Prisons In A Free Society

Rehabilitation is education: if it is not the function of government to provide education to non-criminals, it is not the function of government to provide education to criminals. In fact, the “prevention of rights violation” argument is a stand-in for a whole raft of state-sponsored social services. There is no denying that providing free housing, food, transportation, child care, medical care (etc. etc.) would prevent crime, on the premise that people are economically desparate and turn to a life of crime because they don’t know how to survive ethically. This is how the welfare clause of The Constitution got morphed into the welfare-state clause.

That is a very good point…

Is this kind of a system not creating an incentive for the prison system to want there to be more crime? . . . You can even imagine a situation where a corrupt prison actively frames poor vulnerable people, knowing they will end up in their prison making more profits for them.

We must rely on the eternal vigilance of the voters not to allow this.

If you had a privately run prison, it would have to make a profit. So they get the prisoners to produce goods which they then sell to pay for the prisoners food, prison upkeep, etc. The money left over is profit.

Is this kind of a system not creating an incentive for the prison system to want there to be more crime? Ie. if there is more crime, the prison gets more prisoners which makes them more profit. You can even imagine a situation where a corrupt prison actively frames poor vulnerable people, knowing they will end up in their prison making more profits for them.

There is room for corruption in any system. That does not make the system any less viable. If the cost for care of the prisoners is not covered byt the prison itself, then it has to come from somewhere, i.e. tax payers. I don’t very much like the fact that part of my income is used to support criminals.

There is room for corruption in any system. That does not make the system any less viable.

Indeed, the cynic’s objection comes down to this. Man has free will, man can chose to be evil, therefore is is always possible for any human institution that it will have a corrupt person in it. Non-corruptness cannot be guaranteed, so rational life is impossible. Pfft. Judges don’t encourage crime as a way to assure themselves employment.

Judges don’t encourage crime as a way to assure themselves employment.

Their employment is assured by the fact they are paid via taxes and don’t have to make a profit. However a private prison system would be under pressure to find prisoners.

If you had a privately run prison, it would have to make a profit. So they get the prisoners to produce goods which they then sell to pay for the prisoners food, prison upkeep, etc. The money left over is profit.

Is this kind of a system not creating an incentive for the prison system to want there to be more crime?

Good point. Two objections:

  1. The same potential for corruption would apply at least as much to governmentally run prisons. A bureaucrat who runs a bigger prison has more power (a bigger budget and more people reporting to him) and can expect more pay.

  2. One way to deal with problems of corruption arising from concentrations of power in or as a result of governmental actions is to design a system of checks and balances. An example of a balance would be to require by law that the prison (company or bureaucracy) set aside some percentage of the “wages” of prisoners and put that money into a fund that would pay a prisoner-advocate group – the equivalent of an ACLU. Perhaps there are technical objections to this particular proposal. Regardless, the point is that designing a system of checks and balances tends to either reduce the corruption or make it easier to expose or both.

Their employment is assured by the fact they are paid via taxes and don’t have to make a profit. However a private prison system would be under pressure to find prisoners.

If we got to a point in society where there were not enough prisoners and some of our prisons would have to shut down and consolidate, I’d be a very happy man. As it is, they parole people early simply because of lack of facilities. I do not think there is any reason to worry about a lack of prisoners at this point in time. As was stated elsewhere, a system of checks and balances would have to be created, and since the prisons would be contracting out to the government exclusively, they would have government oversight.

Wow, it has been so long since I’ve visited ObjectivismOnline, and even longer since I posted anything. In fact, I had to start all over and create a new account. It’s nice to see all of the progress that has been made. This really has become a fine website!

I’m excited about jumping right in to a discussion about a subject that I happen to have a fairly solid position on. It may turn out to be just a grandiose theory after you chaps and chapettes are done with it, but I’ll put it out there nonetheless.

Even though I haven’t been around for awhile, it’s still safe to assume that the notion that no person has a right to the time, effort, or property of another person is widely accepted in these parts right? Well, if that notion is correct when it comes to private, innocent citizens in a society, it certainly should be the case when it comes to their relations with convicted criminals.

Not only do I reject prison, I reject any and all forms of criminal punishment or rehabilitation as qualifying for the government’s attention.

My position is rather extreme and on the surface may seem illogical. However, after entertaining alot of credible objections to it, I have yet to find one that I consider valid. Let me tell you why. Although they are commonly thought of as seperate approaches, punishment (simple incarceration) and rehabilitation (incarceration with frills) amount to the same thing and travel on the same altruistic track; one rail being made of contempt and the other of compassion. Yes, ultimately, the selfish interests of the individuals making up society are served with either, but at what cost? This is not a question that society, through it’s spokespeople in government, should have to answer. Why should society have to pay at all to correct the ills caused by the immoral actions of individual citizens?

