“A is no longer A. Yes, it has very much the same characteristics as A, but it has changed”
You have the beginnings of a Heraclitian argument here. Of course, skepticism always has a basis in Heraclitian philosophy - because everything supposedly changes, how can one claim ‘knowledge’ of anything? That is the Heraclitian root of skepticism.
Like you, Heraclitus also stated stated that change exists all around us. He stated everything changes and is always changing. He is the source of the saying “A man cannot step into the same river twice”.
From this starting point, Heraclitus determined that change involves contradiction. His view was: after ‘change’ we have the same thing which is not the same (“it has very much the same characteristics as A, but it has changed” - ie is no longer A but something else), as opposed to substitution, where we have a different thing from that which existed before. As such, a ‘changing’ thing is an ‘identity’ of opposites. It both is and is not what it was and what it will be.
This is an obvious contradiction. And BECAUSE it is an obvious contradiction, Heraclitus came to the conclusion that change *necessarily* involves contradiction. Furthermore, because all the world involves change, the world itself is contradictory.
Now, where Heraclitus acknowledged the contradiction and proceeded to discarded the concept identity because of it, you seek to obliterate the concept identity by attempting to integrate contradiction INTO identity. And you do this with a simple word substitution.
You substitute the term “duality” for “contradiction”.
But such a substitution does not change the nature of the concepts involved. The contradiction still exists. And you accept it as valid.
Since both logic and identity state contradiction does not and cannot exist, this means the acceptance of contradiction (your so-called “duality”) is a rejection of BOTH logic and identity.
Based upon this, if you had answered my questions DIRECTLY, as I asked MULTIPLE times, the responses would have been something like this:
1a. The Law of Identity is a ‘mature’ law.
1b. It is a ‘mature’ law because all things have identity. BUT all things ‘change’ as well. So identity includes “duality” (contradiction).
2a. The Law of Identity is a mature law, so I can make the claim to rationality. And I can claim rationality because I do not accept contradiction. I accept “duality”.
2b. See 2a
3a. As I said, I don’t accept contradiction. I accept “duality”. I accept that a thing can have two opposite attributes and NOT be considered a contradiction. For example, a stick is solid. But it is also NOT solid (when observed in water) - just as a photon is both a wave and not a wave (or is both a particle and not a particle) - depending upon the observation of course. Surely you don’t consider THAT a contradiction!
3b. I claim logic because I accept “duality” NOT contradiction.
–
As an aside to the last sentence in your prior post, I find it unfortunate that I must point out that evasion is not an accepted form of discourse here and that warning against FURTHER evasion is NOT, as you termed it “fatuous”. To answer your question DIRECTLY:
Yes - it IS in my ‘nature’ to WARN people that their IRRATIONAL approach to discussion has NO intellectual content and as such will NOT be tolerated. In fact, since I am a moderator, it is part of my JOB to make such warnings. IF you have a problem with such warnings, I suggest pursuing your form of discourse elsewhere, because you will receive them any time you engage in such practices.
I hope that makes the point crystal clear to you now.