribly useful but at least it’s concrete, consistent and is not a hindrance to productive thought, something no other definition of the term has.

Since when is a definition that is (by its author’s own admission) “not terribly useful” simultaneously “not a hindrance to productive thought?” If it could be used in productive thought, then it would be useful, would it not?

This conversation has just gotten absurd. A rational person should have just dropped out as soon as it was stated that the conclusion that “GOD if SHE exists cannot” make choices was an “interesting” one to reach–how is it interesting when it is arbitrary and meaningless?–and probably sooner.

Because ultimately, arguing with any committed determinist, even if he tries to claim he isn’t one by putting a prefix in front of it, is a waste of time. :dough:

If it [my definition of free will] could be used in productive thought, then it would be useful, would it not?

Traditional ideas about free will are not true but they’re not false either, they’re just gibberish. It’s true, my definition doesn’t generate a lot of productive thought but at least it is not contradictory and does not send the brain into an endless loop. Best to just call it a bad job and stick the entire free will thing

(calling it an idea would give it far too much credit) into the trash can.

ultimately, arguing with any committed determinist, even if he tries to claim he isn’t one by putting a prefix in front of it, is a waste of time.

I am not ashamed of my views, if I was a determinist I would not hesitate to say so in a loud clear voice, the reason you have not heard me say so is I don’t believe it is true. I know of no law of logic that demands every event have a cause, and indeed modern physics tells us that some things have no cause; the word for such things is “random”.

This conversation has just gotten absurd. […] how is it interesting when it is arbitrary and meaningless?

It is my experience that nobody gets mad when they are winning an argument.

John K Clark

do not confuse free will with "ability to do anything

I don’t, It’s very simple, I say free will is the inability to always know what you will do next even in a simple predictable environment.

I’m going to the restaurant.

Why?

Why indeed. I’ll bet sometime in your life you’ve gone into a restaurant and I wouldn’t be too surprised if at least once somebody asked you why you went into that particular restaurant, did you have an answer for them? Usually when somebody is unable to give a reason for why they acted the way they did we take it as a sign of insanity, or at least irrationality.

John K Clark [email protected]

ultimately, arguing with any committed determinist, even if he tries to claim he isn’t one by putting a prefix in front of it, is a waste of time.

I am not ashamed of my views, if I was a determinist I would not hesitate to say so in a loud clear voice, the reason you have not heard me say so is I don’t believe it is true. I know of no law of logic that demands every event have a cause, and indeed modern physics tells us that some things have no cause; the word for such things is “random”.

Just for the sake of clarification, this was in reference to Isaac, not John. I am very well that John is not a determinist at all, but an indeterminist (which is even worse).

This conversation has just gotten absurd. […] how is it interesting when it is arbitrary and meaningless?

It is my experience that nobody gets mad when they are winning an argument.

John K Clark

And for the record, I was neither mad at (just slightly amused/irritated/bored) nor arguing with John (as I clearly didn’t directly address his main arguments but rather just pointed out the irrationality of his whole approach in order to indicate that arguing with him is pointless). So I guess that doesn’t overturn his past experience on either count.

AshRyan,

You’re right, things got silly right at the goddess mention.

Jon KC has coopted this thread. Can one of you sharp objectivists please respond to my last post? This thread was just starting to get good, and has taken a serious turn in the wrong direction. I believe that this is indicative of what’s wrong here:

It is my experience that nobody gets mad when they are winning an argument.

Jon, an argument is a search for the truth. There are either two winners or two losers. You seem to be out to make sure that the other guy loses. Some of what you say may be true, or false, but you and everyone else will never know, because your approach is very confrontational and you sieze on the tiniest points to attack. Rather than try to lure your so-called opponents to your point of view by looking for common ground and points of agreement, you bring in many more disagreements with each sentence you write. You aren’t arguing, Jon, you’re just bickering with big words. A rational and honest man, when arguing, honestly wants the truth to be found. He wants to either find the way to convince his opponent that he is correct, or he wants to be convinced of his opponent’s point of view, but he knows that the truth, properly approached and verbalized, will speak for itself. As long as you’re thinking about who’s winning and who’s losing, well, Jon, it’s clear that you win. Mark this on your scorecard, and kindly let us get back to actually discussing the topic. Thanks.

