Reification and Suicide

13 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

Right, it is my term, to detail my position as based on distinguishing two kinds of pain. I don’t know if you agree these are kinds of pain, or if you see this as a pointless distinction.

I don’t understand your terms, or the manner in which you use them, to the point where I could say whether they are a “pointless distinction.”

If “existential pain” is “a nihilist’s sense of life” or etc., then that has nothing to do with this thread (or my participation in it, at least). If it is used to refer to the sadness that a rational human being might experience, being diagnosed with brain cancer, then it can be meaningful to that degree – but then why not simply refer to sadness?

If it is meant to conflate these very different sorts of things, as I suspect you have done, then it does much more damage.

And your use of “stimulus” seems worthless at best. If we are discussing pain (e.g. “physical pain,” like “torture”), why not use the word we already have for it? – Pain.

And what’s more (and worse), “stimulus” seems to capture part of pain, but not all of it. By describing pain as “stimulus,” we are losing vital information. Only a Nazi “doctor” would think to describe the sensations of the thumbscrew he administers as a “stimulus,” but at least there I can understand why; he seeks to hide himself from reality…

13 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

“You’d been asking about Maynard and I responded, and… bloop! It’s all seemingly vanished here, replaced by a fresh set of questions! (Is “bloop” an onomatopoeia suited to that experience?)”

I honestly don’t know or missed how prior answers answered this part.

It’s not my intention to “answer this part.” It is to express my frustration that I answer your questions and receive no feedback that relates to my responses, but only more questions. It seems an endless pit.

And moreover, your questions are increasingly abstract and vague. Why shouldn’t we go back to discussing Maynard? Or the spies that MisterSwig introduced in… another thread? Or anything concrete?

This is a familiar pattern to me, Eiuol, and I have less and less patience for it.

13 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

“Error. Ignorance. Circumstance. Results.”

Error is not a hindrance to virtue; virtue is a method, not a result.

You did not ask whether error was “a hindrance to virtue”; you asked “what makes one unhappy…if not a lack of virtue?”

One answer to that question is “error.”

Let’s work from something (Rand via Galt, again):

Quote

Happiness is the successful state of life, pain is an agent of death. Happiness is that state of consciousness which proceeds from the achievement of one’s values.

If “happiness is the successful state of life” or “happiness is that state of consciousness which proceeds from the achievement of one’s values,” then another way of phrasing your initial question is “what can keep one from ‘the successful state of life’” or “what can prevent one from the achievement of his values”?

Potentially, error can. As can “ignorance,” “circumstance,” and more generally, “results”:

I attempt to achieve my values, acting virtuously, BUT…

…I make an error in my calculations, or
…I am ignorant of relevant information, or
…circumstances are unfavorable, and thus, in result…

…I fail to achieve my values, and thus I do not experience “that state of consciousness which proceeds from the achievement of one’s values.”

“Virtue is a method, not a result”? Yes. But happiness (as “success” as “achievement”) is a result, and while virtuous action is a method of achieving happiness – the best we can devise, and the only I would recommend – it does not guarantee that result.

13 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

It may turn out that the method was not virtue. But if it is virtue in fact, you won’t be unhappy. To not try to fix error is vice.

Ignorance, if willful, is vice. Otherwise, it is error.

Circumstance only alter how to apply or discover virtue. It is not the cause of happiness. So, we go back to error.

Results are either error or vice.

Any disagreement there?

This is utterly mind numbing. Let’s get back to discussing concretes, please.