The choice to live

Can it be said that in fact there is a reason to choose to live, namely that the preference of pleasure over pain is built-in, and one’s universe (given this is the case) is of a nature where pleasure (i.e., happiness) rather than pain (i.e., suffering) is the rule, rather than the exception? (E.g., given that one lives under a political form where such is the case.)

What do you think?

I think you should use the search button.

Can it be said that in fact there is a reason to choose to live, namely that the preference of pleasure over pain is built-in, and one’s universe (given this is the case) is of a nature where pleasure (i.e., happiness) rather than pain (i.e., suffering) is the rule, rather than the exception? (E.g., given that one lives under a political form where such is the case.)

What do you think?

To say pleasure is the “rule” would be to forget that immediate pleasure over pain is not sought out in many different contexts. “I like ice cream instead of a bullet in the face” is not the same as making long term goals for a kick-ass life, based on a rational standard of value. The choice to live is your own, and its based on your value judgements, in relation to reality.

j..

There is no such a thing as choice to live. To make any choices one has to be alive in the first place. Choice is corollary of life. One only can choose to die and even for that he has to be alive.

There is no such a thing as choice to live. To make any choices one has to be alive in the first place. Choice is corollary of life. One only can choose to die and even for that he has to be alive.

“Life or death is man’s only fundamental alternative. To live is his basic act of choice. If he chooses to live, a rational ethics will tell him what principles of action are required to implement his choice. If he does not choose to live, nature will take its course.”

The “choice to live”, as revealed in this quote, means the choice to engage in life-furthering or live-hindering actions.

There is no such a thing as choice to live.

You choose to live every time you eat. Were not rosebushes. Or, you choose to live when you choose not to die.

j..

I think that the built-in responses are the ‘evidence’ for living. In other words, proper and successful efforts to live will produce a maximized, long-term set of responses whose desirability is ‘built-in’ to the human consciousness. This is also why we live in certain ways. Absolute rationality visavis the maximum extension of healthy life would dictate that a person never eat sugars or meats. But they’re yummy and can be consumed in a manner that does not substantially detract from healthy living.

Responding to another comment here: is a human capable of choosing death? My hypothesis in this instance (and I am not by any means certain of it) is that the human choice faculty is incapable of choosing death. What we see in the case of sacrifice, suicide, stupidity are mis- and dis-integrations of knowledge. Faith, in other words, that death isn’t really what it is.

My hypothesis in this instance (and I am not by any means certain of it) is that the human choice faculty is incapable of choosing death. What we see in the case of sacrifice, suicide, stupidity are mis- and dis-integrations of knowledge. Faith, in other words, that death isn’t really what it is.

A mis-informed or ill-advised choice is still a choice. Your last sentence seems almost entirely speculative devoid of a more specific context. But then again, from your angle one can speculate that no one ‘knows’ what death really is even if the choose to avoid it. What if we continue living only because we assume death is not a better alternative? That makes our choice to live a ‘faithful’ choice.

“Life or death is man’s only fundamental alternative. To live is his basic act of choice. If he chooses to live, a rational ethics will tell him what principles of action are required to implement his choice. If he does not choose to live, nature will take its course.”

The “choice to live”, as revealed in this quote, means the choice to engage in life-furthering or live-hindering actions.

I think that to be exact the quote should read " If he chooses to continue to live", or as you said “to engage in life-furthering.” In other words " If he chooses not to die" . But one cannot choose to live since he is already alive.

You choose to live every time you eat. Were not rosebushes. Or, you choose to live when you choose not to die.

j..

Choice to live is not choice not to die. Strictly speaking one cannot choose to live since he is already alive. However, man can choose to live qua man or qua rosebush (read as parasite, secondhander). But this is already different topic.

I don’t think you can rationally choose between living and dying. Not for yourself anyway. For yourself, dying corresponds to non-existence, and there’s no way to compare non-existence to existence. As Peikoff said, all your concepts/ideas you might use to make an argument exist in the context of existence, not a context where you’re standing above both comparing.

Can it be said that in fact there is a reason to choose to live, namely that the preference of pleasure over pain is built-in,

Pleasure and pain are a complicated issue. Nevertheless, they tend to be reactionary-meaning that a certain act or event will result in pain or pleasure. If a human being refuses or chooses not to be rational (which is the choice for life), then it will not be possible for him to determine which pleasures are life-affirming or not. If you are married or are in a long term relationship, but fail to use your mind to discriminate between pleasures, just how many people do you think you will sleep with?

and one’s universe (given this is the case) is of a nature where pleasure (i.e., happiness) rather than pain (i.e., suffering) is the rule, rather than the exception? (E.g., given that one lives under a political form where such is the case.)