I was hoping that this wouldn’t happen, that your posts would be disregarded as rationalistic bickering, and that the rest of us could continue our argument. Jon, if you have a problem with what I’ve said here, please respond via email - [email protected]. I’m not going to bother reading or replying to anything in this thread that doesn’t have to do with Volition.

I’m not going to bother reading or replying to anything in this thread that doesn’t have to do with Volition

First of all we both know what you just wrote is untrue, you may not respond but of course you will read this. Second, I was on topic, I was writing about nothing but Volition. Third, I always find it amusing when people on the net write a lot of off topic comments and then say it should all end here and nobody should rebut my off topic comments with their own off topic comments, just let me have the last word. Fourth, it’s true, I do seize on the tiniest points to attack and I invite others to do the same with my ideas, or try to; I think that process is the best way to find the truth. And fifth, if you want me to respond only in private Email then you should not have posted a message but sent a private Email.

John K Clark [email protected]

Well, ya got me Jon. You win.

Now, GCS, CapitalismForever, AshRyan, I’m really interested in continuing. Can one of you read my last (on-topic) post and respond? I’m curious as to your thoughts on it. Thanks.

Far from implying that man is a powerless pawn to outside factors, these facts imply that a man has nearly total control over his life, his character, and his choices.  (After all, these things are determined by his attributes, and he IS his attributes.)

Well, which is it now, are these things determined by him, or are they _pre_determined? If something is predetermined–if the choice has already been made–then it isn’t up to me.

Predetermination implies that all events in the universe are ultimately caused by a single authority (which some call “Ms. God” :dough: and others just say it’s the properties of matter / the laws of nature). Volition means that the story of the universe is shaped by volitional beings (who make their choices as time passes) AS WELL AS the laws of nature (which are constant over time).

A predetermined universe is like a book written by a single author, where all the characters do what the author wants them to. As a reader, you have no influence on the plot, as the plot is already fixed at the moment you start reading the book.

On the other hand, a universe inhabited by volitional beings is like an interactive role game. There are a set of rules for playing the game, but the plot is not predetermined by the rules, as the rules allow the players to make their own decisions. Thus, the actual plot is determined both by the rules AND by the players.

Well, which is it now, are these things determined by him, or are they predetermined? If something is predetermined–if the choice has already been made–then it isn’t up to me.

See, that’s where you’re all making the mistake. Because if something is predetermined, and it is caused by your nature, then it IS up to you.

The idea of causation is getting confused here somewhat. To review:

All actions are actions of entities.

The nature of an action is determined by the nature of the entity acting.

Let’s say that an apple falls on the ground, and the seeds inside start growing, and it grows into another tree. What was the cause of that tree? Was it the apple falling? Or the seeds growing? Or the fact that a seed had fallen earlier, turned into a tree which produced the apple that turned into another tree? Or should we say that the cause of that new tree was the first apple tree to produce a seed?

Clearly, without any of these things, the new tree wouldn’t exist. To a certain extent, all had a hand in “causing” the new tree. Ultimately, however, the cause of *this tree* is “the nature of the seed/soil/etc. that created the new tree.” (To prove this point, try planting a rock. No tree will grow. QED.) The earlier things may have caused the nature of the seed to be what it is, and so it is only by extension that they caused the new tree. For an apple seed, the nature of the seed is 100% determined by the nature of the entities that created it, and you can say with 100% certainty, “If this seed came from a healthy tree, and has not been adversely modified in any way since its creation, and I plant it in suitable soil, an apple tree will grow.” Or, to put it simpler, “I know what caused this seed to exist, and I know that its nature does not change significantly over time, and thus, I know its nature, or at least, what is relevant to this question. Knowing this seed’s nature, I know that it will cause a tree to grow.”

With a human, it’s not so simple, but it is somewhat similar.

Evolution/culture/upbringing/etc. may have a hand in making you what you are. However, you are the cause of your actions. That is, your actions are caused by your individual nature at that particular moment when you choose. In addition, you have the ability to volitionally change the attributes that make you what you are. There is thus a sort of “cyclical causation.” As a man learns and grows, he changes his attributes - he changes himself - and thus changes the way in which he causes other actions. Since so much of the mind is so highly self-modifiable, it’s nearly impossible to trace the cause of any given choice down to a single attribute or set of attributes. For all intents and purposes, the cause of the choice is “irreducible,” simply because it’s so subtly dependent on so many of your aspects.

