There are other topic on this issue but they are mostly about the right of a state to conquere land marginally controlled by barbaric natives rather than claim unoccupied terriroty.
Does a government have a right to expand into terriroty which is uncontrolled by any other state? Must the government recieve a request by friendly or national occupants of the unruled territory? Does government authority automatically expand into areas in which national citizens have occupied?
Specific Scenario 1: The US government uses its satellites to discover a deserted island in the Pacific Ocean. Can the government claim this land? Must the government put the land towards some sort of offical state use (build a naval base) before claiming it? Can the government claim the land and then auction off for private use?
Specific Scenario 2: A deserted island is discovered in the Pacific Ocean. An American citizen finds the island first and then claims it as his own property (to cement this claim, he builds a house, a port, and puts a good chunk of the island into use). Can the man ask the US government for his island to be annexed into US territory? Should the US govenrment grant such requests?
Specific Scenario 3: A deserted island is discovered in the pacific ocean by a group of Americans. The members pf the group each individually lay claim to the island and then dispute each others’ claims. Should or can the state intervene to settle this legal dispute?