One of the most fascinating aspects of Ayn Rand’s writing was her belief in the power of physiognomy, “the art of judging human character from facial features.” This belief lies at the core of every one of her major works of fiction, and informs another cornerstone of her fiction, her belief in “love at first sight.”
While her belief in physiognomy is evident in all of her novels it is explicitly mentioned in one – The Fountainhead. In the novel the protagonist, Howard Roark, and the antagonist, Ellsworth Toohey both have a unique and penetrating insight into mens’ characters (or souls).
In Roark this knowledge is mostly on the subconscious or intuitive level. Roark is an excellent judge of character and personality, his faculty of which is so acute that he regularly gives other characters in his presence the feeling of having their innermost being x-rayed or peered in to. This ability allows him to quickly identify potential friends or enemies within a few seconds of meeting them. Because this faculty is on a subconscious level, he has trouble explaining how he finds “his kind of people.” When Austin Heller asks him, he replies:
“I don’t know.” Yes I do know, but I can’t explain it. I’ve often wished I could. There must be some principle to cover it, but I don’t know what it is."
“Honesty?”
"Yes . . . no, only partly. Guy Francon is an honest man, but it isn’t that. Courage? Ralstom Holcombe has courage in his own mannner . . . . I don’t know. I’m not that vague on other things. But I can tell my kind of people by their faces. By something in their faces.
Unlike Roark, Toohey’s insight into mens’ characters is not a matter of intuition or subconscious premises. He understands on a conscious level that the psychological and philosophical premises of a man’s character can be read from his face. This uncanny ability is made known to the reader when Toohey sees Roark for the first time. The scene is set in a large crowded room. Something about Roark stops him in his tracks:
There was another person, that night, abnormally aware of Roark’s presence. Ellsworth Toohey had seen him enter. Toohey had never set eyes on him before and did not know him. But Toohey stood looking at him for a long time.
…
He did not know the man’s name, his profession or his past; he had no need to know; it was not a man to him, but only a force; Toohey never saw men. Perhaps it was the fascination of seeing that particular force so explicitly personified in a human body
Toohey could see the force of Roark’s personality impressed into every aspect of his appearance. Without exchanging a single word with him, without knowing a single fact about him, without knowing anything but what was in front of his eyes he immediately seized Roark up as the type of person he was.
Later, he explains this ability to the hostess of the party, Kiki Holcombe:
“There’s nothing as significant as a human face. Nor as eloquent. We can never really know another person, except by our first glance at him. Because, in that glance, we know everything. Even though we’re not always wise enough to unravel the knowledge. Have you ever thought about the style of a soul, Kiki?”
“The…what?”
“The style of a soul. Do you remember the famous philosopher who spoke of the style of a civilization? He called it ‘style.’ He said it was the nearest word he could find for it. He said that every civilization has its one basic principle, one single, supreme determining conception, and every endeavor of men within that civilization is true, unconsciously and irrevocably, to that one principle. . . . I think, Kiki, that every human soul has a style of its own, also. Its one basic theme. You’ll see it reflected in every thought, every act, every wish of that person. The one absolute, the one imperative in that living creature. Years of studying a man won’t show it to you. His face will. You’d have to write volumes to describe a person. Think of his face. You need nothing else.”
“That sounds fantastic, Ellsworth. And unfair, if true. It would leave people naked before you.”
"It’s worse than that. It also leaves you naked before them. You betray yourself by the manner in which you react to a certain face. To a certain kind of face . . . The style of your soul . . .
While this is the most explicit she is in describing her belief in the importance of physiognomy, other examples of this premise can be found in Dominique’s initial meeting with Roark at the quarry, Kira’s first meeting with Leo in We the Living, Equality 7-2521 meeting Liberty 5-3000 in Anthem, and Francisco, Ragnar, and Galt “picking each other out by sight” in college. Please note that this is not an exhaustive list.
So, what does this all mean? What does it mean to be able to identify a man’s character based on his face? The easy assumption to make is that this equates to a belief in determinism, that a man’s future actions are set out for him at birth. The truth is much more complex.
The answer lies in first determining what a man’s character consists of. Again, the easy answer to say is that a man’s character is the sum of the choices he makes in life, which when analyzed can be abstracted into a set of beliefs that person holds, which can then be used to predict his future actions. This is perfectly reasonable. However this answer leaves out a key component: personality.
