The is bad marketing, to say the least. We have to push for the right sort of principles to move government in the right direction, but its important to do this as skillfully as possible.
In a proper government, most taxes would be use-based (and voluntary). Given that, it would follow that “rich” people would generally pay a lot more for services than poor people since they have a lot more to protect. One could also imagine that “rich” people, having a lot more expendable income, would choose to spend a lot more on less tactical things like security and safety, would generally engage in more complex transactions that required more government work, and so forth. Poor people wouldn’t pay much since they wouldn’t use much. For instance, they might choose to buy a car without paying the sales “tax”, with the understanding that if the transaction is disputed, they would have no recourse. A rich person would generally make the opposite choice.
So instead of “tax the poor” the t-party dorks should be pushing for flat taxes, more use fees (increased prices at parks, post-office, etc.) and so forth.
Now why wouldn’t they be pushing for a flat tax? Let me see… could it have something to do with the fact that a zillion special interests support every one of those special tax breaks, and that the t-party, operating without any clear principle, is really just another form of politics-as-usual? You don’t hear the t-party dorks calling for the end of the interest deduction on homes, or the end of Prop 13 in California–two tax “breaks” that benefit a single special-interest and generally distort the free market for housing. You don’t hear them calling for the end of income taxes in favor of transaction use-taxes. For that matter, I personally don’t even hear the word “flat tax” these days as even the t-party people know that is politically untenable within their own ranks.
This sort of rhetoric exposes the t-party for what they are, which is a bunch of unprincipled children screaming for their own taxes to be lowered without regard to any of the “hard” issues like how we’re going to continue to pay for the welfare state they all live off of (I think the average age of t-party ding dongs is about 70) and how we’re going to continue to be the police of the whole world. This was exposed in vivid color in August when they injected needless panic into the markets by threatening to blow up everything in the short run if they didn’t get what they want, which is to have their cake and eat it too.
I never expected the t-party to live very long. I give them about one more election cycle. After that, reality will catch up with them, and they will return to supporting fatter social security checks regardless of what “other people” need to pay in taxes.
(The only POSITIVE thing that’s happened in the last couple of years is the death of Keynesianism, which had nothing do with the t-party, but more to do with a simple miscalculation of the necessary size of the original stimulus and good ole’ government corruption that watered what little was there down to almost nothing. For the foreseeable future, “stimulus” is going to have a bad name).
OP