Please help me answer the following questions. The scenario and questions below are simple because I do not want to confuse the issue with a lot of distracting information. My hope is that there is a logical, rational answer to my questions that contain no leaps of faith, appeals to emotion, or other “non-rational” components.
I am asking Objectivists to provide an answer(s) to these questions in the hope that I will receive rational and logical responses that will help make the situation clear. I am interested in reading answers from any non-Objectivists on this forum as well, but if you are a non-Objectivist please identify yourself as such when you answer.
Please consider the following scenario:
I live alone on an island in the middle of the ocean. There is no one else on the island, no one ever visits the island, and there is never any communication with any other person. I am completely alone on the island.
How I got to the island is irrelevant. I will never leave the island.
The island and the ocean immediately around the island provide a wide variety of resources. I use my reason and my ability to think to devise ways of turning the resources available to me into those things that I need to live, e.g. I make tools for gathering and/or hunting food, I devise means of collecting and storing fresh water, I discover or construct shelter.
Over time I have become so efficient at providing for my basic needs that I am able to devise ways to use the resources available to make my life better, i.e. provide luxuries and means of entertainment.
I live my life to the fullest of my ability given the circumstances in which I find myself.
One day, a man washes up on the beach. This man is alive but unconscious. I have never seen this man before and I have never had any interaction with this man. Due to being unconscious, the man has not interacted with me in any way and I do not perceive any kind of threat or danger from this man.
I walk up to this man and I kill him. I then continue with my day. The tide washes the body out to sea that evening and I never see the body again. I continue with my life exactly as I did before the man washed up on the beach.
Given the scenario, I ask the following questions: Was it wrong for me to kill the man on the beach? If it was wrong for me to kill the man on the beach, why was it wrong?