Roark the dynamiter

Damn, the system mangled my post.<br /><br />J.<br />It may appear to a fair reader that I’ve been speaking of metaphysical values and moral virtues.<br />Somehow, individual rights do not protect one here, not that they should.<br /><br />“Cake and eat it”? I.E. When something is sold by one, you lose control of it. Yes.<br />Who’s arguing that a buyer does not have property rights?<br /><br />I’d appreciate you staying with my two examples which were entities which continue to have value<br />to certain types of seller:<br />Dog seller and sculptor. Abused by a new owner, do you really think the breeder would<br />stop caring for the dog’s welfare? One with no integrity, maybe. The idealistic artist, no different.<br />The good-will for both in making the trades, would certainly be the assumption of good treatment<br />of animal or artwork. For them to ‘do a Roark’ (or not) would be according to their metaphysical values. Not profit - evidently.<br /><br />You presented sophistry going as O’ist principles.<br />

What?  I must be misunderstanding this.

Is the only force, physical? Is the only value, physical?

Do you understand the metaphysical value creators perceive in their work?

Or the rational egoism that it takes to truly value and create?

Do you understand why Rand would have Roark act the way he did?

I’ve no idea if you misunderstand me.

I’ve no idea if you misunderstand me.

 

Nor do I. I was trying to clear that up, by posing an example and some questions… but for some reason you decided not to answer my questions, despite my efforts to make them clear and direct.  And further, you respond with a series of your own questions, I suppose expecting me to do for you what you were unwilling to do for me. It strikes me as disrespectful.

I’ve been seeing people do this a lot lately, and I find it very frustrating.  Dodging argument.  Dodging questions.  Non-responsive answers and responding to questions with questions.

 

If you understand the position you’re advocating, and can express it clearly, then why not do so?

 

So let’s try this again, and this time I will leave off the rhetorical snippet that you used to frame your entire reply:

 

Let’s say that I sell you a painting. No particular conditions on the sale, just a normal transaction, like buying a stick of gum at the market. But I value the painting very highly, you know? It means a lot to me.  And I deeply hope that you will treat it well, and hang it in a place of pride (as opposed to say your bathroom).

And then… let’s say that you decide to destroy the painting. It is for that reason that you purchased it in the first place. You despise what I value, and you want to watch it burn, insofar as you’re able.

Are you claiming that you are initiating the use of physical force against me? And, therefore, I am morally justified in now responding with force against you?

DonAthos, on 12 Feb 2013 - 02:40, said:

Nor do I. I was trying to clear that up, by posing an example and some questions… but for some reason you decided not to answer my questions, despite my efforts to make them clear and direct. And further, you respond with a series of your own questions, I suppose expecting me to do for you what you were unwilling to do for me. It strikes me as disrespectful.

I’ve been seeing people do this a lot lately, and I find it very frustrating. Dodging argument. Dodging questions. Non-responsive answers and responding to questions with questions.

If you understand the position you’re advocating, and can express it clearly, then why not do so?

So let’s try this again, and this time I will leave off the rhetorical snippet that you used to frame your entire reply:

DonAthos, on 12 Feb 2013 - 02:40, said:

Nor do I. I was trying to clear that up, by posing an example and some questions… but for some reason you decided not to answer my questions, despite my efforts to make them clear and direct. And further, you respond with a series of your own questions, I suppose expecting me to do for you what you were unwilling to do for me. It strikes me as disrespectful.

I’ve been seeing people do this a lot lately, and I find it very frustrating. Dodging argument. Dodging questions. Non-responsive answers and responding to questions with questions.

If you understand the position you’re advocating, and can express it clearly, then why not do so?

So let’s try this again, and this time I will leave off the rhetorical snippet that you used to frame your entire reply:

DonAthos, on 12 Feb 2013 - 02:40, said:

Nor do I. I was trying to clear that up, by posing an example and some questions… but for some reason you decided not to answer my questions, despite my efforts to make them clear and direct. And further, you respond with a series of your own questions, I suppose expecting me to do for you what you were unwilling to do for me. It strikes me as disrespectful.

I’ve been seeing people do this a lot lately, and I find it very frustrating. Dodging argument. Dodging questions. Non-responsive answers and responding to questions with questions.