If it were possible to know all of the attributes of me, and all of the ways that all of those attributes may cause action, well, then, you’d know what I’d do. This sort of near-omniscience is not even required most of the time. How many times has a friend that you know well done something that was totally un-surprising to you? Even if you knew what he would do, that doesn’t detract from the fact that he chose - his nature (his attributes, that is to say HE) determined the outcome, and you are familiar enough with his nature to predict with a fair degree of accuracy what that will be. (That’s not to say that friends never surprise one another. Hell, sometimes we even surprise ourselves!) In fact, the more rational and healthy a person is, the more that they cleanse their mental workings of any contradictions or evasions, the more predictable they become. Thus, as many philosophers have commented, healthy rational people tend to resemble one another. (However, no two people are ever 100% identical, of course.)

Any attribute of your character, any given characteristic that makes you you had to come from somewhere. It may be that the trait was something inherited, or something that you chose to develop, or just an unpredictable combination of biochemical whatevers in your brain. These specifics are a task for neuroscience, not philosophy - philosophically, it doesn’t matter where they come from. However, philosophy tells us that you have identity - ie, your attributes are what they are and are non-contradictory. Since you determine your choices, and you are a certain way, your choice will turn out a certain way. You have the power to choose, but you don’t have the power to choose that which it is not in your nature to choose. That would mean that you have the power to choose to do that which you choose not to do! (Iow, the power to make A = !A. This reminds me of the problem with an omnipotent deity creating a rock so heavy he can’t lift it.)

Thus, the actual plot is determined both by the rules AND by the players.

If I’m understanding your metaphor correctly, then in this case, the players ARE the rules (an entity is its attributes.)

To say that predetermination means that “something else chooses” is to place consciousness before existence. There is no “choice” until there is a self-conscious self-modifying entity to choose. How can “god” or “the laws of reality” choose “for” you? That’s as nonsensical as saying that your nature “forces” you to do something. All that predetermination asserts is that your choice will result in a particular action, *because you, having identity, will cause a particular action*.

Just wanted to add one small point:

What was the cause of that tree? Was it the apple falling? Or the seeds growing? Or the fact that a seed had fallen earlier, turned into a tree which produced the apple that turned into another tree? Or should we say that the cause of that new tree was the first apple tree to produce a seed?

The issue I’m getting at here is that actions are caused by the nature of the entities acting, not by earlier actions. (I.e., actions don’t cause actions, entities do.) That’s a big error in thinking that leads lots of good people astray.

If I’m understanding your metaphor correctly, then in this case, the players ARE the rules (an entity is its attributes.)

My point was exactly that the players are distinct from the rules.

The rules are devised by somebody, or they just develop over time, and then at the beginning of the game the players agree to follow the rules. At this point, the rules are fixed and known, but the outcome of the game isn’t, as the rules don’t specify a particular outcome but make it up to the players’ choices. Thus, the outcome isn’t predetermined by the rules. It is possible to play two games using the same set of rules and have two entirely different plots. The individual elements of the plot only become known over time, as the players perform their acts.

So, here, the rules are one influence on the plot, and each of the players is another influence on the plot–whereas in a static book, the book’s author is the only influence on the plot. In the one example, the plot is determined by a single authority, while in the other one, it is determined by the interaction of several authorities.

To say that predetermination means that “something else chooses” is to place consciousness before existence.  There is no “choice” until there is a self-conscious self-modifying entity to choose.

This is what I wrote:

Predetermination implies that all events in the universe are ultimately caused by a single authority (which some call “Ms. God”  and others just say it’s the properties of matter / the laws of nature).

It would have been more appropriate for me to write “determined” instead of “caused,” so please read the sentence with that substitution. What I am describing here is two possible forms of a predetermined view of the universe, both of which I disagree with: a theistic one (which indeed puts consciousness before existence) and a materialistic one (which doesn’t put consciousness anywhere). I disagree with both of them for the same reason: namely, that they posit a single ultimate source for all events in the universe.

The theistic one posits an omnipotent God and views the rest of the universe as mere agents of God. The materialistic one posits a universe that is a single non-volitional entity, with all its components (including humans) being mere agents of that single entity.

