As an aside, this reminds of the scene in Amadeus when Mozart performs a piece of music before some important people (can’t remember who they were) and they decided that the music had “Too many notes.” :lol:
Touche. Amadeus is one of my all-time favorites. From the perspective of Rand was on a higher level than myself in terms of literature, and thus I can’t know what “too many notes” are, that might be a valid point.
OTOH, if analysing great works of fiction is impossible, it’d make for rather lame Lit classes 
Perfectly mimicking someone’s form by accident would be an unbelievable coincidence. To do it intentionally would require unlimited variability which as I said violates the axiom.
If any “derivative” of the axiom is violated (say the law of causality), that must also constitute a violation of the axiom itself.
A literary character being able to mimic any human isn’t necessarily unlimited variability, since the possible characteristics of humans are themselves limited.
IMO violating a derivative doesn’t equal violating an axiom. E.g. writing a novel involving a god would violate primacy of existence, but it wouldn’t violate “existence exists.” The axiom only states that something exists, not what exists.
I too would rather keep this a literary, as opposed to metaphysical, question. So I’ll just leave this at that.
Think of the scope of Atlas Shrugged. It’s theme is: the role of the mind in man’s life… For a reader to integrate all of it into a managable number of concretes is near impossible, so Ayn Rand presented an integration for us: in the form of Galt’s speech.
Theme is one of the fundamental aspects of literature, and ensuring its clear understanding is literarily necessary.
The role of Galts speech was to integrate the points throughout the novel that one might not have realised as connected, or clarified how they fit into the whole. Considering how much there was too integrate, I do not as one whom has read the novel carefully, see how Miss Rand could have made the speech significantly less than what it is now without comprimising the extent of integration that the speech provides.
Did the speech cover anything that wasn’t depicted in the novel? Anything covered in the speech but not the novel’s progression couldn’t be considered part of the novel’s theme IMO. If the speech is meant to be a clarification of the novel’s theme, then in a strict sense, the speech wasn’t necessary, as the novel sans speech makes the same points.
As Galt’s speech is probably the single best instance of Rand’s ideas, I am glad she wrote it, even IF it had been less than ideal to place it in AS. Whether the speech did in fact clarify the theme isn’t something I’m going to touch.
I would also rather not make this technique topic into a question solely about AS, so unless this issue is spun off, I’ll try to refrain from Galt’s speech too.
Okay, on to more techniques? 
Conflict
A novel should take its characters from one point to another. By the end, characters should have succeeded or failed at some task, and it should be important. Who wants to read a book about a housewife’s efforts to get to the bank before it closes?? Without some more significant reason for caring whether she gets to the bank or not, why does it matter to us?
IMO a general example of lack of conflict is “a day in the life of” books. Take Woolf’s To the Lighthouse. Its action takes place on two days (about ten years apart, if I remember.) Now, what kind of conflict can one build up in the span of a day? It’s not impossible, but generally such novels end up IMO as exercises in the mundane - petty squabbles, passive unhappiness, squelched desires, etc. I don’t think it coincidental that novels with poor conflict tend to end up with poor themes.