If you understand the position you’re advocating, and can express it clearly, then why not do so?

So let’s try this again, and this time I will leave off the rhetorical snippet that you used to frame your entire reply:

DonAthos,

Your frustration is valid, and shared at times. The questions were a preliminary, not a tactic.

I’ve put myself out on a limb with this one, but don’t intend defending it to the ridiculous.

Simply, my position is that individual rights don’t make a society rationally moral - a (mostly)

moral society implements individual rights.

As you know, it all starts and ends with the individual. I think there’s over-emphasis sometimes

on individual rights as the Holy Grail.

Has anyone reading all this caught a glimpse of what an entire citizenry of rational egoists

would be like? That’s the crucial point of all this for me.

“Value”, in all its forms, as well as virtue, would be recognized in others’ life, activity and property, as in one’s own.

This would be a ‘given’. These would be a free, expressive and honest people, with nothing to fear.

Governments would be reduced to bare minimum as reliance on them reduces to the essentials.

My feeling is, the very people who most deserve individual rights, don’t have much need of them.

To look around one now is to see people clamoring for more ‘rights’. I want. I need.

Wherever I have been - or heard of - has been slight variations on the the same theme, of

surrender of self to the collective via the State. This is the destroyer of the human spirit: ‘rights’ are force, that must be made for my gain at the expense of - who? - uh, somebody. Until some other

“group” takes them away for their gain. All one sees are sullen and resentful faces of people who

lost something precious but who cannot begin to know what that was.

Howard Roark stands (and will always) against that tide of human misery.

Because he doesn’t recognize others’ needs for him. He finds value in himself, and through

his creation, and in certain other individuals.

This is the spirit of one who will not be deterred in his quest to make his metaphysical value,

concrete. (Literally.) To take it to the nth degree as Rand dramatically demonstrated, is metaphor,

obviously. Could a man go to that extreme to protect his highest values? Hardly.

But are such values always to be subsumed by individual rights? When is it moral to break the law?

I’m not sure. (Outside of emergencies). I do know though, that individual rights are not a moral code; they aren’t a guide to virtue and value - they are a social code, towards a rational egoist’s freedom from intervention or constraint.

Not a confinement for him.

Forgive my long-winded reply: not dodging you, hey. :slight_smile:

(SNerd: thanks for the clean-up.)

“Man’s rights can be violated only by the use of physical force.” - AR

 

J

Forgive my long-winded reply: not dodging you, hey. :slight_smile:

(SNerd: thanks for the clean-up.)

I think Tyler was looking for clarity through simple yes or no answers. I’d be interested in your answers to his questions. Answering them might lead to an actual conversation in which both sides are discussing the same thing.

J

Your frustration is valid, and shared at times.

 

I’m sure that’s true. :slight_smile:

 

I’ve put myself out on a limb with this one, but don’t intend defending it to the ridiculous.

 

If that means what I think it means – that, no, you do not consider the example I’d provided to be an initiation of the use of physical force, and no, you do not think that I would be justified in responding with physical force – then I’ll not press you to address that scenario again. Please let me know if I’m misinterpreting.

But I will again note that you have not responded directly, and have left me to infer your position.

On the subject of “putting yourself out on a limb,” look… I certainly don’t agree with Ayn Rand on every matter. And I think it’s fine if you don’t either. But it’s in our interest, in all sorts of ways, I believe, to be as clear as possible, with ourselves and with others, on where we agree and where we do not. Or perhaps you don’t yet consider yourself to disagree with her in any way? But again, that’s why clarity is so important. Let’s find out whether you do or do not, and hopefully also the reasons why! :slight_smile:

 

Simply, my position is that individual rights don’t make a society rationally moral

 

Agreed.

But this is not the same thing as saying that individual rights have no connection with a rational morality, or that a rationally moral person is somehow not beholden to individual rights (which is what I believe I’ve heard you say here), and can violate them morally.

 

  • a (mostly) moral society implements individual rights.

 

Yes, agreed.

Though I might observe here that I would view “implement” in your usage as meaning: “the recognition of,” or “the protection of,” and not, as some might mean, “the granting of.”

 

As you know, it all starts and ends with the individual. I think there’s over-emphasis sometimes on individual rights as the Holy Grail.