An analogy might help you understand what I mean when I say “agents of that single entity” : When you lift your finger, all the molecules in your finger move. The motion of each individual molecule is caused by that molecule–but the molecules cannot help moving, as their nature does not allow them to choose whether or not they will obey you. There is a force acting on them, and they are bound to react to that force in a particular way–so, once that force is present, the molecules’ behavior is predetermined.

The molecules of your finger are subentities of your finger, and their actions are merely reflections of your finger’s actions. They do not act on their own initiative.

Nor does your finger act on its own initiative; it is your agent. You are a composite entity made up of many parts and the actions of your parts are simply reflections of your actions. Since you determine your actions, your parts don’t get to determine their own actions.

The matierialistic view of a predetermined universe sees everything in the universe as a mere agent of the universe–including humans.

capforever, you’re making this more complicated than it has to be, and missing my main point.

The choice comes from somewhere, right? You make the choice, I think that we agree on that.

What I am saying is that “you make the choice” is equivalent to “your attributes determine the outcome of the choice.” An entity is its attributes.

The next step in my argument is that you either have or lack any attribute or set of attributes, and not both. (Man has identity.)

Therefore, you will either choose A or not-A, but only one choice will actually happen.

It may be correct, beforehand, to say that either one is “possible,” since we may have had some information to support the prediction of either outcome, but not enough to say for certain what you would do. However, the implication of this argument is that words like “possible,” “probable,” and so on, refer to an epistemological status, not metaphysical status. Metaphysically, what will happen will happen, period, because even choosers have identity, and even the actions of choosers are determined by their nature.

That is the meat of my argument. What follows is just miscellaneous stuff…

You’re right, molecules or fingers or any other parts of a man are not volitional in any meaningful sense. Volition only applies to a conscious entity. Similiarly, saying that my attributes determine the outcome of my choice doesn’t imply that any of my attributes are volitional - that is a propery of the whole, not of any of the individual parts. (Let’s not commit the composition or division fallacies here!)

If you want to really attack this argument, here are a few ideas:

  1. You could try showing that volitional beings somehow lack identity, and can both have and lack some properties at the same time and in the same respect. (Good luck!)

  2. You could try to show that the actions of volitional beings are not determined by their attributes. (I will counter by saying that this means that there’s nothing “free” about “free will,” since that would reduce it to a form of indeterminism.)

  3. You could posit some “spooky attribute” that can possibly cause both P and !P. You could go out further on that limb, and state that only Man has this spooky attribute. (I will counter by saying that this is a violation of the law of causality. Actions are caused by the nature of the entities acting. This sort of spooky attribute would cause an action that has no identity. This is a fallacy I like to call the “Heisenburg Fallacy,” because it blurs the division between epistemology and metaphysics, and states, “Because we can’t know its nature, it doesn’t have one.” This is the standard Objectivist stance, as I understand it.)

  4. You could point out where I have misinterpreted or misapplied the law of identity/causality. Since I don’t believe that I have, I can’t really be of much help on this one, but it would be the only valid rebuttal, if it is possible. :slight_smile:

These arguments, however, hold no weight at all:

  1. But, that means that we don’t have any choice! (Insert re-hash of OPAR here.) (This is invalid because it is a strawman.)

  2. The way that you put it, it’s fine, but that approach opens up the door for all sorts of “bad” determinists to get in. (What they say has nothing to do with me. Guilt-by-association. You can’t attack my argument based on your aversion to some other argument.)

  3. You were so rude to Jon KC! How can we believe what you have to say? (Ad hominem. One thing has nothing to do with the other.)

Clearly we DO have a choice in our actions. We all agree about that. What’s not at all obvious, however, is the implication that a predetermined universe, in which every entity (including Man) is bound strictly to the law of causality, is in conflict with that fact in any way. If you believe that it is, I invite you to prove it to me by showing that my argument is flawed.

However, if you do not believe that my argument is flawed, then the next step, of course, is unpacking what that would imply about choice, moral agency, rights, life, the universe, and everything. It is a subtle restructuring at a very deep level, to be sure. But truth cannot ever contradict truth. I put stock in the law of non-contradiction, and resolve these problems using logic. If it’s unsettling, well, that just means that there’s work to be done.

It is clear that we do not know enough about how the human mind works to say specifically which attribute(s) cause one’s choice to go one way or the other.

