“The proletariat will use its political supremacy to wrest, by degree, all capital from the bourgeoisie, to centralize all instruments of production in the hands of the state…”
“Evidence appears to be mounting that the Obama administration has systematically targeted for closing Chrysler dealers who contributed to Repubicans. What started earlier this week as mainly a rumbling on the Right side of the Blogosphere has gathered some steam today with revelations that among the dealers being shut down are a GOP congressman and closing of competitors to a dealership chain partly owned by former Clinton White House chief of staff Mack McLarty.”
Interesting, but this would certainly be hard to prove. I’ve done work for a lot of car dealers and believe that the vast majority of them are probably Republicans. They are, for the most part, small businessmen who are self-made. That usually isn’t the typical Democrat party contributor.
Interesting, but this would certainly be hard to prove. I’ve done work for a lot of car dealers and believe that the vast majority of them are probably Republicans. They are, for the most part, small businessmen who are self-made. That usually isn’t the typical Democrat party contributor.
Yeah, they leave out the kind of statistical analysis necessary to make the claim, and include some arbitrary filters to make the case stronger. For instance, they filter only owners of multiple dealerships in one example I’ve seen. I’d like to see a tally of all Dem dealerships and all Rep dealerships (& Hillary supporters, etc), and the percentages of those totals that were closed.
The underlying issue, however, is not whether the Obama administration actually did target Republican dealerships, but whether the policy they established provides the power to close dealerships arbitrarily. It is not even necessary to consider whether this or any future administration would actually use that power. It is only necessary to consider whether the fact of that power will compel dealerships to change their behavior based on the possibility of its use. The true evil of this power is that the government can claim innocence, much as a man with a gun in hand walking down the street can claim innocence when people “voluntarily” place their wallets in his free hand.
[on edit:] Of course, your point, that most dealers are likely to be Republican, does nothing to weaken the argument that the closures targeted Republicans. In fact, it seems to strengthen the argument, if anything. When you consider whether dealerships would have been targeted at all if they were unionized, you see that closing dealerships was a “safe” action, from the administration’s pro-union, pro-minority worldview. It helps “share the misery” of factory closings. Note that one of the criteria for closure was the income level of the surrounding community.
[on edit:] Of course, your point, that most dealers are likely to be Republican, does nothing to weaken the argument that the closures targeted Republicans. In fact, it seems to strengthen the argument, if anything. When you consider whether dealerships would have been targeted at all if they were unionized, you see that closing dealerships was a “safe” action, from the administration’s pro-union, pro-minority worldview. It helps “share the misery” of factory closings. Note that one of the criteria for closure was the income level of the surrounding community.
Given the things this Administration has done, I wouldn’t put it past them to target dealers who support Republican candidates. However, something that should be considered is that both GM and Chrysler have been talking about the need to close dealers for several years now. This isn’t an idea that the Obama thugs came up with in the last couple of weeks. Given the volume of cars they sell, there are far too many domestic nameplate dealers. This costs the manufacturers in terms of raising their expenses and making it more difficult for them to control the quality of the experience a car buyer encounters at a dealership. GM and Chrysler didn’t close more dealers prior to this financial crisis because the process is both time consuming and expensive in that they have to confront 50 different dealer franchise laws. When GM shut down its Oldsmobile division, getting rid of those dealerships alone cost them something in the range of a billion dollars. It was also a big distraction for the company’s management.