 

They aren’t the Holy Grail where ethics are concerned – and if that’s your point, you’re absolutely right. Individual rights aren’t a guide to moral action.

But they are the Holy Grail politically, and they are a limitation on moral action.

Don’t make me quote that Galt again, but I will if I have to! :slight_smile:

 

Has anyone reading all this caught a glimpse of what an entire citizenry of rational egoists would be like?

 

I think that’s what Galt’s Gulch is meant to provide? Though otherwise, I guess we must imagine such a thing.

 

To look around one now is to see people clamoring for more ‘rights’. I want. I need.

 

Yes, this is a problem. People invent “rights” out of thin air.

And one of the ways to address this problem is to be very clear on the nature of rights: what actually constitutes a right, and what does not. Ayn Rand believed that the line of demarcation was physical force, and that you uphold every actual right by forbidding the initiation of physical force; correspondingly, to initiate physical force is necessarily a violation of a person’s rights.

 

Howard Roark stands (and will always) against that tide of human misery.

 

I like Roark and The Fountainhead, though it’s been a long time since reading it. I haven’t touched on the matter of the novel under debate – and I don’t know that I plan on it – but if people wish to discuss such things, then in my opinion, they must be willing to consider the facts and the arguments, as presented. Same as with any other matter.

 

When is it moral to break the law?

I’m not sure. (Outside of emergencies).

 

I would argue that it is moral to break the law when the law itself is immoral; i.e. when it operates contrary to individual rights, and initiates the use of force.

 

I do know though, that individual rights are not a moral code; they aren’t a guide to virtue and value - they are a social code, towards a rational egoist’s freedom from intervention or constraint.

Not a confinement for him.

 

I disagree in this sense: individual rights – which are a necessary and inescapable social corollary of the moral code presented by Ayn Rand (which is to say, they form the Politics that goes hand-in-hand with Objectivist Ethics) – do absolutely confine the rational egoist to only those actions which do not violate another human being’s rights.  In initiating the use of physical force, the rational egoist is inviting others to constrain him and intervene against him physically, in retaliation.

But then, it might be worth asking: how do we recognize the “rational egoist” in the first place? It is not simply a label a man wears, and thereafter every action is recognized to be “the work of a rational egoist.” We know a man by his actions. And if a person goes around violating others’ rights, initiating the use of force, then I do not believe we would be discussing a “rational egoist” at all.

 

Forgive my long-winded reply: not dodging you, hey. :slight_smile:

 

In this spirit, let me return to the questions you asked of me.

 

Is the only force, physical? Is the only value, physical?

 

Physical force is the only force that matters when it comes to the matter of individual rights.

We could speak of “persuasion,” for instance, as being “another kind of force.” But Rand drew clear and important distinctions as to why the initiation of physical force is immoral, and it has to do with the nature of physical force itself. Please see the quote I’d provided.

And if we’re discussing some “non-physical force,” then certainly a man could fight his enemies with those weapons, and initiate the conflict, with no issue politically. That alone would not guarantee moral action. But at least it would not necessarily be immoral.

For instance, this board is organized around the “non-physical force of persuasion.” It is still immoral to evade and be a Nazi and come here and argue for antisemitism. But insofar as the owners of this board allow such a thing, politically a man has the right to do it… and it would be immoral for the government to step in and shut him down.

As a (probably inadvisable) shorthand, I’d say that we morally may fight words with words, and fire with fire, but not words with fire. (Though again, this simple observation doesn’t guarantee moral action at all; one must yet be fighting on the right side, for the right reasons.)

 

Do you understand the metaphysical value creators perceive in their work?

Or the rational egoism that it takes to truly value and create?

 

I would hope that I do? I mean, I do “create” things in my own fashion. But the tenor of your questioning seems like maybe you’re suggesting that I cannot possibly understand these things, if I don’t agree with you that a “creator” has the right to destroy other peoples’ property, if it should fall afoul of their values… So I don’t know how to answer you properly.

 

Do you understand why Rand would have Roark act the way he did?

 

To answer this fully would require a lot more investigation and discussion, as I believe that it really forms the matter for this entire thread. I will say that I’m not altogether convinced that Roark’s actions in The Fountainhead are fully consistent with the philosophy that Rand ultimately developed or set forth in her non-fiction especially. Whether that constitutes some great criticism of either Rand or The Fountainhead or Objectivism…? I am equally unconvinced.

