Basically as long as there are legal channels to increase profit, I don’t see why a private business wouldn’t do it.
Is that a normative claim or a descriptive one? It is true that some people, even those who run businesses, will engage in all sorts of legal immorality to increase their supply of cash – they will actively lobby for subsidies for their businesses, work to create new government giveaways, seek protection from loss when business isn’t ideal. But there are many reasons why a business shouldn’t advocate violating people’s right. I assume you know what the reasons are.
Do you consider private prisons using legal and voluntary means to enthusiastically enforce the law bad? I see no problem with this as long as the laws are generally good.
Of course if there are bad laws or poorly worded laws then it would be a problem if such organizations would choose to unethically exploit them. But all this shows is that if the laws of a nation are bad, then the residents probably have much more important things to worry about than whether or not their prisons are privatized.
It depends on context. Private prisons are generally heavily subsidized in the first place. If they advocate for harsher laws than necessary, they’re basically using tax money to fund campaigns that proposes that we spend even more tax money on enforcement, indictment, and incarceration.
The US prison system is dominated by minorities. A majority of them are incarcerated is drug related crimes. US annually spends billions of dollars on the war on drugs, and most of those money go towards fighting marijuana. We still have mandatory sentences for drug trafficking that often times puts weed dealers in jail far longer than men that convicted rape or assault, with no possibility for parole.
Now if I was a private prison, those would be the laws I lobby for. Are those laws bad? Some people think so, some people don’t. Most people probably don’t even care. After all the only people it really affect are poor minorities.
Is that a normative claim or a descriptive one? It is true that some people, even those who run businesses, will engage in all sorts of legal immorality to increase their supply of cash – they will actively lobby for subsidies for their businesses, work to create new government giveaways, seek protection from loss when business isn’t ideal. But there are many reasons why a business shouldn’t advocate violating people’s right. I assume you know what the reasons are.
Normative, from my experience working in finance. In fact most large corporations have teams of accountants and lawyers working around the clock just to figure out legal (and sometimes illegal or borderline) ways for which they can squeeze out money, as well as funding political campaigns and lobbying for advantageous laws. Look at how many white collar corporate scandals you see nowadays, and picture that as only the tip of the iceberg.
A publically traded corporation as an entity is pretty much amoral - they exist only to increase the value of the shareholder’s stock. The whole system is designed from the bottom up for that sole purpose. Not for the greater good, not for philosophy or morality, but for profit. Corporate interaction is more akin to interactions between countries than interactions between men. They will always go for something when its deemed advantageous, anything that gives them that extra point of market share, as long as its legal.
Normative, from my experience working in finance.
Alright, then here is why. First, a business is a reflection of its creator’s and owners’ values, and living by the violation of rights is not a rational means of survival. Second, from a simple bottom-line perspective, surviving by the violation of rights is only possible if rights-principles themselves are destroyed, which translates into the numerous bad consequences for the business, such as the conclusion that other people’ obligations to you under contract are not valid, and that you too are fair fodder for those seeking a sacrificial animal. So in order to live off of the blood of others, you must destroy the principles that would prevent them from living off of your blood. Working towards your own destruction is the essence of immorality, which is why you shouldn’t do it.
Thanks for answering a question that I never actually asked
. But that doesn’t really have anything to do with what I said.
I’m not arguing that it should be done. I’m telling you that it is consistently practiced in reality, and therefore I don’t see why a private prison wouldn’t do it if the money is there to be made. Yes you’re right, a corporation is a reflection of its owner’s values. And by far the greatest of their values is “making money”.
Now admittedly I’m not well-versed in objectivism, since I found this site only because I really liked The Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged. Could you elaborate on what you mean by living off violating others rights is not a rational mean of survival? Specifically, what are the “rights”, what do you mean by “survival” (since I sense that there’s a very specific meaning of survival that you’re referring to), and finally why is it irrational?
By the way, given that your explanation on immorality is correct, it would pretty much mean that our system is already completely corrupted. So would an objectivist be obligated to fix the system?
I’m not arguing that it should be done.
Is that you don’t know what “normative” means?
I thought it meant that the practice is of the norm or standard…
Sorry English isn’t my first language. I just looked up the word, and if by normative you mean that I favor the stance, then I retract my word. But if by normative you meant that such acts pertains to the norm, then I stand by what I said.
I thought it meant that the practice is of the norm or standard…
Ah, that explains it. It’s a term of art. It refers to a prescription of what you should do; of course some people say “you should do what most people do”.
You misunderstood my reply: I was pointing out how ridiculous the entire argument was that you advanced, that it reduces to the absurdity that man must be the slave of the state, in order to be protected from possible misdeeds. You failed to get the point that all of life could be reduced to state-run paternalism, motivated by the fear that a corrupt person would somehow influence the government in order to win special treatment, and thus groceries, shoes, and music would have to be state-run to protect against corruption. That, or maybe the idea that people could act in a corrupt manner is not a justification for having government run businesses.
… And yet you, for some spectacularly unimaginable reason, overlook the fact that I rejected that very line of reasoning.