So Has Anyone Got Any Advice For My Situation?

Kevin, like everyone, gets irritated when he has to say the same things over and over again, Dave, I’m sure he didn’t intend his somewhat vicious statement quite the way it came out.

Unless I’ve specifically retracted something I’ve said or written, you can be sure that I most certainly did mean it, and in exactly the way I chose to express it.

Men, you have to let your subconscious be your guide. Don’t sit down and think, “is this the right time for flowers? Too soon? Too outspoken?” Think, do I want to give her flowers? If you do, it will feel, to you, that it’s exactly the right time and that will make it the right time because you’ll be comfortable with it.

This is a dangerous statement. It might make sense to a female reader, since women have the inestimable advantage of having been near-experts on the subject of romance from an extremely young age. Men, on the other hand, have to LEARN romance; it generally takes a long time, and often a great deal of painful experience, before we can even begin to grasp a woman’s nature and respond appropriately to her uniquely feminine needs. (And even then, most men still never “get it.”)

To say that a man should let his subconscious (i.e., his feelings) be his guide in handling an attraction, is not unlike advising a person who is completely ignorant about the stock market to make investments on the basis of what he “feels” will make him money. Unless one already has a great deal of stored, automatized (accurate) knowledge, his subconscious isn’t going to be much help to him — in fact, trying to rely on it will likely send him straight down the tubes.

Two basic things a man needs to be successful in love are: 1.) A solid understanding of the opposite sex, which is rooted in a deep appreciation and respect for women in general, and 2.) The ability to see reality clearly. When it comes to matters of the heart, far too many guys practically ONLY know how to feel, and to act on their feelings, which often leads to calamitous consequences. To be truly objective — to attempt an unbiased, third-party-like assessment of a situation without any reference to one’s own emotions or desires at all — would not only be impossible to this kind of man, it would barely even be conceivable.

This thread is a good case in point of a guy who urgently needs to set aside his feelings, and take exactly this kind of objective, honest look at his present situation. The one uncontestable fact of his dilemma is that the girl that he is so strongly attracted to has expressed that she does not want to have a relationship with him. What does it matter what the reasons are? Who cares if the reasons she’s cited make any sense? Although his feelings may be pulling him in an absolutely opposite direction, the bottom line is that he’s looking for love in the wrong place. He needs to respect this girl enough to drop her and move on, and find someone else who is much more enthusiastic about dancing with him.

I’ve said it many times, and I’ll say it once again: Guys, romantic love has nothing whatsoever to do with _ you _ or your feelings. That’s a slight exaggeration, of course, but it’s necessary to make the point. There’s an old saying that men do the picking, but women do the choosing — in other words, you might have picked her, but if she hasn’t chosen you, you’re entirely out of gas.

While you’re at it, you can forget about confessing your feelings or pleading your guts out to a girl in order to get her to like you — that only works in the movies, or if you’re a stud like Ross on Friends. This side of fiction, a woman only cares about who you are and how much she likes you; your feelings toward her don’t mean a thing as far as her own emotional response is concerned. Which takes us right back to the principle that your feelings are fundamentally irrelevant: if you’re dealing with a girl who sees you as John Galt, Howard Roark and Cary Grant all rolled into one, then by all means go ahead and fall in love with her. If, on the other hand, she starts to suspect that you’re much more into her than she’s into you, even if up to that point her feelings for you have been positive and on the rise, the sudden imbalance is going to make her feel very awkward and uncomfortable, and what feelings she did have for you will likely fast evaporate.

As Jennifer indicated, women love and need an element of MYSTERY and CHALLENGE in the dance of romance — two things which are totally absent from the tattered shreds of the bad joke of what claims to pass for the courtship process today. Women complain all the time that guys move too fast — WAY too fast — that they don’t give the process of love anywhere near a chance to grow and develop. For exactly this reason, I strongly advocate that a man employ a process of literal, old-fashioned dating; just pretend that it’s about 1925, back in the days when men and women took delight in dressing up, going out, and enjoying a chivalrous evening together, long before such cultural institutions as Internet porn and rap music were invented. In other words: Just go out and have fun! (And no, “fun” does not mean sex.) View the dating process as simply the chance to enjoy each other’s company, to talk, and to get to know each other better. Do this once a week across several months, and you will have built a solid foundation for a mature, enduring romantic relationship.