Do you understand the metaphysical value creators perceive in their work?

 

As a creator, yes, I understand.

 

Or the rational egoism that it takes to truly value and create?

 

 

More so than you can possibly imagine. In fact, my rational egoism is such that I would take pride in finding – creating – a morally proper response to someone who messed with my artwork. I would make them pay for destroying something I had created and valued highly, but without initiating force. I would set for myself the goal of making them wish that I had initiated force instead of what I had done to them.

 

Do you understand why Rand would have Roark act the way he did?

 

Yes, I understand why Rand had Roark act the way he did. She did it for its aesthetic effect, and to portray aesthetic integrity. It is not a guide to moral action.

 

J

The aesthetics in his action would be…? I can’t find ANY. All I see is that what he did was a crime, him a criminal, and what he did was immoral.

The aesthetics in his action would be…? I can’t find ANY.

 

The aesthetics of his action is his artistic independence and rebelliousness.

 

All I see is that what he did was a crime, him a criminal, and what he did was immoral.

I don’t think you’re unreasonable for having that view. My view differs. I place more importance on Roark’s artistic integrity than on his ethical lapses. That’s the nature of art. We each bring different values and contexts to our judgments of it. We each place different importance on different elements within the art.

J

It’s called poetic license.

There are all sorts of forms of poetic licence, from a poet using a word that does not quite rhyme in a poem where everything else does, or a screen-writer putting script in Lincoln’s mouth, etc. Is there a particular sub-type of poetic licence being used here? I think of it as the “audience as God” type. I’m interested in your ideas on this.

Aside: Today I learnt that “Poetic Licence” is a shoe-brand (or something related to shoes). Googling tells me it is all about shoes!

Yes, I understand why Rand had Roark act the way he did. She did it for its aesthetic effect, and to portray aesthetic integrity. It is not a guide to moral action.

 

J

Hereby splitting the ‘aesthetic’ from the ‘moral’, and demolishing the essence

of Romanticist Art.

"What Romantic art offers him is NOT moral rules, not an explicit didactic message,

but the image of a moral PERSON - i.e. the concretized abstraction of a moral ideal."

[and]

“Please note that art is not his only source of morality, but of a moral sense of life.”

[Art and Moral Treason; TRM]

(Not “a guide to moral action” - uh, naturally!

A concrete abstraction of a moral ideal, of a moral sense of life.)

Hereby splitting the ‘aesthetic’ from the ‘moral’, and demolishing the essence

of Romanticist Art.

 

That’s totally false. Rand split the aesthetic from the moral, and she very successfully created great Romanticist art while doing so.

 

As I said here:

Howard Roark’s actions were not moral, just, rational, fair, etc., according to the convictions that Rand held at the time, just as the heroic criminals in The Night of January 16th and her unpublished novel The Little Street did not behave morally according to Rand’s beliefs at the time.

As Rand wrote (Journals of Ayn Rand, 22):

"I do not think, nor did I think when I wrote this play, that a swindler is a heroic character or that a respectable banker is a villain. But for the purpose of dramatizing the conflict of independence versus conformity, a criminal – a social outcast – can be an eloquent symbol. This, incidentally, is the reason of the profound appeal of the “noble crook” in fiction. He is the symbol of the rebel as such, regardless of the kind of society he rebels against, the symbol – for most people – of their vague, undefined, unrealized groping toward a concept, or a shadowy image, of man’s self-esteem.

“That a career of crime is not, if fact, the way to implement one’s self-esteem, is irrelevant in sense-of-life terms. A sense of life is concerned mainly with consciousness, not with existence – or rather: with the way a man’s consciousness faces existence. It is concerned with a basic frame of mind, not with rules of conduct.”

 

In other words, as an artist, Rand was focused on portraying an ideal “sense of life,” and not necessarily on the ethical particulars presented in her art. Her goal was not to present morally perfect characters, or for them to become the basis of anyone’s ethics.

 

So, as I said earlier, your apparent attempt to derive a proper ethics from Rand’s fictional characters is mistaken and misguided.