When a criminal is sentenced to a term in prison, he loses all of his rights as an individual. If he retains any right to life, it is only the right to any life he may enjoy after the completion of his sentence. During his sentence, however, he exists by permission of his captors - be that the government or a private entity. His actions have proven to the world that he does not understand or respect the principles necessary for life. Just like anyone on the outside, an incarcerated criminal should have to earn his living.

Which brings me to the nuts and bolts of my theory. I believe that once a criminal is tried, convicted, and sentenced, an auction should be held where that criminal is sold to the highest (private) bidder. If no one bids, that criminal should be summarily executed (And pay for the cost of the bullet if possible), regardless of the severity of the crime he committed or the length of his sentence.

Of course, this would rarely happen since some sort of value can be squeezed out of virtually everyone - even the most hardened of criminals. In fact, as I’m writing this I’m desperately trying to think of an example of someone who is absolutely useless - even when compelled to be useful at the point of a gun. But even if such a creature did exist, the point would be moot since the trigger would be pulled anyways.

This is where private enterprise enters my house of cards. Companies that own and operate prisons would compete for the least violent and most cooperative prisoners. In fact, amongst the best of them, I can imagine some prisons existing as job training institutes, that receive their revenue from the companies that hire their “graduates”. From my understanding, this is essentially the thinking behind the government subsidy-laden halfway houses we have today.

On the other hand, the prisoners themselves would compete for better assignments within the facilities of their new owners, or for transfers (“career moves”) to better facilities with possibly more opportunity and better living conditions. All the while, whether they realized it or not, these inmates would be cultivating all the virtues that extended participation in a market-economy requires.

Of course I only addressed the extremes; the best and the worst. The vast majority of criminals, and the companies that acquire them, are somewhere in between. While their redeeming qualities are overshadowed by their negative qualities, the notion of advancement in these places would only extend as far as an extra meal, a fluffier pillow, or a slightly less back-breaking job. But unlike in a government prison, where those things are acquired by intimidation and brutality, they would be the result of for-profit cooperation amongst a freely selected aggregate of prisoners.

So now I suppose I must address the issue of security. The government must make it perfectly clear to any bidder that he is assuming a dangerous liability. I do not think it is necessary for the government to proscribe specific standards of security for guarding prisoners for the same reasons I do not think it is necessary for the government to set security standards for anything. If a company wishes to stay in business, and avoid massive negligence lawsuits and devestation to it’s reputation, it will take the steps necessary to protect itself (and in turn, society). It’s the same situation if the dangerous substance being guarded is TNT or flesh and blood. Now that I think about it, this is similar to BurgessLau’s earlier post discussing the concept of bonding out - only better.

So there’s my theory, I hope I didn’t elaborate too much or we won’t have anything to haggle over. However, I think I framed my arguments in a manner compelling enough to ensure that I won’t be laughed off of ObjectivismOnline for another 3 years!

Cheers,

Grant

Which brings me to the nuts and bolts of my theory. I believe that once a criminal is tried, convicted, and sentenced, an auction should be held where that criminal is sold to the highest (private) bidder. If no one bids, that criminal should be summarily executed (And pay for the cost of the bullet if possible), regardless of the severity of the crime he committed or the length of his sentence.

This would never work simply for the fact that those with rich friends could buy out the prisoner and set him free with no punishment at all. The other side is that all infractions of the law are not the same. A child shoplifting a 5 dollar toy does not equal the crime of a murderer or rapist. The courts and prison system is simply a means for the government to civily punish those that break the law on behalf of it’s citizens, otherwise you have an anarchy. You can not run a nation by punishing every crime with assigning a monetary value to someone’s life and if no one is willing to pay it they forfiet their life. That’s a police state that breeds terror.

ggdwill,

You’re kidding right? In my opinon that has to be the worst idea for a prison system ever. I don’t want criminals to be advancing and earning better living conditions, I want them to sit in a cell and think about what they have done.

Also, the value of a prisoner would be very high I think. This is what I was saying before, that there is an incentive to have prisoners. An example would be in the film “Shawshank Redemption”. The guy was a very valuable prisoner by doing all the tax forms, and so the head of the prison kept him there.

Finally, I don’t think the state should have the right to kill anyone.

Finally, I don’t think the state should have the right to kill anyone.

You are a pacifist? On what philosophy are you basing your position?

