Sports And Objectivism

Are sports consistent wtih Objectivism? What is the social value of professional sports? What is the personal value?

I am not a big sports fan (actually not a fan at all ), but I can definitely see it’s potential value. It gives man a sort of hero worship - in most cases, a completely proper one. Professional athletes have acheived greatness. They have mastered their bodies, honed a skill to perfection, and in many cases, capitalized on their abilities beautifully.

I think there are some immoral sports, however. Take boxing for instance. Present in this sport is the idea that it is proper for on man to physically harm another. Hockey has this element to it as well, although not in the same manner that boxing does. In boxing, it is inherent in the game. In hockey(correct me if I’m wrong here), it’s not the rules of the game that make it violent, but just a “tradition” of sorts. I’m not sure which is worse - a game entirely based on the use of force, or a sport in which it is present for little more than commercial appeal.

Football is sometimes viewed as violent, but let’s take a look at what is really going on. Is football really violent (i.e. man should destroy man), or is there just a great risk of inury. There is no direct attack of one man on another. One football player knocking another to the ground is not done with the express intention of causing him harm (if teams are playing ethically). Rather, injuries are a side effect of “capturing the ball.” Sports, to be of value, do not have to be completely safe. In fact, placing themselves in that situation demonstrates a kind of courageous confidence in their ability to evade injury and withstand beatings. This is definitely something to be admired.

I could go on and give examples from a few other sports, but I think you get the idea.

Are sports consistent wtih Objectivism? What is the social value of professional sports? What is the personal value?

Thomas A. Bowden, an Objectivist lawyer and big sports enthusiast, wrote a very nice article in the August 1983 issue of The Objectivist Forum. The article was titled “In Praise of Spectator Sports” with the subtitle “The value of sports as ‘a celebration of human skill, determination, and goal-achievement.’”

The subtitle pretty much sums it up, but if you are interested in the subject you might enjoy reading the article for all the details.

I think there are some immoral sports, however. Take boxing for instance. Present in this sport is the idea that it is proper for on man to physically harm another.

I believe when relating to morality, it is different to initiate force unwillfully, which is opposite to the welcoming of force to build ones self defence capacities, make money, have social interaction, and other positive attributes, which participating in boxing willfully creates.

Thomas A. Bowden, an Objectivist lawyer and big sports enthusiast, wrote a very nice article in the August 1983 issue of The Objectivist Forum. The article was titled “In Praise of Spectator Sports” with the subtitle “The value of sports as ‘a celebration of human skill, determination, and goal-achievement.’”

Tom also wrote an ARI op-ed in praise of sports which you can read at http://www.aynrand.org/medialink/sports.shtml and Rob Tracinski did one too which is at http://www.aynrand.org/medialink/op-eds/heroes.txt.

ESPN’s Page 2 examined the issue of the hardest sport a while back. Eight panelists, some with Ph.D.s, rated each sport on a number of attributes. If nothing else, it at least can perform its stated purpose of encouraging debate. Which sport is most deserving of hero worship?

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/sportSkills

Boxing immoral?!?

What about martial arts, are they immoral too?

Boxing does not assume it is alright to hurt others, but that it may be necessary to defend yourself against others. The arena is a place where two individuals test their skills against one another, while agreeing to respect certain rules to avoid as much as possible causing real damage.

I heard Ayn Rand was a fan of Ali, and I myself enjoy watching a good fight now and then.

Actually, the only sport I enjoy watching more than boxing or martial arts is RoboWars, the show where two teams build robots that have to destroy one another in the arena. :slight_smile:

I dont really enjoy watching any sports. Soccer can be ok, but I wouldnt go out of my way to watch it. I can understand why others enjoy watching sport though and I think it can certainly fill a positive need for some people. The problem is that it often degenerates into some kind of irrational neo-tribalistic ‘warfare’, with the whole “my team” against “your team” aspect. This can probably be seen more clearly in European soccer, although it applies to pretty much every national sport where countries compete as a whole.

I think there are some immoral sports, however. Take boxing for instance. Present in this sport is the idea that it is proper for on man to physically harm another.