What do you think?

Pleasure can indeed take over pain as the predominant reaction of one’s universe. But that is contingent upon the moral system a person has built up and trained within themselves, the successful accomplishment of virtues, etc. One again, this is using the mind in conjunction with pleasure, not ignoring the mind in pursuit of pleasure.

This is also why we live in certain ways. Absolute rationality visavis the maximum extension of healthy life would dictate that a person never eat sugars or meats. But they’re yummy and can be consumed in a manner that does not substantially detract from healthy living.

You are adopting a dangerous contradiction here. Are you accepting a moral compromise by not practicing impeccable rationality? Or is there a problem with your observations about absolute rationality?

I don’t think you can rationally choose between living and dying. Not for yourself anyway.

I have heard and read many a soldier who disagrees with this. Or do you not think that charging into for sure death for the sake of a greater cause is a rational choice to die?

I have heard and read many a soldier who disagrees with this. Or do you not think that charging into for sure death for the sake of a greater cause is a rational choice to die?

I think maybe they’re not choosing death, but choosing between life as a slave if their side loses, vs a tiny chance of a normal life if they survive the battle. Because everyone believes that somehow they’ll be different, they’ll be the one to survive.

I don’t think you can rationally choose between living and dying. Not for yourself anyway. For yourself, dying corresponds to non-existence, and there’s no way to compare non-existence to existence. As Peikoff said, all your concepts/ideas you might use to make an argument exist in the context of existence, not a context where you’re standing above both comparing.

You’re treating the choice to live as if it is only seriously in doubt when made by people considering suicide or actions they know will result in their death. The point of Ayn Rand’s discussion of the “choice to live” is that this choice does NOT refer only to consciously deciding to keep on living. Living is a process, and there are many different things which either advance or hinder that process. Getting an education and building up a skillset that makes my future income more secure advances my life relative to not getting an education, while engaging in an action which I know will make me think lower of myself is life hindering, because my self-esteem is an important component of sustaining my life. A great number of the choices you and I make every day are manifestations of choosing between a life-furthering path and a life-hindering path, or as Ayn Rand put it, “the choice between life or death.” Most people choose each path very inconsistently; I may decide to show up for work on time and work hard, which is a manifestation of me choosing to live, and later the same day decide to eat a box of doughnuts for lunch or skip my exercise routine for no good reason, which is a manifestation of the choice to die. This later one might not strike you as literally a choice to die, but it is a choice which hinders my living of a flourishing life; my life is less secure than if I had made the other choice. A moral, virtuous life consists of an individual actively learning what is good for him and what is bad, and consistently making choices which enhance his life. This is why Ayn Rand’s virtues are focused around what is required for man to live his life in a full and complete manner; what man’s life qua man requires.

In certain situations the continuance of life for man qua man becomes impossible, life becomes its antithesis, a process of dying. In such a case man can rationally decide not to prolong his agony. This is rational and moral choice.

You are adopting a dangerous contradiction here. Are you accepting a moral compromise by not practicing impeccable rationality? Or is there a problem with your observations about absolute rationality?

There’s no contradiction. Rationality provides for the development of a hierarchy of values and their pursuit. The precise nature of those values is contextual. In the context of life vs. death, the resulting conclusions about what constitutes proper ethical choices are absolute. It is moral to eat to be nourished to live. However, the context of what to eat and why provides for a broader range of choices. Man’s nature dictates that he eats certain things, and cannot or should not eat other things. Moreover, his inborn or developed preferences further dictate what styles and types/flavors are desirable. Hierarchically, eating at all is most important, then eating healthily, then eating foods that taste desirable.

Therefore I can say that it is rationally moral to eat yummy foods because our biology responds positively to them. This is only true if you consider a context where higher values have been properly accounted for.

Extending the argument, a living things chooses to live because it is designed to do so. That’s what makes it ‘good’. A living thing designed to work against its own life would simply be a thing that after a short period of time is no longer living.

