22 - Enthymemes should not draw conclusions with all the steps, or going far back, because it is confusing for being too long, or it states the obvious. This is why less educated people tend to be more persuasive among crowds. Crowds like general arguments in universal terms. This suggests that enthymemes are meant to be condensed, they cannot be extensive syllogisms otherwise they fail their purpose.
Effective speeches do not use generic information.
23 - Aristotle has a list of topics (generalizable points to argue from in similar form) for speeches just as he does in Topics for dialectic argument. Many of the topics are the same.
Consider the time: “You would have done it before, so why not now?”
Turn things back to the one who sent them: “Not even you would do it, so why would I?”
Draw out a contradictory private view.
Refer to things that are supposed to happen and seem incredible. People don’t believe what could not be true or likely, so the thing believed must be true. Or at least, Aristotle is pointing out that this is how people tend to think, so that noting the truth of apparently improbable things is important for difficult arguments.
Explain the reasons for false impressions.
24 - There are fallacious ways to make speeches, where the argument doesn’t work.
Exaggerating a charge so that it seems worse is a way for them to make themselves look innocent by suggesting that of course they wouldn’t do something so extreme.
Leaving out the when and how. This is what happens when it is relevant to ask “who punched first” but no one asks. This is context dropping.
Mixing up what is so simply, with a particular case. It’s what happens when somebody says that something is not likely even though it did happen. The fact that it did happen basically means that it is likely. It is likely given the particular case with its context. Things are not simply likely or not, but in reference to circumstances. Necrovore does this in one post I’ve responded to.
Book III
1 - Rhetoric is relative to the listener. It should make something more clear. There is no special point here other than focusing on communication. Say what you mean, don’t make it fancy. Being like a poet is not appropriate for speeches or everyday talking.
3 - Cold or ineffective wording happens in 4 ways:
Compounded words
Eccentric words
Frequent, long, or unseasonable epithets (most posts by dream_weaver)
Metaphors that are a big stretch