“I’d like to see prisons designed in a way that lets prisoners pay for their keep by doing some productive work.”
I actually thought of this prospect after getting off of the computer on the night of my posting. The prisoners could be expected to work in some manner – otherwise, their food and supplies are being provided free of charge when those of us who refrain from slaughtering cities are struggling to earn these necessities by our own productive effort.
“Probably a good percentage of inmates are not there for violating contract or other’s rights”.
You are correct on this count. I do not believe that drug users, for instance, should be arrested. However, in the event that they initiate force against other individuals, even while under the influence, they are to be held accountable for their actions. Even so, I am discussing prisons in a rational, (Objectivist)/ Capitalist society - not prisons in the present. As of right now, taxation is mandatory and the matter is not up for debate.
“The Solution to Crime is to have enough countries so that criminals can be expelled, not concentrated, and deal among themselves.”
This is an interesting idea, but many of your views about multiple and competing police forces seem to stem from the anarchist philosophy, which I strongly disagree with.
Hi Summer. It’s an interesting question, prisons as they are epitomize the altruist concept of feeding your enemy - to the direct benefit of no one. Working has been tried in the past, but the simple truth APPEARS to be that brute labor doesn’t produce enough to mantain a hi tec retention compound. (However this has not been tried in modern times as far as I know, and maybe if the prisoners were leased to a private company, then they could pay for their existence. But with the current laws that can land a man in prison this would be a de facto return to slavery).
If government is instituted with the individual consent of each citizen (which I consider something Ayn Rand would favor) then breaching that contract leaves you liable to the penalties you agreed to on the first place.
These can be, confiscation of assets, real estate, medical estate (organs), or why not? exile.
Since we are not living in a society where the culture is predominantly Obectivist or even Rational, I have no way to answer the question about prisons in an hypothetical country - be that a future America or any other of the 180?+ already existing sovereign territories.
I don’t believe in Anarchy, as in I consider it a fancy name for a state of chaos only found in between enemy lines, or those sort of situations. Anarchy means No Government - of any kind - why do I have to in an Obectivist Forum explain that I talk literally?
I never suggested competing police forces. At all. I suggest that the already existing countries are already beginning to compete and I suggest that could further the establishment of Governments that know their place.
As for the question about prisons, I still believe dangerous guilty criminal inmates should be deprived of their nationality - not as retribution, not as reformation, but as the logical consequence of a broken deal.
Why is this contractual approach not the most compatible with a Capitalist Society, or an Objectivist Culture?