Philosophy of Mathematics

How are “relations of quantity” as subject to study different and distinguishable from “quantity”?  
 

What do you mean by foundational?  And of “what”? In what sphere?  

Is mechanical structure and function foundational of experience?  Is a relation of mere causal connection even complete causal dependency foundational as between incommensurate spheres… shall we say the electromagnetic forces are one of the fundamentals of literary romantic poetry?  Is the strong force (without which all nuclei would not exist) foundational to a persons edifice of knowledge and experience?

Certainly from a third person physical analysis … indeed causation is fundamental to the physical results… but within the sphere of first person experience, fundamentality in that structure is of a kind in that structure.  The foundation and pillars are some kind of first or base experience … and yes but of course the whole things sits on the ground of physicality and causation but they are externals.

Are the foundations of Objectivity qua mental activity within that sphere or do they lie in the external ground of all things in existence?

1 Like

Thanks for sharing your questions, SL.

Knapp’s accusation against Aristotle is that in making quantity the subject of mathematics, one is diverted from the relationships among quantities that are pursued in mathematics such as Euclid’s (2014, 40). That is false. It is an outlandish disregard for Aristotle’s treatment of geometry. Knapp wanted to focus on relationships, which is fine and usual, and that focus is not a divergence from Aristotle and not unusual. He wanted to bolster Rand’s focus on measurement in general epistemology by counting it as (relationships and) the primitive of mathematics and as in our connection to the world in elementary mathematics. He enormously loosened what measurement is so as to claim that geometry of Euclid—whose theorems are of relationships, but not of measurements (no scaled rulers, etc.)—is about measurement. With this loose notion of measurement, Knapp tried to explicate what is going on in higher mathematics and keep the higher also tied to the world.

Far truer to mathematical practice and stronger in tying all to the world is the Franklin book mentioned by Eiuol upstream, which adds structure as topic of mathematics, joined with quantity.

To say that quantity is more fundamental than measurement, as Rand does in her exchange with Peikoff, is only as in saying that Existence is more fundamental than consciousness and is indeed required (as both object and life-supporter) for there to be consciousness (or any other living activities). I follow Rand on that and on the meaning of objectivity.

2 Likes

The strange thing about higher math is that even those like Hardy, who wanted it divorced from the world, and live in a realm of pure thought, find that even their most obscure, seemingly useless piece of math will often find a connection with the real world.

The one I like the best is, by using a suitable definition, 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 +… = -1/12.   We can see in the complex plane why it is so (analytic continuation holds, which does not apply to just real numbers), but it being so weird, we are inclined to say it is just a mathematical quirk.   Yet the usual explanation of the Casmir Force requires it.   To make matters worse, the typical answer (requiring virtual particles) is wrong - it is just a result of Van der Waals forces.   The interplay between math and the world can and does throw us curveballs.

1 Like