The Morality Of Pandering To Customer Irrationality

This came out of the branding and brand names thread.

I put forward a case of two identical white t-shirts - made from the same cotton, same methods, same factory, etc. etc. There is one slight difference - one has a cK label but the other has a Target label. The cK one will sell for a higher price, even though rationally, they are identical.

However, there are example situations where charging a premium for a plain white cK t-shirt would be rational. Say that the cK one is sold at an upmarket department store. It’s not crowded, there is classical music being played subtly, the interior design is aesthetically pleasing, etc. The Target one is sold at a store with screaming kids, long queues, clothes strewn all over the floor, etc. At the end of the day, you’re not paying the premium for just the t-shirt, but the combined shopping experience.

Or with cars, one car may come with a better after-care package, even if in every other way, they are identical.

But for the purposes of this discussion, we’ll leave the above scenarios (and many others like it) out.

Assume that both t-shirts are sold at an identical place. The cK one will warrant a higher price. Marketers are aware of the irrationality involved. Is it a moral practice?

I challenge your basic assumption that a cK t-shirt sold at the same place as an identical Target t-shirt will warrant a higher price. I know, I used to work at Marshall’s.

In case you’re unfamiliar with this company, they buy clothing and housewares overruns, irregulars, pretty much everything that didn’t sell well enough originally, price it way, way down, and re-sell it. Generic t-shirts would usually roll out without too much trouble . . . a lot of the designer stuff was still priced too high for quality and would wind up sitting on the shelf until it got clearanced down to less than a dollar.

Attempts like these to pander to irrationality usually don’t work out in your favor. I mean, we only had the cK t-shirts because they couldn’t sell them anyway. If you price too high for your quality you will not move your stock.

I agree with JMegansnow that, for the most part, an identical product will not be able to warrant a higher price on brand alone.

There are a number of famous disasters in the auto industry where they got burned with “badge engineering,” as it is called in that biz. The Cadillac Cimmeron comes to mind: made in the 1980s, it was a Chevy Cavalier that was re-badged as a Cadillac with minimal/no changes (I think it had leather seats…). It failed horribly and negatively affected Cadillac’s sales of their other cars.

A logo’d t-shirt is actually a bad example, since t-shirts are pretty much identical; the buyer is essentially paying for the logo. That is one instance in which the brand is legitimately the source of the purchase price.

IA logo’d t-shirt is actually a bad example, since t-shirts are pretty much identical; the buyer is essentially paying for the logo. That is one instance in which the brand is legitimately the source of the purchase price.

Pfft. T-shirts are not “pretty much identical”. I can think of a lot of factors that make one preferable over another, such as whether it’s see-through or not, whether it shrinks to the size of a gum wrapper in the dryer, whether it binds up under your armpits (something that can happen even if it’s the right “size”), whether it’s long enough for you to tuck into your waistband, whether the cotton is coarse so it’s extremely scratchy, or if it has a spandex blend so it hugs your curves nicely, etc. etc. etc.

Hmm, OK.

Let’s forget t-shirts.

What about the New Coke case? As I remember (please correct the details if I’m wrong), Coke in the 70’s was losing market share to Pepsi. So in the 80’s, they came up with New Coke, which had a sweeter flavour. In blind market testing, it was found that people overwhelmingly preferred the taste of New Coke to the old Coke. Because of this, they introduced the new product on to the market supported by a huge advertising campaign.

But as everyone knows, it was a massive failure. People (I think) took to the streets in protest, saying things like “Don’t mess with MY Coke”. Consequently, old Coke was released back on to the market and sold in huge numbers. All this despite the fact that people thought New Coke tasted better.

Isn’t this a case of consumer irrationality and marketers pandering to it?

Pfft. T-shirts are not “pretty much identical”.

Point taken, but I think that my observation remains valid: that when a person buys a logo’d t-shirt, they do so for the logo and not for the shirt.