Because man lives - the result of man’s biology which pursues life - then it is proper and therefore moral for man to pursue life. His ability to use reason allows him to do so more successfully than otherwise. This use of reason provides for a hierarchy of values - which is why man’s biology which compels him to rape women for pleasure and genetic dominance (sometimes, it is theorized), is subordinate to his volition which, due to his rational faculty, acts in favor of higher values that consider the long term benefits of not committing a crime versus the short term gratification (among other reasons why rape is morally wrong).

But this is not a mysterious contradiction. A living thing inevitably - as part of its nature - would have as a base value the sustenance of its own life. No one need rationalize life - it is its own justification where it emerges.

This is why the choice of death is even permissible. A rational being chooses life because of the ‘evidence’ built into his nature - life is pleasurable, it is a reward. When the facts of reality overwhelm the provisions of that ‘evidence’ - during terminal and painful illness, or after the loss of all loved ones, or ones highest value etc. - then and only then would there be a ‘choice’ to live or not. Thus, life itself is not a ‘rational absolute’, but a consequence of some living thing’s contextual nature. Otherwise, death would never be a permissible choice.

Conversely, when reason proves - as in the rape example - the undesirability of an action, pleasure itself is not a proper reward. Thus some elements of man’s nature are subordinate to reason - the proper way of stating this being: because of reason, man is able to subordinate lesser parts of his nature to higher parts.

And my personal opinion - based on my hierarchy of values - is that there are so very many values to live for that even in many of the cases I just mentioned above would there be plenty of reason to live.

Therefore I can say that it is rationally moral to eat yummy foods because our biology responds positively to them. This is only true if you consider a context where higher values have been properly accounted for.

This does imply “absolute” rationality, though. Rationality involves recognition of one’s full context of existence, including what is required of living. Completely eliminating yummy foods would be irrational if they are part of your flourishing as an individual. But of course, one must recognize that consumption of such foods could lead to death in the long-term context. “Absolute” rationality is required to determine if “giving up” all (or some of) your favorite yummy foods will add to or detract from your flourishing. It would not be rational to consider life to be just maximizing heartbeats; it is redundant to label an action as “rationally moral.” An action is either rational or it is not. Any rational choice is morally good. No qualifier is required.

Extending the argument, a living things chooses to live because it is designed to do so. That’s what makes it ‘good’. A living thing designed to work against its own life would simply be a thing that after a short period of time is no longer living.

If you are designed to live, that is just determinism, because it would be to say you have no choice in the matter. It is true that virtually no one chooses death the first time such a choice is made, so it may be better to suggest that feelings of pleasure are what lead to the choice to live when you are first born. Still, there is nothing “built-in” about that. A choice still must be made, even if the choice is seemingly easy to make.

Because man lives - the result of man’s biology which pursues life - then it is proper and therefore moral for man to pursue life. His ability to use reason allows him to do so more successfully than otherwise. This use of reason provides for a hierarchy of values - which is why man’s biology which compels him to rape women for pleasure and genetic dominance (sometimes, it is theorized), is subordinate to his volition which, due to his rational faculty, acts in favor of higher values that consider the long term benefits of not committing a crime versus the short term gratification (among other reasons why rape is morally wrong).

Jeez, where did you hear that? Anyway, you seem to be suggesting that one has reason and emotions, and that reason can supersede emotion. To be compelled to find pleasure is an emotion, to be compelled to achieve “genetic dominance” (whatever that is supposed to be) is an emotion, so you can’t suggest either of these are biological mechanisms like reflexes. Use (or improper use in this case) of reason is what determines what emotions you have. It is not a matter of subordination, but of causality.

This does imply “absolute” rationality, though.

Yes, absolutely. But I was responding to someone who implied that my previous argument did not match up to the standard of ‘absolute’ rationality.

If you are designed to live, that is just determinism, because it would be to say you have no choice in the matter. It is true that virtually no one chooses death the first time such a choice is made, so it may be better to suggest that feelings of pleasure are what lead to the choice to live when you are first born. Still, there is nothing “built-in” about that. A choice still must be made, even if the choice is seemingly easy to make.

Yes, it is determinism. If I eat rat poison, I will die. My biology determines this. But is it philosophical determinism? I’ll discuss that in a minute, but first I want to make clear that I am trying to say that the fact of life is what makes life moral for those things that possess it. The conditions of life determine the details of what the proper values are for that living thing. The only way to escape those values is to change the nature of the thing so that its life demands some other values for its proper existence. This is not an argument about volition - it is a general argument about all living things.