Bonding out means that the prisoner or his supporters would put up money for a bond (if that is the right word) as a sign of their commitment to making sure the prisoner will not commit another crime once he is let loose. To avoid losing that money, the prisoner’s supporters will need to watch him very closely.

This is an interesting proposal but I am curious about one aspect of it; would the “supporters” gain some “right” to use force against the person they bonded out in order to protect their investment? How can they prevent him from committing more crime?

First, please remember I offered this bonding-out idea only as an example of what might be done. I don’t want to debate its propriety.

How would the qualified convict be prevented from committing more crimes? One way is simply very close supervision by the supporters. (A lot of money is at stake.) That level of supervision tends to discourage certain types of criminals, doesn’t it? Active community policing, down to the level of active ticketing for minor infractions, certainly seems to have that sort of effect – judging from local news accounts.

Another way is by ad hoc physical restraint, which is a right that others have when they see a crime about to happen and there isn’t enough time for the police to arrive.

A third point to keep in mind is that “home detention” – whatever the right term may be – is already in practice for some criminals, either before or after conviction, is it not? Perhaps you could briefly describe how that works. My “knowledge” of this comes only from news accounts.

Keep in mind too that this proposal is not for all criminals, only the ones that the courts and the criminals’ supporters think are suitable risks.

Some good points guys…

This would never work simply for the fact that those with rich friends could buy out the prisoner and set him free with no punishment at all.

Requiring that the bidder keep his new purchase in custody the entire length of his sentence would be part of the terms the government sets at the time of sale. To do otherwise would be a breach of contract, and probably a criminal act itself. I can see how you misunderstood me. I should have specifically pointed that out. I was just relying on a literal appreciation of the word “sentence”; something not commonly experienced in today’s legal environment.

The other side is that all infractions of the law are not the same. A child shoplifting a 5 dollar toy does not equal the crime of a murderer or rapist.

This is the most common objection I hear. You’re right, not all crimes are the same in terms of the impact they have on their victim(s). What I’m pointing out is that that is irrelevant. Here’s why: The government, in a free society, would not differentiate between someone who was born with some handicap that made them incapable of supporting their own life and someone who lazily pissed it away. Neither situation is a valid reason to have the government - ie, the taxpayers - continue to suppor their lives. So why is committing a crime a valid reason?

ggdwill,

I don’t want criminals to be advancing and earning better living conditions, I want them to sit in a cell and think about what they have done.

Well, under my plan, that would literally be none of your business.

Also, the value of a prisoner would be very high I think. This is what I was saying before, that there is an incentive to have prisoners. An example would be in the film “Shawshank Redemption”. The guy was a very valuable prisoner by doing all the tax forms, and so the head of the prison kept him there.

As I pointed out a moment ago, just as a bidder would be required to keep the prisoner the length of his sentence, he would also be required to release the prisoner once the sentence is completed.

But sorry, not good enough :homestar:

This is the most common objection I hear. You’re right, not all crimes are the same in terms of the impact they have on their victim(s). What I’m pointing out is that that is irrelevant. Here’s why: The government, in a free society, would not differentiate between someone who was born with some handicap that made them incapable of supporting their own life and someone who lazily pissed it away. Neither situation is a valid reason to have the government - ie, the taxpayers - continue to suppor their lives. So why is committing a crime a valid reason?

“I hate Steve because he stole my car” and “I hate Steve because he’s black” are different; just because I hate Steve in both cases doesn’t mean I hate him for the same reason. “Jimmy is a criminal because he stole 5 bucks from the supermarket” and “Jimmy is a criminal because he raped, murdered, and then raped my wife again” are different; just because Jimmy is a criminal in both cases doesn’t mean he’s a criminal for the same reason or degree.

Correct me if I’m wrong, but I have serious doubts that Objectivism supports an absolute as extreme as “Slavery or death!” to all crimes. Lets say a paraplegic teenager stole my Rolex. I accidently dropped it in her lap and she turned and gunned her little motorized wheelchair out of there. Yet when caught, she was unable to produce anything of value to anyone (and no one participating in your slave-trade wanted a paraplegic), your answer would be: kill the @^%#$! If the experience is enough to rehabilitate her (but she lost the watch), what then is your answer? Since all criminals must either repent for their sins or get a bullet between the eyes, you kill a rehabilitated paraplegic? The severity of the crime is, after all, “irrelevant!” She’s just as bad as any crazed necrophiliac chainsaw murderer, so if she can’t offer a return on anyone’s investment, cap her! She has forfeited her right to life and as such is at the disposal of anyone who wants to dispense a little “justice.”