That’s true, but so what? If it has a cause then it is mechanistic.

In fact, since so much of the brain’s activity is on a microscopic - even subatomic level, it seems to me that the limits set by the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle imply that it is impossible to ever say exactly what those characteristics are.

And if it doesn’t have a cause then it is random.

John: Despite the mystics in modern physics, the HUP does NOT show that things ever happen for no reason. That was Heisenberg’s interpretation of his principle. The principle is true - his interpretation is invalid.[…]Do not be so arrogant as to confuse an epistemological limitation with a metaphysical fact.

Einstein thought as you do, till the day he died in 1955 he thought that the only reason some things appear to be random is that there are hidden factors we haven’t discovered yet influencing them. In 1964 a way was proposed to test if he was right or wrong and about 10 years later the experiment was actually performed, it’s called Bell’s Inequality. Because of that experiment we now know with certainty that Heisenberg was right and Einstein was wrong; this is how it works:

When a photon of undetermined polarization hits a polarizing filter there is a 50% chance it will make it through. For many years physicists who disliked the idea that God played dice with the universe figured there must be a hidden variable inside the photon that told it what to do. By “hidden variable” they meant something different about that particular photon that we just don’t know about. They meant something equivalent to a lookup table inside the photon that for one reason or another we are unable to access but the photon can when it wants to know if it should go through a filter or be stopped by one. We now understand that is impossible. In 1964 (but not published until 1967) John Bell showed that correlations that work by hidden variables must be less than or equal to a certain value, this is called Bell’s inequality. In experiment it was found that some correlations are actually greater than that value. Quantum Mechanics can explain this, classical physics or even classical logic can not.

Even if Quantum Mechanics is someday proven to be untrue Bell’s argument is still valid, in fact his original paper had no Quantum Mechanics in it; his point was that any successful theory about the world must explain why his inequality is violated. I will attempt to show how to find the inequality, show why it is perfectly logical, and demonstrate that nature refuses to be sensible and just doesn’t work the way you’d think it should.

I have a black box, it has a red light and a blue light on it, it also has a rotary switch with 6 connections at the

12,2,4,6,8 and 10 o’clock positions. The red and blue light blink in a manner that passes all known tests for being completely random, this is true regardless of what position the rotary switch is in. Such a box could be made and still be completely deterministic by just pre-computing 6 different random sequences and recording them as a lookup table in the box. Now the box would know which light to flash.

I have another black box. When both boxes have the same setting on their rotary switch they both produce the same random sequence of light flashes. This would also be easy to reproduce in a classical physics world, just record the same 6 random sequences in both boxes.

The set of boxes has another property, if the switches are set to opposite positions, 12 and 6 o’clock for example, there is a total negative correlation, when one flashes red the other box flashes blue and when one box flashes blue the other flashes red. This just makes it all the easier to make the boxes because now you only need to pre-calculate 3 random sequences, then just change every 1 to 0 and every

0 to 1 to get the other 3 sequences and record all 6 in both boxes.

The boxes have one more feature that makes things very interesting, if the rotary switch on a box is one notch different from the setting on the other box then the sequence of light flashes will on average be different 1 time in 4. How on Earth could I make the boxes behave like that? Well, I could change on average one entry in 4 of the 12 o’clock lookup table (hidden variable) sequence and make that the 2 o’clock table. Then change 1 in 4 of the 2 o’clock and make that the 4 o’clock, and change 1 in 4 of the 4 o’clock and make that the 6 o’clock. So now the light flashes on the box set at 2 o’clock is different from the box set at 12 o’clock on average by 1 flash in 4. The box set at 4 o’clock differs from the one set at 12 by 2 flashes in 4, and the one set at 6 differs from the one set at 12 by 3 flashes in 4.

But I said before that that boxes at opposite settings should have a 100% anti-correlation, the flashes on the box set at 12 o’clock should differ from the box set 6 o’clock by 4 flashes in 4 NOT 3 flashes in 4. Thus if the boxes work by hidden variables then when one is set to 12 o’clock and the other to 2 there MUST be a 2/3 correlation, at 4 a 1/3 correlation, and of course at 6 no correlation at all.

A correlation greater that 2/3, such as 3/4, for adjacent settings produces paradoxes, at least it would if you expected everything to work mechanistically because of some hidden variable involved.

