Socializing vs Globalizing

I’m working on a paper with a friend and we’re looking for some empirics on different nations successes and failures with either globalizing (freeing their markets of regulation, adopting capitalsim, and/or lowering protectionism) or by socializing (increasing government size in either revenue, services and goods provided, etc.)

Also, does anyone feel there is a treshold for development for a country to reap the benefits of globalizing? In a preliminary discussion we argued on whether a developing nation would actually see more growth under a more socialist/communist regime as opposed to a ‘free market.’ There were really two points:

  1. The natural resource curse, an undeveloped nation has no industry in which it has an absolute (maybe comparative?) advantage so it will have to rely on its commodities as primary exports and will compete with other undeveloped nations to trade with industrialized nations.

  2. Instituations vs Geography, while Sachs’ research may not be entirely credible; however, if a country initially rebukes the free market it impliments better institutions (good economic rules, like private property) and is less reliant on its geography (natural resources).

I’m working on a paper with a friend and we’re looking for some empirics on different nations successes and failures with either globalizing (freeing their markets of regulation, adopting capitalsim, and/or lowering protectionism) or by socializing (increasing government size in either revenue, services and goods provided, etc.)

Also, does anyone feel there is a treshold for development for a country to reap the benefits of globalizing? In a preliminary discussion we argued on whether a developing nation would actually see more growth under a more socialist/communist regime as opposed to a ‘free market.’ There were really two points:

  1. The natural resource curse, an undeveloped nation has no industry in which it has an absolute (maybe comparative?) advantage so it will have to rely on its commodities as primary exports and will compete with other undeveloped nations to trade with industrialized nations.

  2. Instituations vs Geography, while Sachs’ research may not be entirely credible; however, if a country initially rebukes the free market it impliments better institutions (good economic rules, like private property) and is less reliant on its geography (natural resources).

A good text with many empirical statistics is Alan Greenspan’s book The Age of Turbulence. There is a particular chapter in which Greenspan discusses trade and globalization, and provides many facts of its effects. I can quickly address the points in your post though, and you can find more elucidation in Greenspan’s text:

  1. The so-called Dutch Disease that you are referring to is an issue. The issue is that the export of newly found natural resources will increase demand for a nation’s domestic currency. This raise in the exchange rate will subsequently cause other exports of that nation to be less competitve on world markets. This type of incident has occured in many countries, most notably, in recent years Nigeria. If you want empirical evidence of this, you can look at Nigeria, some of the Latin American countries, Russia, and the development of North Sea oil in Britain. I think that the key to avoiding this is to have an educated workforce. Empirically, developed nations are almost totally immune from this (exception: North Sea oil), while developing nations typically experience it frequently.

  2. I don’t think I agree here. It sounds contradictory. The precursor to any free-market is the establishment of property rights. Equally important, is the timely and efficient enforcement of those property rights. As a generality, most socialist and communist nations have either explicitly not protected property rights, or have made the process of implementing your right to property burdensome (if it takes 5 years to enforce your right to property through a bureaucratic judicial system, then the right is essentialyl worthless anyway). There is a history of countries moving toward capitalism but not particulary protecting property, i.e. China, Latin American nations, Russia. It seems to be that, eventually, any benefits from a move towards free-markets are erased and the country lapses into some form of democratic socialism. Russia has basically done this.

I’ve always been taught it to be called ‘the natural resource curse’ but I guess that is synonymous with the Dutch Disease?

I was speaking strictly in theory, I lack any evidence, that is what I’m looking for. And by initially rebuking the free market, I was referring to having lots of protectionist policies and to be more isolationist like early America so that industries develop. However, I think the proper response to that is that while refusing to import, trading countries will obviously counter with tariffs of their own and also without importing a country will see slower advancements in technology.

I was speaking strictly in theory, I lack any evidence, that is what I’m looking for.

Evidence for what? Are you looking for evidence that protectionism ans socialism do not work (even) for poor countries? If so, look at India and China.

The distinction between rich and poor countries and what works for them is inherently flawed. All countries, or tribes, were quiet equally poor in the past. Portugal, the poorest nation of Europe in the 1400s became the richest of the World a century later, only to slowly decade and now reanimated artificially as a province of the EU.

The best example that created wealth, and enforcement of rights and security, is better than natural resources and looted treasure is the rise of the (2nd) British Empire in detriment of the Spanish Empire.

Capitalism works for poor countries, it is in fact what turns them into rich countries.

Now you might have heard that Petrobras, the Brazilian State Oil Company, is worth more than Microsoft. Today it was announced that they will create another company to channel the oil money into “social causes”. This sounds disastrous for an economy that was already making huge profits planting crops in the jungle and building competitive airliners.

A natural resource is only a curse when it’s not seized privately by the citizens. Or when it’s seized publicly by state projects (like the English coal mines operating at loss)