Would you apply the same reasoning to martial arts tournaments, or is there something about boxing in particular that makes you dislike it? I personally find almost no enjoyment whatsoever in boxing, but it would be hypocritical for me to claim it is immoral when I enjoy watching martial arts, and sometimes UFC.

oops, erandror beat me.

I believe when relating to morality, it is different to initiate force unwillfully, which is opposite to the welcoming of force to build ones self defence capacities, make money, have social interaction, and other positive attributes, which participating in boxing willfully creates.

I didn’t look at it this way before. My condemnation of boxing is withdrawn.

Simma down, everybody!

I didn’t look at it this way before. My condemnation of boxing is withdrawn.

Simma down, everybody!

Of course we have to remember that just because something does not involve the initiation of force, this doesnt mean that it is moral. I’d be loathe to accept that street fighting (for instance) would be a particularly moral activity for a rational individual to engage in, even if both parties had agreed to the fight before hand. Similarly I’d have to ask questions of someone who was just involved in boxing for the ‘pleasure’ of hurting others. I suppose it all comes down to the reasons why the individual has chosen to participate in the sport.

I dont really enjoy watching any sports. Soccer can be ok, but I wouldnt go out of my way to watch it. I can understand why others enjoy watching sport though and I think it can certainly fill a positive need for some people. The problem is that it often degenerates into some kind of irrational neo-tribalistic ‘warfare’, with the whole “my team” against “your team” aspect. This can probably be seen more clearly in European soccer, although it applies to pretty much every national sport where countries compete as a whole.

Would you apply the same reasoning to martial arts tournaments, or is there something about boxing in particular that makes you dislike it? I personally find almost no enjoyment whatsoever in boxing, but it would be hypocritical for me to claim it is immoral when I enjoy watching martial arts, and sometimes UFC.

oops, erandror beat me.

Soccer is great escapism if you keep it in context.

I go and watch my local team and cheer them on. I have realistic expectations and don’t lose the plot if they get beaten. It is fun to sing about how much you hate your local rivals but that’s as far as I take it.

The tribal thing is a big problem in the west of Scotland. I live in central Scotland having moved there from East Scotland, where I was sheltered from it.

It’s very us against them where Fenian B******s fight with Orange B******s (as they call themselves) and some people I have met (including a guy at my work who I mentioned on the Eddie Willers thread) are so collectivized that they cannot imagine that somebody does not take one side over the other.

It is also notable that it is a case of “Hooray! They have lost” rather than “Hooray! We have won”. (Where is John Galt when you need him.)

It is an even bigger problem in some parts of Italy, notably Rome.

But sport provides me with a chance to be entertained and worship heroes albeit on a limited scale.

Personally, I like those sports that have a strong esthetic component like figure skating, gymnastics, synchonized swimming, and diving. Perhaps the reason is that I was a dancer and gymnast in my younger days and still enjoy doing choreography. http://www.speicher.com/choreo.htm

L. Peikoff in his lecture “Why Ancient Greece is my Favorite Civilization” gives an interesting angle on this issue.

He said, the Ancient Greeks would have thought the skills of todays professional sportsmen admirable … BUT only in slaves… supposing one had slave and had no better use for him then to train him in a sport to such a degree. (understand the talk is of slaves in old Greece)

Apparently Greeks would see the honed specialized skills of todays top sportsmen not worthy acquiring for men since they believed in well rounded universal development, like say doing a pentathlon in Olympic games and having good education (like rhetoric etc) and good looks (body bearing and muscles) to top it off…

He said the Greeks wouldn’t consider running today’s marathon (40 miles+) as sport since that would take such specialization that one who undertook training for it wouldn’t have time to lead the life proper to man.

That is how I remember this part of lecture from memory, last time I listened to that tape is something like half a year, so if anybody wants to have some argument with that, let him look it up on tapes first. But the above is essentially what he (LP) tried to put accross in the lecture on this point - Ancient Greeks and sports.

