In speaking of a sort of block appearing between (1) the initial idea for a story and (2) the next stage, which is the more and more detailed planning of the story, you said:
It happens everytime.
Of course it happens every time. It is perfectly natural to be blocked between idea and planning – if you don’t do what is necessary: do the preliminary questioning and answering and more questioning and connecting and differentiating that needs to be done when you think about something. All these mental activities must go before you begin planning and as you spiral through your planning from general to specific.
What do you do as soon as you get an idea for a story? Do you carry a notebook with you? Do you jot down the initial idea and any other ideas that pop out of your subconscious mind? Do you enter the idea into a journal and begin asking yourself questions? For example, if you begin with the fourth “door” into The Story Room, a whole situation (such as a tsunami hitting a town), you might immediately start thinking about and writing down such questions as:
-
Wait a minute, why does this intrigue me so much? Well, because it is a terrifying fact of overpowering destruction by nature, and I am fascinated with how different people with different values react to facts of nature.
-
Okay, now I see a bit of a THEME emerging (facts and values), so what kind of CHARACTERS would inhabit a story like that? Well, I would certainly need a range of characters to show a range of reactions. And their divergent reactions would easily set up the story for …
-
PLOT! Yeah, I see, the conflicts between the characters about what to do to save the town, which the main character loves, would make the backbone of the plot. But where should I start? With the wave itself? No, probably I need to set up a conflict ahead of time. Maybe I could … and so forth.
Do you see? No planning has started yet. It won’t until you have simmered and stewed and brainstormed and researched. (How fast do tsunmais really move? What can stop them? What sort of geography represents the greatest threat and the best opportunities for prevention? Etc.) This intermediate period is not wasted. It is absolutely crucial for getting to the next stage, planning. Your conscious mind can’t plan, a mostly conscious activity, if you have not stoked the boiler, the subconscious, with plenty of wood.
You can’t plan until you have done your homework. You must have facts and insights and imaginings and what-ifs from which to work before you can do any more than the simplest planning.
But the duration is what makes it an issue for me. A few days is fine. I would guess that a lot of authors have that and to an extent it is natural. It is the stretches of weeks and sometimes months that scatter things so far afield that […]
This sounds like you don’t know what to do. Your mind-manager isn’t giving you assignments such as: “Okay, if you are starting with situation, then you should think of what kind of characters you want here. Now, start thinking about that.” Make a list of such assignments as they come to you. You are the boss of a sometimes not so swift employee who must be given specific assignments every day. But you give him space too because you know he does have imagination.
[…] I actually have to go back through my writing aims and goals and purposes to realign myself.
I repeatedly go back to my aims for every writing project. That is how you stay focused. This process of repeated “realignment” (and refueling) is the normal course of writing. It is not a sign of failure in any way.
And it is absolutely like being paralyzed, almost like being rebuffed by a unseen force. And with computers you have to be careful or you will have spent five hours playing a stupid game, or typing “dog-poo” on google to see what response returns. Sometimes I miss my Royal typewriter.
You don’t need to do that if you know what to do at this intermediate stage and if you give yourself specific, doable, discrete action items.
Have you studied – and I do mean studied – The Art of Nonfiction? It is as valuable for fiction writers as for nonfiction writers. I and another writer – he is a beginning fiction writer – met monthly to discuss one chapter at a time. It has a ton of information in it. It is much more craft-oriented than T_he Art of Fiction Writing_, which mostly focuses on the esthetics of romantic fiction.