I’ll buy the argument 100% that Nautilus machines are safer for those who are learning or incompetent. It is simply untrue that by doing a snatch or clean properly you will destroy your skeleton. I know people (myself included) who are living proof that his claim is incorrect.
I would also agree that machines isolate individual muscles better. If you are looking for a beach body, I could see where utilizing a machine would be best.
However, fitness is not solely comprised of people aiming for big chests. Some people who exercise want to perform better on the job or athletic field and in order to do that, you need to engage in explosive lifts and other movements that can not be done on a machine. You need to incorporate movements that require balance and coordination which are things that machines will restrict- if not outright prohibit. Doing a pullup versus a lat machine or a jerk versus a shoulder press machine are a few examples.
That I think is the chief argument for barbells and free weights in general. Recruiting more muscles and requiring fast-twitch muscle fibers is more efficiently done with free weights versus safety for weekend warriors and greater muscle hypertrophy allowing more pump for muscle growth on machines. Fair enough I think. Maybe it depends on people’s goals. Functionality versus beach body.
There are many boxers who are fine, but it’s still not healthy practice to get your head beaten on a regular basis. Explosive movements, epsecialy movements with high skill requirements, are dangerous. A lot of people break themselves doing such things, and for no good reason.
Machines take away from the skill requirements and work the individual muscles more effectively. Skill(like balance and coordination) is specific and does not transfer well into other movements, but strength does. And since machines do make you stronger, they can build functional bodies.
Explosive free weights movements do not reqruit more muscles fibres. They only do so if you look at a specific repetition in a specific(limited) part of the ROM. To reqruit the most muscle fibres all you need to do is work the muscle to failure. And here a Nautlus machine will help you by providing variable resistance that follows the muscles force production. This is what makes the machines improved barbells, because the resistance they provide is superior to barbells.
Just for the record though, I personally train mostly with barbells, because that’s what they have at the gym where I train. And I have made some great changes to my body with the help of barbells, so I have nothing bad to say about the proper use of a barbell. I’m just saying good machines are a logical improvement of the same concept.
With that said though, I think this is a liiiitle bit off-topic. 