 

J

Howard Roark’s actions were not moral, just, rational, fair, etc., according to the convictions that Rand held at the time, just as the heroic criminals in The Night of January 16th and her unpublished novel The Little Street did not behave morally according to Rand’s beliefs at the time.

 

This may be way off-base on my part – I’m no Ayn Rand scholar – but is it also at least possible that Rand’s views may have changed or shifted or further developed after writing The Fountainhead? Do we know whether she arrived clearly at a “non-initiation of force principle” by that point in time?

I’ve heard it said that Rand went through something like a Nietzschean (sp?) phase during her youth… and the idea that maybe certain “moral rules” don’t quite apply to a heroic creator like a Roark (which maybe are echoed in some of whYNOT’s posts here, too) strikes me as being sympathetic to my ignorant layman’s conception of Nietzsche.

Hereby splitting the ‘aesthetic’ from the ‘moral’, and demolishing the essence

of Romanticist Art.

"What Romantic art offers him is NOT moral rules, not an explicit didactic message,

but the image of a moral PERSON - i.e. the concretized abstraction of a moral ideal."

[and]

“Please note that art is not his only source of morality, but of a moral sense of life.”

[Art and Moral Treason; TRM]

(Not “a guide to moral action” - uh, naturally!

A concrete abstraction of a moral ideal, of a moral sense of life.)

Hereby splitting the ‘aesthetic’ from the ‘moral’, and demolishing the essence

of Romanticist Art.

"What Romantic art offers him is NOT moral rules, not an explicit didactic message,

but the image of a moral PERSON - i.e. the concretized abstraction of a moral ideal."

[and]

“Please note that art is not his only source of morality, but of a moral sense of life.”

[Art and Moral Treason; TRM]

J. “Rand split the aesthetic from the moral…” Where do you get this? Are you claiming Rand

contradicted herself? Is it that you don’t approve of morality within aesthetics? Or is it

that you do not agree with the morality, rational egoism, itself?

I believe you could read those quotes again.

“Her goal was not to present morally perfect characters…” [J.]

“…but the image of a moral PERSON.” [AR]

Second, an out of context quote - about a criminal! - from her Journals, on ‘Jan16’, means little, here.

Do you think she changed her mind about Roark “as the image of a moral person” in later life?

Apparently you do.(“According to the convictions she held at the time.” [J.])

Show me that, in her words, then.

Third, it’s disingenuous to claim I am deriving a morality from TF.

(I read it last at least 20 years ago, if that says anything one way or other.)

I was the one who opposed literalism (“a text-book”) repeatedly, earlier - you recall?

I made the statement that AR meant readers to take the morality literally, NOT Roark’s acts.

I’ve used my own examples, my own reasons - and just once mentioned Rand’s intent, with Roark’s

actions. That I might be wrong, on morals over rights, is hardly relevant, here.

My morality is derived elsewhere, and only supported to some extent by Rand’s characters’

moral sense of life.

And you?

DonAthos, on 13 Feb 2013 - 19:43, said:

This may be way off-base on my part – I’m no Ayn Rand scholar – but is it also at least possible that Rand’s views may have changed or shifted or further developed after writing The Fountainhead? Do we know whether she arrived clearly at a “non-initiation of force principle” by that point in time?

I’ve heard it said that Rand went through something like a Nietzschean (sp?) phase during her youth… and the idea that maybe certain “moral rules” don’t quite apply to a heroic creator like a Roark (which maybe are echoed in some of whYNOT’s posts here, too) strikes me as being sympathetic to my ignorant layman’s conception of Nietzsche.

DonAthos, on 13 Feb 2013 - 19:43, said:

This may be way off-base on my part – I’m no Ayn Rand scholar – but is it also at least possible that Rand’s views may have changed or shifted or further developed after writing The Fountainhead? Do we know whether she arrived clearly at a “non-initiation of force principle” by that point in time?

I’ve heard it said that Rand went through something like a Nietzschean (sp?) phase during her youth… and the idea that maybe certain “moral rules” don’t quite apply to a heroic creator like a Roark (which maybe are echoed in some of whYNOT’s posts here, too) strikes me as being sympathetic to my ignorant layman’s conception of Nietzsche.

Don, An honest appraisal, with some legitimacy. Yes, Rand evidently moved away from Nietzsche

very early on, before TF, I believe - but vestiges still remained.

