1 hour ago, MisterSwig said:
By “doing what is best for the self” do you mean “surviving”?
Does it seem likely? I’ve been arguing against holding “life as the standard of value” as meaning mere survival. Has that been unclear?
But I do believe that morality is about “doing what is best for the self,” yes, only my view of this – and “life as the standard of value” – is more expansive than mere survival. It takes “experience” into account.
1 hour ago, MisterSwig said:
Because you have proposed that you might be willing to rape a hundred women in order to “live to fight another day.” So, I’m wondering what wouldn’t you do under duress in order to keep your life? Would you murder your entire innocent family?
What I would or wouldn’t do depends upon the context of the situation. And moreover, it depends upon how I understand “life as the standard of value.” My own understanding, again, relates to this experience thing.
So I can tell you that I would not expect to find any situation in which I would be willing to murder my family, for instance. But rather than go into that whole line of argument fresh here, perhaps you would be willing to peruse this fairly recent thread where I’d discussed it at some length?
(Though “fairly recent” as I say, I’m curious as to whether there is any contradiction between my arguments there, and my current burgeoning attempt to relate those kinds of arguments to my ethical philosophy more generally. I haven’t taken the time to review it yet – so maybe you’ll find something worth investigating.)
Anyhow, here is my first paragraph from my first post in that thread, to give you a sample of the thrust of my argument along these lines:
On 1/10/2016 at 8:34 AM, DonAthos said:
If I were in a situation where I judged that I had to murder my wife to allow myself to survive, I wouldn’t choose to do it. You would describe that as “stupid,” but to me, I would look upon “survival” thereafter as a continual punishment. So no thanks to that.
Perhaps you can already see how I relate this to “experience”…? And though I had hoped that you would reach a similar conclusion yourself, perhaps it gives you a small window on to how I would answer the question of why Galt would see his life as “worthless,” if he survived at the cost of Dagny’s murder.
1 hour ago, MisterSwig said:
Be a man and die like one.
I recognize that this is meant to sound pithy or punchy or something, but…
-
I don’t think it’s a great look for “rational selfishness” or a moral philosophy or Objectivism. I would associate the morality of the Japanese military circa WWII, for instance, with “be a man and die like one”; not Rand’s philosophy, which is meant to teach a man how to live, and live happily.
-
I think it reveals that you cannot do what I had charged you to do: to tell me why it would be “better for me to die, rather than comply with those orders [to rape a hundred women–with a gun pointed at my head]?”
Your reply is “because it would maintain the integrity of my moral system.” And because “I’ve made an oath.” And because “it’s not the women’s fault.” But none of that tells me why it would be better for me to choose to die. Why should I prefer oblivion to rejecting my moral system, or renouncing my oath, or being the agent of harm against others? How is that oblivion better for me?
Because, insofar as I understand what you’ve said till now, you hold that suicide cannot be “for the self”; i.e. that it cannot be better for me to choose to die.
But I believe in moral suicide because I believe that it can be better for the self to choose to die rather than live, in some (rare) circumstances. And I account this to “experience,” and further believe that until you understand my meaning, and relate it to Galt, et al., that you will not have a full understanding of this issue.