Hi,
Originally posted this article on my minds page earlier today: https://www.minds.com/AzraelRand
Quote
The Case for Open Objectivism
Before many of us even came to know and appreciate Objectivism, the movement had already been split into two factions: Those who believe that Objectivism should be viewed as a closed system, upholding the view that the philosophy as created and left by Ayn Rand is complete and does not require amending, and the other faction that believes that Objectivism ought to be viewed as an open system that requires amending in order to be considered complete. Both factions agree that Objectivism is the one and only true and moral philosophy required for mankind but they do not agree on whether or not it should be open to changes. This text makes the argument in favor of the Open Objectivist viewpoint and begins the process of examining the resulting logical and moral implications.
Ayn Rand designed Objectivism to be the one and only philosophy required for mankind to live a moral and fulfilling life on earth. How? By acknowledging objective reality as the one and only moral standard required to guide one’s life and by creating a philosophy that was aligned with and in harmony with human nature. The idea behind Objectivism is quite brilliant and is likely why many of us have made it our own philosophy. In theory, if one had a perfect understanding of objective reality, they would be able to live the most fulfilling life possible within the constraints of objective reality. Of course practice and theory don’t always perfectly overlap with one another as we all have come to experience firsthand. The great arbiter between these two entities is objective reality. Reality decides who is right and who is wrong. As Objectivists we all ought to be in agreement that objective reality is best fit to serve as the judge in this arbitration. But how do we do that? It’s not like there’s a person or god called objective reality we can simply ask or pray to in order to receive our answer.
The solution I favor is by observing the outcomes reality makes available to us. If Objectivism was correct and complete as-is and was in fact the one and only philosophy required for man to live a virtuous and fulfilling life, the outcomes produced by objective reality ought to support this. What would this look like in real life you might ask? Well for starters Objectivism would be the only state endorsed philosophical framework. There would be a statue, monument, or plaque displayed in every town or city commemorating Ayn Rand’s contributions to the world. Every class in school would be taught from an Objectivist framework. Streets, parks, museums, hospitals, landmarks, etc. would be named after Ayn Rand. Regretfully this isn’t the world we live in.
On a more individual basis, all other things being equal, it’s reasonable to assume that if we have all the objective facts and truths on our side and consistently put forth a strong effort we should be rewarded with our desired outcomes more times than not. If we’re not getting the outcomes we desire in this scenario, then the only logical conclusion is that we haven’t accounted for one or more objective truths in our belief system and are therefore not truly on the objective path yet. We can’t say that Objectivism at any point in its history was lacking talented, committed, and passionate spokespeople that had a solid understanding of the philosophy. We had Ayn Rand herself, Leonard Peikoff, and more recently Yaron Brook and many others. It really doesn’t get any better than that in my opinion.
If we can agree on the assertion that Objectivism isn’t perfect as-is we need to revisit the philosophy’s premise to see if it’s valid, and if that’s the case, we need to determine which objective truths aren’t currently accounted for. Assuming the premise of Objectivism is valid and we can correctly account for potential errors and/or omissions then it stands to reason that we should be able to influence our environment; something we haven’t been able to do in a major way thus far.
As previously discussed, Ayn Rand created Objectivism as a philosophy for man on earth. It is a philosophy built around embracing, not rejecting, objective truths and to make informed decisions based upon these truths applicable to both the individual and society as a whole. It was designed to be the one and only philosophy required for man to live a virtuous life in accordance with his nature. This may just be my own personal bias speaking here but I don’t see anything inherently wrong with this premise.
So let’s move on to a review of what major objectives truths are and aren’t accounted for by Ayn Rand in formulating the specifics of Objectivist doctrine.
Objectivism certainly accounts for the selfish aspect of human nature. It also rightfully states that embracing objective truths is a prerequisite towards achieving desired outcomes. Furthermore she believed reason to be the answer to uncovering these objective truths.
What I discovered while researching Objectivism’s shortcomings is that Objectivism does not correctly account for our tribal nature, biological differences between racial groups, and the fact that we are naturally led by emotions and not reason. Although these topics would be considered heresy by the originalist Objectivist doctrine, an objective overview of the subject matter at hand demands that facts be recognized for what they are even if they are emotionally unpleasant.
While I’m still in full agreement with Ayn Rand that discovering and embracing objective truths is a prerequisite towards achieving desired outcomes, I can no longer agree with the assertion that an individual’s application of reason is the single best means to uncover objective truths given our subjective nature. I would place the responsibility of uncovering objective truths on a scientific process structured in a way that incentivizes the discoveries of objective truths; more than one person involved in the process, built in checks and balances to account for human biases, etc. I’m not going to go as far as dismissing individual reasoning all together; rather I’m making the case for individual reasoning as validated by constructive criticism & objective research.
In addition, because Ayn Rand outright dismissed the tribal / groupish aspect of human nature, instead of accounting for it together with our selfish nature, and did not account for biological differences between racial groups, I can no longer fully support her body work that deals with how society ought to be organized. Ayn Rand taught us the horrendous consequences of dismissing the selfish aspects of human nature in her essays about socialism and communism. Today reality is informing us of the consequences of ignoring the groupish aspect of human nature. Instead of society embracing both our selfish and groupish aspects in harmony with human nature, we are instead collectively embracing what can only be described as irrational selfishness.
As stated before, I still fully support the original premise of Ayn Rand’s philosophy; however, I believe that it’s necessary for us Objectivists to explore the avenues that Ayn Rand would not or could not explore and to determine the associated logical implications. Doing so, in my opinion, is the only way forward if he hope to change our environment for the better.
A good starting point for anyone looking to do so is to read, study and internalize Jonathan Haidt’s book The Righteous Mind for a detailed analysis of human nature including our selfish and groupish nature, moral foundations, and the nature and limitations of the cognitive process. While I’m not in agreement with Haidt on what he views the implications of his findings ought to be as it relates to organizing society, I do wholeheartedly recommend the book for its detailed analysis of human nature. The revelations regarding human nature presented in his book were as enlightening to me as my first exposure to Ayn Rand.
If you’re interested, I also have a rebuttal to Stefan Molyneux’s UPB: https://www.minds.com/AzraelRand/blog/an-objective-critique-of-stefan-molyneux-s-universally-prefe-891837573402587136