Peter Schiff has made the argument repeatedly that the US doesn’t manufacture anything, and that we need to start manufacturing more. Fellow Oist Stuart Hayashi argues that we in fact are manufacturing more:
This is why Peter Schiff is wrong to say that the United States is falling behind in its manufacturing, and for saying the USA doesn’t manufacture anything anymore.
It’s true that the number of U.S. manufacturing jobs has been decreasing, but that’s because of advances in automation. It doesn’t follow that just because the number of U.S. manufacturing jobs is decreasing, that U.S. manufacturing output correspondingly decreases. In 1900, more than 70 percent of the U.S. population worked on farms. Today, only 3 percent of the U.S. population works on farms. But in that span of time, agricultural output has increased both per-capita and in total. The same goes for manufacturing output and exports.
In absolute terms, the number for the USA’s manufacturing Industrial Production Index was 23.7 in 1960 A.D. and 112.9 in 2007 A.D.1
One could reply that it’s true that manufacturing output has increased in absolute terms in the past four decades, but so has the U.S. population, and that manufacturing output per capita has shrunk.
But that’s wrong. We can take the Industrial Production Index numbers for the years 1960 and 2007, and then divide them respectively by the U.S. populations from those same years. There were 180.671 million Americans in 1960 and 300.913 Americans in 2007.2
The manufacturing IPI number, per American, from 1960 was 1.31178 x 10^-7. For 2007, the figure was 3.75912 x 10^-7. That means that U.S. manufacturing output has increased per capita.
So, per person, the USA manufactures more utility, goods, and services today than it did in 1960.
I used the Consumer Price Index (CPI)3 to find that the United States earned $142.734 billion (in 2008 U.S. dollars) from manufactured goods exports in 1960, while it earned $1.291 trillion (in 2008 U.S. dollars) from exporting manufactured products in 2008.4
That means that the United States incurred $790.02 (in 2008 U.S. dollars) per person from its manufactured exports in 1960, and incurred $4,253.43 (in 2008 U.S. dollars) per person from its manufactured exports in 2008. So in terms of purchasing power, the USA still earns more money, per capita, from its exports today than it did in 1960. It’s true that the trade deficit has increased by a significant margin over those same 48 years, but that cannot be properly attributed to any decline in either U.S. manufacturing output or in U.S. manufacturing exports.