"The motive and purpose of my writing is the projection of an ideal man.
The portrayal of a moral ideal, as my ultimate literary goal, as an end in itself.."
[…]
"My purpose, first cause and prime mover is the portrayal of Howard Roark or John
Galt or Hank Rearden or …AS AN END IN HIMSELF…"[TRM]
However Roark is being perceived in this thread, is it not clear how Rand perceived her creation!?
I think that this is right. I think that Roark and Galt and Rearden, etc., are meant as projections of ideal men, per Rand. Does this also mean that they are morally perfect men? What would “moral perfection” mean in this context, anyways? That they never make mistakes? Never evade? Never act contrary to their own best interests?
It’s interesting, because it seems to me that this question strikes at the heart of many controversies which – in my admittedly limited experience – tend to plague the Objectivist community. Perhaps it is unsurprising that this topic is so contentious.
As I write this, I’ve noticed that Dante has replied in his usual excellent manner – and with an admission of guilt from Roark, no less, which is… monumental for the topic under discussion. If I take this as an expression of moral culpability (and I see no other reasonable way to take it, though perhaps someone else will suggest one), then where does it leave us with the idea of “Roark as moral ideal”? Is he only “the moral ideal” at the very conclusion of the novel (or perhaps one sentence past), when he has learned every lesson that the novel was set to teach? Or is it allowable that Roark will make mistakes as he learns and grows? That he was “the moral ideal” all along, despite what are obviously immoral actions and, I would argue, implicit evasions? (Though, again, I do not know whether Rand had developed her theory of “evasion” yet…)
Could it be that a “morally perfect” man will yet make moral mistakes… but he will learn, and (as here) apologize, and seek to make amends, and resolve not to repeat those mistakes that he commits…? I rather hope so, else I’m not certain that such “moral perfection” is apt to measure anything about human beings, except perhaps in a manner fit for Catholics.
In any event, Roark’s culpability here (insofar as we trust him to identify his own error) I think should conclusively answer the question as to whether or not Rand’s heroes – “moral ideals” or not, and whatever we take that to mean – may yet act immorally within her fiction. It is not enough to say that Rand’s hero did X to conclude that X is a moral action, within Objectivism as developed in her later writings, or even within Rand’s moral understanding at the time of writing the fiction in question.
And her definition: "Romanticism is a category of art based on the recognition
of the principle that man possesses the faculty of volition."
She also states, that broadly “Naturalism…denies it.”
Volition. Volition to what? Choice of which? The choice of reason. The choice to live according to
what is right and proper to man. Virtue and value, so… morality.
I think if we take this formulation too strictly, however, we reach the conclusion that all Romanticism portrays Objectivism/Objectivist heroes, and that there is no Romanticism apart from that.
Volition yes, but not everything that a man chooses is necessarily “what is right and proper to man.” Morality, yes, in that men value certain things, and make choices accordingly… but they do not always value the right things, or have a proper morality; they are not necessarily Objectivists, and not necessarily correct.
While Objectivism offers the only morality proper to man, it is not the only moral system ever proposed. While I understand how it feels contradictory to speak of “immoral moralities,” there it is. I’ve already introduced Catholicism, so imagine a Catholic writing of a volitional hero who acts according to the author’s moral code. He may likely do things that an Objectivist would consider highly immoral. And yet, would we say that this was not Romantic?
Was there no Romantic art prior to Ayn Rand? (As no one had yet formulated Objectivist Ethics?) Are all heroes of Romantic art supposed to act morally (not just “according to some code,” but according to Objectivism) throughout their novels, at all times?
The dynamiting is not a deliberate error Rand is using in this way. Rather, it is a powerful aesthetic statement about artistic integrity; Roark takes the only action possible to him that will protect the integrity of his work. The dynamiting and the fraud serve different purposes and are used in different ways in the novel, and must be analyzed differently.
I just want to say in Jonathan’s “defense,” that I believe he’s said something much to your point, earlier in this thread:
Yes, I understand why Rand had Roark act the way he did. She did it for its aesthetic effect, and to portray aesthetic integrity. It is not a guide to moral action.
I believe that Jonathan is introducing the “fraudulent” nature of Roark’s dealing with Keating as a countermeasure against the claim that Roark’s subsequent dynamiting of Cortlandt is morally justified because Roark had an implicit contract with Keating going in. Which… I don’t know how I feel about that one way or the other, and I’d probably have to do some re-reading before I could opine on it.