Simply stating that they are different does not make them different.
Ok, let’s assume they are the same and extrapolate to other things and see if we hit a contradiction. I pay money to buy a house. By the definition of property used above, I am giving property to recieve property. In fact all commerce becomes a circular loop of giving A to recieve A, which doesn’t make sense. The only way for it to make sense is that I give A to recieve B. Taking that back to before it is not the case that I am having A stolen to protect A. I am giving A to protect {A,B,C,D…Z} (where A= money, B= house, C = car, D = peace of mind, E = etc etc.)
For government funding to be moral, it must be done voluntarily.
Ideally yes. But lets think about this. Lets say I want a military in my country to protect my property. And not just me, most of my fellow countrymen do. But not everyone. Lets say some small group (5% or so) doesn’t want a military. Some may have rational reasons (hey I live in Montanna what do I care), some may have irrational reasons (hey we have a local militia that is sufficient). Do they have to pay? If so then it is not voluntary.
If not then do you exempt them of the benefits? CAN you exempt them of those benefits? I would argue that you can’t, not if you want to maintain any concept of a country (otherwise it would be “ok so we will allow this guys house to be conquered, but not this guys”). It’s also highly innefficient. So you protect them as well and they recieve benefits that they have not paid for.
They, in fact, have assaulted my property because it lowers the amount of military protection I recieve for my investment because I am subsidizing their protection, desired or not.
The reality, as opposed to the metaphysical reality, is that government can never be voluntary for all participants all the time, because it is composed of individuals trying to come to a unified purpose. Which, dirty a word as it might be, requires compromise. The best hope would be that everyone gets what they want most of the time, and the costs of the compromises they make do not outweigh the benefits of unified spending: ie it is a net positive for them.
This is not Rand’s view, nor the view of anyone I have encountered here, myself included.
I apologize, that was a pretty broad generalization/unfair representation.
You lack the philosophical framework by which to properly analyze whether or not something is in one’s rational self interest. Simply claiming that some specific situation is beneficial to some specific people for some period of time does not mean that it is in one’s rational self-interest.
I’m not really sure what you’re saying here. What I’m hearing is “Just because it’s good for you doesn’t mean it’s in your self interest” which I don’t think is what you’re actually saying.
So that is your true standard of morality - utility.
Dude you just selectively quoted me and removed the line that provided context (does the level of education in my vicinity protect/enhance/threaten my property.)
Anyways, my standard of morality is self-interest and intellectual honesty, And yeah, depending on how you define utility there are ties there. But my guess is that here you are talking about Utility with a capital U and trying to bring up the utilitarian vs objectivist argument, which is interesting when you talk about government spending.
All government spending involves using a “greater good” argument to justify the use of force to collect taxes to pay for said spending. This is effectively utilitarian in nature and against Objectivism IFF there are people who do not agree that the “greater good” serves their self interest, people who are being forced to work against themselves or towards something that has no value to them.
They question then again is “could there ever be a type of government spending that everyone can agree on, or those that don’t agree with it can be exempted from the benefits at no additional cost.”
In a country of 300 million people I don’t believe this is remotely possible for any spending. I don’t consider that conclusion utilitarian though, I consider it to be acknowledging reality.