If someone does a crime, it is not my obligation to support his prison or buy his food or anything else. That doesn’t mean I have to or even should kill him if he is of no value (or threat) to me. What rational self-interest do I have in killing a 13-year old paraplegic girl? Because I have a profit motive and she’s a dependent (but not mine), I should kill her? Do I really like that spiffy new wheelchair? I think it’s pretty obvious she’s not stealing from me again, unless I accidently drop my watch into her lap *again*. So maybe it’s my responsibility to society that should prompt me to kill her. I mean, her mom’s probably sick of supporting her, so I should probably just shoot her. After all, because it’s no one’s obligation to support a dependent, I should just go ahead and assume that no one’s holding that optional value.

“To refuse to sanction evil does not necessarily involve accosting its representatives, if no purpose is served thereby.” -OPAR p285

ggdwill, what is justice? In your philosophy, what does that concept mean?

You are a pacifist? On what philosophy are you basing your position?

I’m not sure what I based my position on apart from vague feelings, therefore I am open to persuasion. Is the death penalty required for the worst crimes because of justice? Ie, an eye for an eye?

If you had a privately run prison, it would have to make a profit.

Says who?

The Ayn Rand Institute is run privately, but it doesn’t “have to” make a profit.

Some good points guys…

Requiring that the bidder keep his new purchase in custody the entire length of his sentence would be part of the terms the government sets at the time of sale. To do otherwise would be a breach of contract, and probably a criminal act itself. I can see how you misunderstood me. I should have specifically pointed that out. I was just relying on a literal appreciation of the word “sentence”; something not commonly experienced in today’s legal environment.

What then should this rich person’s friends do to make sure he is serving a sentence? Make him wash his own clothes? Deny him maid service? No cable? What does this kind of punishment gain anyone?

This is the most common objection I hear. You’re right, not all crimes are the same in terms of the impact they have on their victim(s). What I’m pointing out is that that is irrelevant. Here’s why: The government, in a free society, would not differentiate between someone who was born with some handicap that made them incapable of supporting their own life and someone who lazily pissed it away. Neither situation is a valid reason to have the government - ie, the taxpayers - continue to suppor their lives. So why is committing a crime a valid reason?

So if I am understanding your arguments here, anyone incapable of leading a rational life would be “put down” since they are a failed individual. If a person commits a crime then they are also an irrational person, so once again they should be disposed of. I think it is arguments like this that cause others not understanding objectivism to call it facist. Give me one logical reason why a person who commits the smallest crime deserves death. A government that only protects a rational reasoning person and disposes of those that aren’t is not a good reason, that is not what a government is about.

Note that the majority of criminals are not rights violators,

That is the case now. It wouldn’t be the case in a free society. People who do not violate rights shouldn’t be sent to prison.

Rehabilitation is education: if it is not the function of government to provide education to non-criminals, it is not the function of government to provide education to criminals.

I’m not sure it’s education. I see it more as psychotherapy. Now you’ll remind me that isn’t a government function, either. I agree. Except that in some cases it is or may be. For example, prisoners receive medical care at least paid for by the government (denying it would be cruel and unusual punishment).

Of course, this opens other doors, such as labeling all criminals mentally ill, which can then be taken as a powerful precedent if the government becomes tyranical (I can see some of the more extreme liberals compassionately curing conservatives, and us).

There is no denying that providing free housing, food, transportation, child care, medical care (etc. etc.) would prevent crime, on the premise that people are economically desparate and turn to a life of crime because they don’t know how to survive ethically. This is how the welfare clause of The Constitution got morphed into the welfare-state clause.

It might reduce some crimes. People sometimes do turn to crime out of desperation. But it would require the bigger crime that is the welfare state, which I don’t think I need to go into just now.

Let me put a different question: how far does, and should, the government go to prevent crime? For instance, would you object to the police giving lectures about securing one’s property (like what kind of locks are harder to pick, what inds of car alarms work best, etc etc)?

“Jimmy is a criminal because he stole 5 bucks from the supermarket” and “Jimmy is a criminal because he raped, murdered, and then raped my wife again” are different; just because Jimmy is a criminal in both cases doesn’t mean he’s a criminal for the same reason or degree.

Absolutelyy true.

A man who steals 5 bucks won’t receive the same punishment as one who raped your wife, nor should they.

However, a crippled man who steals five bucks would be punished the same way as a fit man who stole five bucks. A black man who rapes your wife should receive the same punishment as a white man who rapes your wife.

More important, a cripple who steals is as guilty of stealing as a fit man would be. A judge may be more lenient towards a cripple. Judges should have certain discretion. But the guilt remains.