For the record, I don’t think I own any logo’d shirts, unless the tiny little “dockers” or “ralph polo guy” symbol that is stiched into the front counts.

Isn’t this a case of consumer irrationality and marketers pandering to it?

Having tasted both New Coke and Original, I’d say no… it was a case of bad focus groups.

Actually, when you put Coke, Pepsi, and RC in a blind taste test, RC wins. Yet RC is sold at a discount compared to the big 2 and is but a mere fly on the windshield of the big drink makers. Why? Coke and Pepsi are known quantities. People are generally afraid of change. Marketing exists to either reinforce that or to allay fears of change by stressing the positive effects of change.

I think my comment from the other thread makes more sense. I shop at SYMS which take remaindered suits and overurns from major manufacturers and retailers that have gone bankrupt, removes the labels, and then sells them at a deep discount. This is really the only case that I can think of your point. Correct me if I’m wrong.

If I go to SYMS and buy what is a Dolce & Gabbana suit that had it’s label removed by D&G and SYMS added their label in, I am buying the same suit for $300 less. Same suit, just a lower price. Significantly. Is what you are saying about irrationality that I would be irrational to go to a D&G shop and one of their suits off the rack and end up paying $300 more than I could otherwise?

Pretty much, yes. In fact, that is a good example. As is the RC Cola one - like you said, people can have a fear of change even for very low-involvement items. (I mean, come on, we’re talking soft drinks here!)

Going back to the D&G suit example however, such an action may be rational to an extremely wealthy person, to whom an extra $300 could be a small price to pay for the ambience of the D&G store, the attentive service, proximity to his place to work/home, etc.

But if someone is paying the extra $300 JUST for the label, then I believe that this is irrational.

Also, Megan, overstock is not necessarily an indication that people are unwilling to buy a certain item - it could be an oversupply issue.

Pretty much, yes. In fact, that is a good example. As is the RC Cola one - like you said, people can have a fear of change even for very low-involvement items. (I mean, come on, we’re talking soft drinks here!)

My old employer had a poster in our web guys development office that said “change is change.” Basically when it comes to change, it doesn’t matter how minor it is someone is going to notice it. So we’d do all we could to extend the existing website interface instead of modifying the navigation. I’ve seen it on my current job. I have customer call me up completely flustered that we changed the shade of purple on our site and demanded to speak with someone over me about the change. Seriously.

Going back to the D&G suit example however, such an action may be rational to an extremely wealthy person, to whom an extra $300 could be a small price to pay for the ambience of the D&G store, the attentive service, proximity to his place to work/home, etc.

But if someone is paying the extra $300 JUST for the label, then I believe that this is irrational.

Again, you aren’t paying just for the label. It’s all the other stuff you mention. Plus, I really hate SYMS since I have to dig and dig to find a nice suit that fits me, etc. So that $300 is in a way worth it. Again, when you buy a brand name, you aren’t just buying a label, you are buying everything that is associated with it.

So when you buy a suit at D&G, you get a higher level of service, you know that you are getting a genuine article, and a real sense of the style. When I bought the suit at SYMS, I got a very different shopping experience. So even though the suit is the same, it’s really impossible to say any two items are exactly the same. Even if you have two exact items, there will end up being something that differentiates the two. It may be something minor or ephemeral, but there is something.

Actually, the label itself may have value. If you are in sales, you could use the label of the clothes to align yourself with a customer.I know someone that was in the last stages of negotiating a sale with a large computer company and at the last minute he pulled out his Palm Pilot to check a note. The thing is, Palm was one of their major competitors. They flat out said that if he didn’t like the company enough to use their product over an inferior one (Palm) then they wouldn’t do business with his company. Of course they lost out on the benefits of working with my friends firm but I could say that they have a valid point. I’d rather do business with someone who truly understands my product/service from multiple perspectives. So yes, in some cases a brand name or label can be rational to pay additonal amounts of money. It’s a stretch and not something you see every day unless you are in sales.