Personally, I have always seen top flight pros in any sport as leading (very much) impoverished lives and usually the talk is about the first third of one’s life that falls near 100% victim to the sport one does. At least nowadays many of them make enough financially to set them for life and that is something to consider. There’s many a men who worked most of their lives at routine factory jobs and made a pittance in comparison and if they dedicated part of their lives to some sport 100% and made it to top, they wouldn’t be loosers any way at the end of it and very likely would enjoy it more.

I suppose thats the way it really is in reality. Moost top sportsmen wouldn’t in most cases lead some more worthy alternative lifestyle anyway, so it is perhaps from this point of view not much loos for them that way.

On the other hand, Greeks wouldn’t have dreamed of specialization we now have in most productive professions, not just sports but again, the question would be if that is quite right.

Myself, I have always been an example of such universality that L Peikoff outlined in his lecture on Greece now that I think of it. I used to do sports like cross country skiing and bicycling and rock/ice climbing, I even took ballet dance classes when ~ 30 yrs of age (I didn’t race on skis or on bicycle but I did it way more than just recreational pastime, the ballet was of course just interesting to learn a bit, that all and I was still quite trim at that point for it) and I got pretty well acquitaned with Ayn Rand’s philosophy and read various books in philosophy (appart from Objectivism) and studdied physics at university all the while keeping bread on table by manual labor (housepainting on my own).

vaclav (knowledge integration)

Only someone who has never sat at East End Park, Dunfermline (The home town of both Nazareth and Andrew Carnegie) on a wet Wednesday night and sung about how much he hates Falkirk (local rivals) would say something like that. :slight_smile:

The question arises, then regarding professional sports.

There is much discussion in the media about the “outrageous” salaries paid to star athletes, especially in baseball.

Would capitalists consider these “outrageous?”

The wages of sportsmen reflect that they are in high demand (or very average demand if you support my team) relative to their supply.

What is outrageous about that?

:stuck_out_tongue:

Quote frankly, I find NOTHING wrong with a star athlete placing a high price on him/herself for his/her talent. As in any capitalist endeavor, it is up to the purchaser to either accept such price or reject it.

I’m focusing specifically on professional baseball here, since it is exempt from antitrust laws. I would argue that professional baseball is the only endeavor that is truly still capitalist! :smiley:

I scoff at the media for their commentaries expressing disdain at the high price of such sports and athlete’s salaries. After all, the owners of such teams had the choice of rejecting such prices. They instead elected to contract such players at such prices because they thought such players could increase the profits of the owners and their teams. :slight_smile:

Yankees did right by signing Alex Rodriguez. :smiley:

That’s why the Yankees rule! :slight_smile:

A-Rod is an entirely separate issue. You know that the union and Bud Selig nixed the contract with the Red Sox, right? Do you know why?

Because there is a clause in the collective bargaining agreement something to the effect that you can’t take less than a current contract, because it would undercut the lowest paid players on the team. It was originally placed to protect those who were good, but not that good, and has now been used to hamstring the greatest player of last year, who wished to go to the Red Sox above all. Now, granted, the Yankees had the most money and A-Rod got a more valueable contract, which makes me happy. But A-Rod valued the Red Sox above the actual monetary value of the contract, and was not allowed to sign with them.

A-Rod is an entirely separate issue.  You know that the union and Bud Selig nixed the contract with the Red Sox, right?  Do you know why? 

Because there is a clause in the collective bargaining agreement something to the effect that you can’t take less than a current contract, because it would undercut the lowest paid players on the team.  It was originally placed to protect those who were good, but not that good, and has now been used to hamstring the greatest player of last year, who wished to go to the Red Sox above all.  Now, granted, the Yankees had the most money and A-Rod got a more valueable contract, which makes me happy.  But A-Rod valued the Red Sox above the actual monetary value of the contract, and was not allowed to sign with them.

A-Rod would have made a mistake by being willing to sign for less than his value.

Perhaps there is an unusual justice in Bud Selig nixing this deal. This one time he was right.

Sports provide entertainment for the fans.

They provide an element of fun for amateurs like myself who participate in them.

Each one of us is meant to enjoy life, and having good clean fun through sports is one way to do so.

Strangely enough we don’t get Baseball here in Scotland, AutoJC.