I read “Thus Spoke…”, and can understand her early infatuation with him. But also quite clearly

understand her later rejection(as “irrational” and “mystic”) of him too.

Yet, no doubt, into later years with Atlas, she condemned the judgment of the collective upon

the individual, continuously. Though Atlas is more concerned with Society’s enslavement of the individual, as I don’t need to tell you.

"Civilisation is the progress toward a society of privacy. The savage’s whole existence is public,

ruled by the laws of his tribe. Civilisation is the process of setting man free from men."

Do individual rights, and individual morality ever conflict? was my concern, at bottom.

I’ve read your earlier reply carefully; I think your interpretation is sound. I agree.

Also,I do not think you should break into a house to retrieve your painting, btw!

Having said that, I can still see a minor gap. You know a rational egoist by his actions, you said. Absolutely. Yet, how does a rational egoist know himself?

Additionally, I think we may have a tendency to expect society to become something staidly conservative.

But if all I’ve done is to play devil’s advocate in this, and raise some

thoughts - good.

(And if a man insults my wife, he gets a punch on the nose - and I will happily be arrested for Initiation of Force!)

J. “Rand split the aesthetic from the moral…” Where do you get this?

 

I get it from her writings on the subject, including the quote that I just provided in my last post. Looking up “eesthetic judgment” in the AR Lexicon. She very clearly separates aesthetic judgments from moral ones – her view was that an artwork which presents a morally evil view can nevertheless be aesthetically great; one’s agreeing or disagreeing with the moral content of a work of art has no relevance to making an aesthetic appraisal of it.

 

Are you claiming Rand contradicted herself?

 

On this issue, no, I am not saying that Rand contradicted herself. Rather, I’m saying that your position doesn’t accurately represent what she believed.

 

Is it that you don’t approve of morality within aesthetics? Or is it that you do not agree with the morality, rational egoism, itself?

 

Are you asking me if I approve of the idea of a moral point of view being included in a work of art? If so, yes, I approve. Or are you asking me if I think that one’s ethical beliefs should affect one’s aesthetic judgments of a work of art? If so, then no, I don’t believe that. I agree with Rand that one’s ethical beliefs should have no bearing on one’s aesthetic judgments of works of art.

 

As for your second question, I agree with the morality of rational egoism.

 

I believe you could read those quotes again.

“Her goal was not to present morally perfect characters…” [J.]

“…but the image of a moral PERSON.” [AR]

Second, an out of context quote - about a criminal! - from her Journals, on ‘Jan16’, means little, here.

It’s not an out of context quote and it’s not “about a criminal.” It’s about her views on the aesthetics of presenting a morally righteous, heroic sense of life in a work of art while placing no importance on particular immoral actions taken by the character who is embodying that sense of life.

 

Do you think she changed her mind about Roark “as the image of a moral person” in later life?

No, I think that you misunderstood what she meant by “image of a moral person.”

 

Apparently you do.(“According to the convictions she held at the time.” [J.])

My comment “according to the convictions she held at the time” has relevance only to that previous OL discussion from which I quoted myself. It was a reference to the fact that Rand’s view over time were unchanged on the subject of “faking reality,” and that she was aware that some of her characters’ actions were immoral by her own standards (which did not change over time). I would suggest that you read that OL thread if you truly want to understand the context of why I used that phrase.

 

Show me that, in her words, then.

Third, it’s disingenuous to claim I am deriving a morality from TF.

(I read it last at least 20 years ago, if that says anything one way or other.)

I was the one who opposed literalism (“a text-book”) repeatedly, earlier - you recall?

I made the statement that AR meant readers to take the morality literally, NOT Roark’s acts.

The problem is that you’ve also made statements to the contrary on this thread. You’ve been saying one thing and then arguing the other, and then not answering people’s questions when they’re trying to get you to clarify which of the two contradicting positions you actually hold.

 

I’ve used my own examples, my own reasons - and just once mentioned Rand’s intent, with Roark’s

actions. That I might be wrong, on morals over rights, is hardly relevant, here.

My morality is derived elsewhere, and only supported to some extent by Rand’s characters’

moral sense of life.

And you?