What is personality? Broadly, you could say a person’s personality is the most fundamental aspect of individuation. Even in infants you can observe personality traits emerging, such as stubborness, extroversion, introversion, degrees of intelligence, inquisitiveness, and levels of irritibility. An individual’s personality is complex and continues to develop as the child matures and his brain continues to grow. Eventually, a person’s personality reaches its final stages of maturation and you can observe and interact with a fully developed human being.
So, how does personality affect character? If we go back to the earlier definition of character as “the abstraction of the sum of expressed action” then we need to look at how people make choices.
How do people arrive at the choices they make? The possibilities seem to predicate on whim, emotion, or reason. I should note that these are broad categories which are not necessarily mutually exclusive.
The first of these categories, the whim, is too inclusive a cause to be easily deconstructed. A whim is defined as an “arbitrary thought or impulse” which could be caused by the willful abdication of thought (a loss of mental control) or it could be based on an emotion, or a rational thought. Whatever the origin of the whim, when it is indulged, it is characterized by a lack of overall rational deliberation. It’s execution is swift or immediate.
The second of these categories is emotion. Ayn Rand believed that emotions are automatic responses formed by subconsciously held metaphysical premises. These premises can be set by consciously held ideas programming the subconscious or by a process of automatic accumulation of experientailly drawn conclusions, or by unquestioningly assimilating outside ideas.
The third of these categories is reason. A full discussion of how a person uses reason in a decision making process would be too involved for the present discussion. Rand writes that “the method which reason employs in this process is logic—and logic is the art of non-contradictory identification.” What is important to note is that the key faculty in properly employing reason in the use of logic is intelligence.
Now consider how a person’s personality can affect the above three ways of arriving at choices.
Because personality is so complex it’s difficult to construct a model to use. Although not representative, for the sake of demonstration I’ll define a very simple personality. Let’s say a person of average intelligence has personality traits that include a high level of aggression, a weak level of curiosity, and a high degree of stubborness. A person with an average intellect who is not especially curious may not like reading too much. Instead, because of high levels of aggression that person may enjoy physical activity as a means of releasing it. Because of his stubborness, he has a disinclination to examine the validity of his choices, and may not learn easily from mistakes. That sort of personality would naturally gravitate toward decisions based on emotion and whim because they complement his general disposition – it is the path of least resistance. That doesn’t mean that this person is incapable of rational choice, but it does mean that this person will have a harder time choosing a rational choice when confronted with other options, under certain contexts.
So how does this all fit into the theory of physiognomy? The idea is that because personality and intelligence are genetically based, it may mean that these characteristics could be expressed in the genetic structure of a human face. As a science, Physiognomy would attempt to understand the genetic basis of such a connection and would attempt to discover the means to reliably interpret features into corresponding personality traits. Unfortunately, Physiognomy as a science is still at it’s very early stages. There have been historical attempts to develop physiognomy, but none of them have been scientifically rigorous.
What you may be wondering is if physiognomy as a field of study is still in its infancy whether one can draw any conclusions about whether it is valid or not. I would argue that you can. The means of doing so are your own life experiences.
From my own experience I can tell you that one of the easiest things you can read on a person’s face is intelligence or lack of intelligence. I can spot aggressiveness, stubborness, extroversion, introversion, and a whole host of other personality traits. All I have to do is study a person’s face for a few seconds and I can create a pretty accurate profile of his or her personality. I test this by then interacting with the person. I’m not always right, but I’m right enough of the time to know that it isn’t chance.
Here’s one ubiquitous example of physiognomy that just about everyone knows how to do: spot a bitch. Both men and women can spot a bitchy personality from a quick glance at a face. It’s not the style of makeup or how she grooms her face that tips people off, because those aren’t always factors. It’s the face. Something about the face that clues people in.
I also have a theory about how this works. I think that people who are attentive and sociable meet people with similar personality types thoughout the course of their life. If physiognomy holds true, then that person begins to automatically and subconsciously associate certain personality traits with certain features. Then, when that person meets a new person he automatically draws on past experiences to interpret commonly held features linked to memories of certain personalities and either likes or dislikes this new person’s face based on subconsciously held information.
Any thoughts?
Edit: Just realized I finally got to 500 posts! ![]()