What kills romance — and annoys the hell out of women — is the desperate and pathetic PRESSURE that so many guys seem to think is the key to a girl’s heart — pressure of exactly the kind which several participants in this thread have brazenly advocated (and presumably still do, since they have not recanted their statements). Let me say clearly and for the record, since I’m in the business of making women happy, not miserable, that any man who advocates employing PRESSURE TACTICS on a woman is indeed much worse than anything I could possibly express on these message boards. The man who truly cares about women will shun PRESSURE as the deadly poison it is — he will pay careful scrutiny to all of a woman’s signals and statements, and respond to them appropriately and respectfully. Should such a man find himself in the position of being told by a woman explicitly, in words, that she does not want to have a relationship with him — regardless of what her reasons may be, or for no reason at all — he would at once acknowledge her decision, back off, and LEAVE HER THE HELL ALONE.

Have I made myself perfectly clear?

This is a dangerous statement. It might make sense to a female reader, since women have the inestimable advantage of having been near-experts on the subject of romance from an extremely young age. Men, on the other hand, have to LEARN romance; it generally takes a long time, and often a great deal of painful experience, before we can even begin to grasp a woman’s nature and respond appropriately to her uniquely feminine needs. (And even then, most men still never “get it.”)

I meant, after you’ve rationally evaluated the overall situation the timing of small and specific parts of the pursuit operates best if you don’t over-think it, much like when, say, you’re planning to write an essay you have to sit down and consciously do the outline, but you let your subsconscious take care of the choice of specific words, comma placement, phrasing, etc. when you’re actually writing it.

If you were to try and consciously analyze every word before you say it, whether you’re talking to someone or writing, you would go insane. You would certainly sound insane.

Kevin, like everyone, gets irritated when he has to say the same things over and over again, Dave, I’m sure he didn’t intend his somewhat vicious statement quite the way it came out.

As we have seen, that’s not true. I don’t choose to engage in discussion with the hostile. The only thing that warrants such behavior is response to a personal attack. It’s not conducive to discussion, and expressing a withholding of overly-hostile words it’s just as bad as voicing them. Both are forms of personal attack, which have no place here.

Other than that, he’s right though. Sure, women love to be pursued, but you have to do it before you declare yourself or request that she make a decision. Telling her you want a relationship forces her to assemble all the evidence she has on you make some sort of determination.

That makes sense. I didn’t consider the before/after declaration aspect of it. I’m not a “declarer” at all, so I didn’t even think to look at it from that angle. I don’t think I’ve ever done a preemptive declaration of feelings in my life, which is why I said to show rather than tell.

Kevin, you are making the assumption that the girl says what she means. I don’t like to generalize, but I will say that often, the best way to understand what a woman thinks or means is not to listen to her words but to listen to her actions. Obviously there are certain times when regardless of what is going on in her head, you have to take the words for what they are, for example if she tells you to stop touching her then you had better stop touching her, even if she likes it, because the risk of a sexual harrasment suit is not one that you probably want to take. Looking at the context of the situation, however, it sounds like there is no real danger for Strangelove to be continue to pursue the whole thing.

I agreed before that that he should continue to pursue her and be aggressive, but I was under the impression that she had not really made a definite decision and that she didn’t necessarily mean what she said. That was an error on my part, Strangelove is really the only one who could have a definite idea about that since he was the one talking to her.

Stranglelove. Run away! I think Kevin and Jmegan have given good advice but I’ll add just one more thing. If you are not sure just give her your #, tell her that you are interested but won’t wait forever, and don’t call her again. If she then pursues YOU then fine but forcing something that isn’t there is a waste of both your time.

I’m here to offer you completely unobjective (or is it?) and completely different advice:

Take the focus off of her and put the spotlight on yourself.

Here’s how:

Find a quiet space to think.

Reflect on why you feel attracted to this woman. Don’t be intellectual about it…or completely intellectual about it. Just find the traits and emotions that are creating the attatchment.

Realize then that you are simply projecting yourself onto this woman. The only way to “understand” another person is through your own experiences recorded in your mind. You are simply putting your qualities that you normally deny or rarely think about in yourself onto this girl. In doing this, you will realize your potential to grow. You may find that what you like about her is completely opposed to what you view yourself as…that’s actually quite normal, and a sign that you’ve actually found something. Remember then, that in the future, you can choose to be that way at any time.

This won’t make the pain of a letting go of an attatchment (which is all it is at this point) go away. But it will give you something positive out of the experience. My advice as far as the girl is simply this: Let go. You can still talk to her and be friends, but only in letting go of her will you set yourself free…and it isn’t easy. Good luck.

Peace, Love, and Understanding