Me? As I’ve already said on this thread, I don’t share your position that one can be behaving morally while destroying others’ property or otherwise violating someone else’s property rights. I don’t share your belief that “When a man’s values are being violated it is an attack on his mind. This is force.” I don’t share your belief that your actions are moral if you are willing to do the time for having done a crime in order to protect something that you objectively value but which is someone else’s property.

J

I get it from her writings on the subject, including the quote that I just provided in my last post. Looking up “eesthetic judgment” in the AR Lexicon. She very clearly separates aesthetic judgments from moral ones – her view was that an artwork which presents a morally evil view can nevertheless be aesthetically great; one’s agreeing or disagreeing with the moral content of a work of art has no relevance to making an aesthetic appraisal of it.

 

J

Again, you’ve found a red-herring citation about what AR thought about “Naturalist” art - certainly

not Romantic.

i.e. that it can be morally corrupt, but aesthetically great. In that context, one should separate

one from the other, she’s saying. No?

That she made this distinction for, I repeat, non-Romantic art, alone.

Do you have any doubt that Romantic art must, should and does, combine the two?

(With the grasp of The Romantic Manifesto that you have - and which I’ve remarked on

before, I find it strange.)

The chapter is “Art and Moral Treason”: titled such, for a good reason.

"Just as Romantic art is a man’s first glimpse of a moral sense of life,

so it is his last hold on it, his last lifeline."

Again, you’ve found a red-herring citation about what AR thought about “Naturalist” art - certainly not Romantic.

 

Wrong. Rand’s statement about aesthetic judgment does not apply only to naturalist art. It applies to all works of art. Her position – the Objectivist position – is that a viewer or reader’s moral views have no relevance in making aesthetic judgments of any and all works of art. Agreeing or disagreeing with the moral content of a work of art is irrelevant to an aesthetic appraisal of it.

 

i.e. that it can be morally corrupt, but aesthetically great. In that context, one should separate one from the other, she’s saying. No?

No, she is saying that the morality of the content of a work of art is always separate from a proper aesthetic appraisal of it. Not only is she saying that an artwork which contains evil moral content can be judged to be aesthetically great, but she is also saying that a work of art can be morally great and be judged to be aesthetically terrible. She is saying that the correctness or incorrectness of an artwork’s moral content has no relevance to its aesthetic value.

 

That she made this distinction for, I repeat, non-Romantic art, alone.

Wrong, for the reasons that I’ve stated above.

 

Do you have any doubt that Romantic art must, should and does, combine the two? (With the grasp of The Romantic Manifesto that you have - and which I’ve remarked on before, I find it strange.)

Romanticism, according to Rand, presents man as choosing his values and as pursuing them. Her view of Romanticism does not require a presentation of man as morally perfect in pursing his values. A heroic character can be overzealous in pursing his values, step over the line and commit immoral deeds, and yet the work of art which contains the character can still qualify as Romanticism. Romanticism is an aesthetic style, not a moral one, which presents a type of man or an attitude toward existence. It presents grand, heroic, larger-than-life events which portray man as strong and as capable of choosing and acting to achieve his goals. It doesn’t specify what those goals must be, which morality must guide him, or that he must not deviate from his own or the reader’s morals in pursuit of his goals. And therefore a story about a larger-than-life criminal or a heroic “noble crook” (as Rand called it) can qualify as Romanticism.

 

The chapter is “Art and Moral Treason”: titled such, for a good reason. “Just as Romantic art is a man’s first glimpse of a moral sense of life, so it is his last hold on it, his last lifeline.”

Do you believe that either Howard Roark must be considered to be morally perfect or that Rand must be judged to have committed moral treason in her art by writing The Fountainhead and creating a heroic character who violates his own morals, as well as the author’s?

J

In his defense speech:

“They took the benefit of my work and made me contribute it as a gift.”

They, in fact, did not make him contribute it as a gift. He is the one that set the terms. They, in fact, did not make him do anything.

For someone that cares that much about his work, don’t design/erect it unless you have legally binding contracts. It was his own mistake/risk he took and made others pay for it by dynamiting it. He should have at least gotten 10yrs sentencing. I bet Toohey would have enjoyed being a prison guard, he’d really of gotten his rocks off, not in Roarks mouth or ass, but by making him take his orders: move when he is told to, etc and if he doesn’t, beat him with a rubber hose. (P.663)