Jeez, where did you hear that? Anyway, you seem to be suggesting that one has reason and emotions, and that reason can supersede emotion. To be compelled to find pleasure is an emotion, to be compelled to achieve “genetic dominance” (whatever that is supposed to be) is an emotion, so you can’t suggest either of these are biological mechanisms like reflexes. Use (or improper use in this case) of reason is what determines what emotions you have. It is not a matter of subordination, but of causality.

Bad example - I mentioned that compulsive rape instincts are a theory. The most extreme case came to mind first, sorry. After a quick google search on the matter it seems like this theory, along with all ‘evolutionary psychology’ theories are subject to ongoing debate. I can’t say it’s true, and won’t try to use it, but the theory has been put forward and hasn’t yet been summarily refuted. It seems there is little solid evidence for it, however.

The larger argument about volition is important, though. You cannot argue that emotions are not similar to reflexes - at least some of them. Many Objectivists uphold an absolute wall between the rational and the irrational. I refer to psycho-epistemology - about which I admit I know very little. Yet, is there any evidence that emotions are the result of purely cognitive processes? That the rational faculty of the mind operates independently of the irrational and reflexive. I have to be clear on this: I’m not saying that reason is colored by human bias - reason is pure. I’m saying that human biases interfere with the use of reason, or can, and often do. The precise details of this are part of the science of psychology.

Why can’t an emotion be part of a biological mechanism? Because emotions have to do with cognitive processes? Because the rational faculty of the mind is necessarily independent from reflex - never subordinated to it? That seems like an absurd proposition to advocate for. What I do know of the world and the science of psychology is that there is plenty of evidence that emotions are at least heavily influenced by biological processes - at least sometimes. Is there even a debate here?

Reason is a tool to achieve values. Volition is the means by which reason is applied. But I would say that many of those values are deterministic - you can’t nor ever did choose to be human, future technology notwithstanding. Certain mystical traditions think that volition of the soul led to the accepting of the human form. Hogwash. To a certain extent, values are determined from the onset. Otherwise you might as well choose to be dead.

I think the right way to approach this argument is to answer this question: what is man? If man’s essence is his rational faculty - then the circumstances of his upbringing might provide him with values to pursue, and accordingly an ethical code which he must follow to achieve them - but in essence, that faculty itself has no ‘deterministic’ need to pursue life.

Or, man, in essence, is the sum of his parts. I don’t think you can argue otherwise. Possessing a rational faculty, he must use it to maximize his values. But many of those values will be biologically determined - and to an extent not yet known, you have to wonder how much of the faculty of consciousness depends on those values to operate. Again, caution, I don’t mean that ‘real reality’ is inaccessible to man: I mean that only certain constrained parts of reality are relevant to man’s values. For instance, infrared cannot be seen. RGB can be seen. A beautiful sunset is appreciated in RGB, not in infrared - and even if the spectrum was converted on a monitor to RGB, it’s still seen in RGB. Art will never be in infrared, so the nature of beauty is somewhat constrained by man’s biological nature. Art can express order or chaos - generalized representations of life or death - but ‘what’ on a canvas represents order (lines, triangles, red, orange, pink, circles?) is determined by man’s nature. Geometric consistency as order is fundamental to man’s existence as a living thing - the ultimate alternative of to be or not to be. Further, certain dyes and pigments provoke emotions that correlate ordered patterns with values. Why is dark negative, blue cool, white positive, orange hot? Because of the corresponding things in nature that man is accustomed to by either upbringing or evolution. Whether hot or cool is the appropriate value for a man depends, but whether blue is the appropriate color for cool - that is more or less determined.

That life is valuable for life is inherent. It’s why life is, and why ‘is’ is. ‘Life is good’ is somewhat axiomatic for living things. Man’s choices are not determined, but his ultimate values are. So when would a man choose death? This is the question of the thread basically.

When the value of death is higher than life. Is this possible? Are there any values outside of life? People have already commented on this. My contribution, given my comments, has been: life is valuable for a reason exogenous to the volitional faculty. I’m saying its biology. I’m saying that’s not a contradiction, because volition serves biology, yet remains rational in doing so - acknowledging that certain values are exogenous to the cognitive faculty: why does cake taste good? because that’s what my tongue says (you then go on and determine the consequence of eating too much cake etc., but the statement itself is true).

There’s a deeper metaphysical issue here, and it plagues every modern science. It’s related to the halting problem in computing. I’ll look it up and comment on another thread.

But really? Emotions are only in response to thoughts? No relation to reflex?