Does this mean it’s impossible to make two boxes that have those specifications? Nope, but it does mean hidden variables can not be involved and that means something very weird is going on. Actually it would be quite easy to make a couple of boxes that behave like that, it’s just not easy to understand how that could be.

Photons behave in just this spooky manner, so to make the boxes all you need it 4 things:

1)A glorified light bulb, something that will make two photons of unspecified but identical polarization moving in opposite directions so you can send one to each box. An excited calcium atom would do the trick, or you could turn a green photon into two identical lower energy red photons with a crystal of potassium dihydrogen phosphate.

  1. light detector sensitive enough to observe just one photon. Incidentally the human eye is not quite good enough to do that but frog’s can, for frogs when light gets very weak it must stop getting dimmer and appear to flash.

3)A polarizing filter, we’ve had these for a century or more.

4)Some gears and pulleys so that each time the rotary switch is advanced one position the filter is advanced by 30 degrees. This is because it’s been known for many years that the amount of light polarized at 0 degrees that will make it through a polarizing filter set at X degrees is [COS (x)]^2; and if x = 30 DEGREES then the value is .75 If light is made of photons that translates to the probability any individual photon will make it through the filter is 75%.

The bottom line of all this is that there can not be something special about a specific photon, some internal difference, some hidden variable that determines if it makes it through a filter or not. Thus the universe is either non-deterministic or non-local, that is, everything influences everything else and does so without regard for time or space. One thing is certain, whatever the truth is it’s weird.

John K Clark

However, if you do not believe that my argument is flawed, then the next step, of course, is unpacking what that would imply about choice, moral agency, rights, life, the universe, and everything.  It is a subtle restructuring at a very deep level, to be sure.  But truth cannot ever contradict truth.  I put stock in the law of non-contradiction, and resolve these problems using logic.  If it’s unsettling, well, that just means that there’s work to be done.

Oh, but I am predetermined not to believe your argument! :wink:

Kidding aside,

If you want to really attack this argument, here are a few ideas:

[…]4) You could point out where I have misinterpreted or misapplied the law of identity/causality.

Here:

  1. You could posit some “spooky attribute” that can possibly cause both P and !P.  You could go out further on that limb, and state that only Man has this spooky attribute.  (I will counter by saying that this is a violation of the law of causality.  Actions are caused by the nature of the entities acting.  This sort of spooky attribute would cause an action that has no identity.

Why would it? This is a non-sequitur. Once the entity has caused the action, the action has identity. When I decide to buy a vanilla ice cream, I begin performing a specific action, and my action has a perfectly well-defined identity: namely, it is the action of buying a vanilla ice cream.

It is only until the entity has begun acting that the action has no identity (given that the action simply doesn’t exist yet). BTW this is just as true for non-volitional actions as for volitional ones.

Clearly we DO have a choice in our actions. We all agree about that. What’s not at all obvious, however, is the implication that a predetermined universe, in which every entity (including Man) is bound strictly to the law of causality, is in conflict with that fact in any way.

How would you define “choice” ?

Surely, CapForever, things that don’t exist don’t have identity. (Existence is identity, entity is its attributes, without attributes, it doesn’t exist, yadda yadda.)

The “spooky attribute” theory is specious because it seems to get around the alleged contradiction between predetermination and free will, but only by creating an exception to the law of causality. All actions are caused by the nature of the entity acting. (Another way to put this would be to say that their identity is determined by the identity of the acting entity. 6 of one, half-dozen of the other.) The spooky attribute says, “This action is caused by the nature of the entity acting, but the identity of the action is not determined by the identity of the acting entity.” Ie, the entity has some attribute(s) that can cause either P or !P. Which is to say, the identity of the action is not determined by the identity of the acting entity. (But we just said it was, so, it’s a contradiction - hence, “spooky”.)

Choice

The act of determining, generally in advance, the nature of an action that the chooser will take, when the action is caused by a mental process on the part of the chooser.

