Based on a trailer I saw of the soon to be released movie Sherlock Holmes, I’m afraid he is being depicted as some kind of action hero. There are hints that there may be some use of his intellect in solving the crime, but I had read elsewhere that Ritchie was trying to show that Holmes’ intellect was also detrimental to him.
Man, and Ritchie really can have some great dialog too. I was not looking for an action flick with Holmes.
Great, now they ruin one of my favorite literary characters.
*slaps Ritchie with a glove*
I demand satisfaction.
Basil Rathbone, avert your eyes!
I shall reserve judgment until I’ve seen it.
I do recall someone on this board once made the argument that things Hollywood produced were undeniably better than any other source, because they were mainstream.
I am not sure, but I think this trailer may have been the proverbial garlic to that particular vampire.
Judging from the trailer it seems like they’re making a Shanghai Noon/Knights of Sherlock Holmes. While I did enjoy those movies I find it a shame that they’re doing this with my second favorite detective(number one of course being Hercule Poirot). I would have loved to see a new, well-made, and serious Sherlock Holmes movie.
Oh, well… there’s always the old tv-series with Jeremy Brett as Mr. Holmes.
well you never know. ya it looks like another hollywood action movie. but personally im a huge fan of Robert Downey Jr. i think it will be a good fun movie to watch
I admit my assessment is preliminary and based solely on the trailer, but I’m going to see the movie with the mindset of not expecting “my father’s Sherlock Holmes”. I would be more than pleased to see the deductive prowess of the world famous Holmes rule the day but that will not be my expectation.
I can’t wait to see what they do with that live-action film of Tin-Tin now.
“My god, Tin-Tin, they’ve stolen the Professor’s shark-submarine!”
“Indeed, Captain Haddock. Shit’s gonna get fucked up. Fucked up, Belgian style.”
I’ll also have to wait until I see it. People complained that Peter Jackson was turning LotR into a campy action movie, too, and I thought the movies were better than the books in many respects.
I think, if all as was on писано, the film should be interesting.
We saw it last night and it was great! Reason and intellect prevail over mysticism. What more could an Objectivist want? ![]()
(Also, the preview for Iron Man 2 was fantastic! Stark tells a congressional committee they can’t have his device because it doesn’t belong to the American people, “it’s my property!”) :lol:
Blech, League of Extraordinary Gentlemen meets Raiders of the Lost Ark…
loved it!
It was good. It’s what you would want from a modern Holmes movie. There was one unnecessary action scene about 30 minutes in.
I saw Sherlock Holmes earlier this evening with my girlfriend. It was thoroughly enjoyable, and I actually really enjoyed the way Sherlock Holmes was portrayed. I’ve read the stories (or, most of them, as I’m finishing them up now), and I’m glad to say that my girlfriend is now interested in reading them as well (although, that’ll have to wait until after I introduce her to The Fountainhead
)
I’ll probably see it.
But I’m witholding judegement until I hear from the Baker Street Irregulars ![]()
I would not recommend this movie to anyone.
Mostly because of the portrayal of the character and the presence of summer blockbuster-esque action scenes in what is primarily a cerebral series. The biggest enjoyment from a Holmes story is the use of his inductive reasoning and his rapport with Dr. Watson. The ‘action’ scenes in the books are few and far between and used primarily at the climax of the story (a chase, usually, or a confrontation.)
The best characterizations of Sherlock Holmes have been Basil Rathbone and Robert Stephens- and although the Rathbone movie series may have been flawed in certain instances (such as Dr. Watson being a bumbling fool) they have the character down pat. Stephens also had an admirable take on the character in “The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes,” which was a movie that built very well on the already established Doyle canon with some interesting elements (such as Gabrielle Valadon being a character that ends up being the equal to one Irene Adler from ‘A Scandal in Bohemia.’)
R.D.Jr should have steered clear from this script and from the character altogether. He is simply not someone that has the necessary qualities to portray a cerebral character (and the script doesn’t do him any services.) Instead we have Sherlock Holmes, Action Hero, watered and dumbed down.
To anyone who loves Conan Doyle’s only worthwhile creation, this movie and this character are nothing more than an attempt to lobotomize an excellent character for the sake of blockbuster mediocrity.
Kainscalla, I understand your position, but I thought it was very well done. There was only that one scene in the lab/house/boatyard that does not fit the “climax”-type description. The fight scene at the gambling ring has support from the stories (he referenced having done that sort of thing before, and he was an expert boxer, etc.). Even the fighting was done in a way which I thought fit very well with the character; he used a great knowledge of anatomy and fighting tactics to predict his opponents moves and find the most efficient way to disable them, with an accompanying estimation of the damage done (a nice touch, I thought, and something Holmes would almost certainly know how to calculate). Not only was the fighting often fairly cerebral, but there were many instances in the story where Holmes showed off his “deduction” chops, including the final climax of the story, where he puts everything together.
As a depiction of Sherlock Holmes, the character, I thought it was quite good, and the minor modifications I thought were justified and even good in the context of a movie (as opposed to a short story). As a depiction of a rational person pursuing their passion and justice, it was great. So, overall, it was a very good movie.