Unpack that a bit with a real-world example:

(A lot of this is still rough and very much off-the-cuff, so please don’t be too nitpicky! B) )

Let’s say that I am going to buy a car. (We’ll take for granted that I’ve already chosen to buy a car in the first place, whatever that entailed.) I’m in the lot, looking at different models. I’m not sure which car I am going to buy, although I know that I will buy one of them. The action (buying a particular car) will be determined by my nature. More specifically, it will be caused by a mental process. (It doesn’t make much sense to say that things caused by me, but not as a result of a mental process, are really “chosen” per se. When I’m out in the sun, I don’t burn quickly. That’s caused by my nature, but there’s no “choosing” about it, really.) However, at this point in time, I’m not sure which car I’m going to end up buying.

I weigh the options, the price, etc., visit a few different dealerships, take a few test drives. I then determine (maybe subconsciously, and certainly not in so many words!) that the car which it is most in my nature to buy is an Acura RSX Type S. I have thus chosen a type of car to buy.

I also consider other things, as well. Am I going to buy the car now, or wait until I’ve saved some more money? Am I going to finance, buy outright, or lease? Leather, or no? Etc, etc, etc. (In this real-world case, I determined that no other car would satisfy me like the RSX, and since I cannot yet afford it, I’m driving my roommate’s green boat to work for the time being. :wink: )

All of the actions that I take (including, in this case, delaying my purchase until a later date) are caused and determined by my nature. However, in advance (prior to choosing) I did not know what would happen. (Here’s where it gets really interesting!) Normally my ignorance wouldn’t matter - even if I don’t know that I won’t burn in the sun, it’s still not a choice I make. However, in this case, the action is caused by a mental process, and so, before I determine what my choice will be, nothing happens at all. (In many cases, there is a “default” that will take effect in the absence of a choice. In others, not making a choice is a choice in itself, of sorts.)

Choices can also be made implicitly - that is, without a fully explicit conscious process, even though the action is a result of a “mental process”. (This covers the “not making a choice is a choice of sorts” situations I mentioned.) The choice to focus/think or to evade is an implicit choice of this sort. It is caused by a mental process (meaning simply, my height and weight and whatnot probably have nothing to do with it.) My choice is the act of determining the outcome. In this case, however, once I know what the outcome will be, well, the outcome is. This differs from the car example because, with the car, I make my decision about the action, and then, later on down the road, I actually take the action. The deciding and the acting may be separated from one another in time. However, with choosing to think, the choice is performed sub- or “pre”-consciously (since it is the choice to be or not to be conscious.) Once the choice is made, the action is taken.

You have a lot of choices involving how you make your choices as well! Are you going to consider your own wellbeing as the criteria of your decision, or are you going to use the wellfare of others as your rule? Are you going to judge based on the immediate outcome, or based on the long-term effects, or some combination of both? Are you going to weigh options according to a process of logical evaluation, or will you simply accept uncritically whatever others/your emotions tell you? All of this is included in the “choice to think.” That choice includes the choice of how to think. (To paraphrase Peikoff, the mind is not a lightbulb that is simply turned on or off. It takes work.) In other words, the nature of the action - the outcome and quality of the choice and the resulting action - is determined by the nature of the entity acting.

This sounds really complicated the way that I’ve written it out here, but that’s simply due to my excited rush to respond before fully ironing out all the details in my explanation. My main point is that, once you properly distinguish the epistemological from the metaphysical (ie, what we know from what is,) the rest is basically busywork - ie, not brain surgery, and a situation where you can apply the earlier conclusions one after another and chug through the concepts and end up with a cogent explanation. But that explanation might not be quite what you expected to get. It’s like Newton’s laws. The axioms are stupid-simple, but applying them consistently is not always immediately obvious. Like any other concepts, they must be internalized and automatized and concretized, etc, etc.

One could say that choosing is, quite literally, “realizing one’s destiny,” in two different senses. First, “realize” in the sense of “to discover,” because it is the moment when we discern what is in our nature to do. Second, “realize” in the sense of “to make real,” because, prior to choosing, what existed was an entity with a specific nature - not an action or a plan. (Even though the future event was implicit in the nature of all the entities involved in the action, the implicit is an epistemological concept, not a metaphysical one. Metaphysics only cares about what IS. “Might be” is not a metaphysical concept, and neither are “implicit” or “possible.”)

Well, sorry for the length and the rambliness of this. I’m sure that I’ve given you all plenty of meat to tear into, and I’ll probably have to rephrase every concept over again more carefully :slight_smile: Maybe I’ll just edit it when the urge strikes me again. (It is my destiny, after all :stuck_out_tongue: )

Have fun.