I think we all agree that the focus of the lives of most people is the procurement of desired goods and services. In practice, goods can be obtained through production or trade.
Professional politicians, the kind you meet in all western states today, are, from this perspective, traders of popularity and pull.
They trade popularity because that’s the main capital/raw material of their trade. It is their main concern to appeal to the most people, ideally to the most powerful, and to do so in way that is safe from the perspective of their life-long carrer in politics.
Therefore, the chief aim of the skilled politician is 2 fold: first, to obtain decision positions in the public sector, and secondly, to secure the political support/pull and/or votes to attain higher positions in the State’s hierarchy.
Much like in a Karl Popper-esque debate, the fact that truth sides with one group or another is irrelevant, since a politicians has more chances to a prosperous life by selling the illusion of truth than truth itself.
We regard politicians as master con-artists, because we perceive them via the condescending moral superiority of production. But simply because production is mandatory for survival, that doesn’t make it otherwise superior to other means of attaining valuables.
The question I’d like to ask you is this:
Why should one person who would make a particularly succesful and gifted politician, repress in himself this skill and instead try to shoe-horn himself into a mediocre production job? Is that really self-interest?
If one is knowleagable in matters of human nature, politics and manipulation, why should he feel ashamed of his nature?
My “larger” theory is that the Objectivist view of universal self-interest as expressed in laissez-faire capitalism is not best for everyone.
I do agree that there are certain people who are best suited for life in capitalism, but I do also think that capitalism can be a disaster for a large portion of the population, from the perspective of their self-interest.
At this point, I’m equating self-interest with survival and material prosperity. I see no reason to expect self-interest to any other kind of ‘ethical considerations’.
‘Man’s survival qua man’, but not all men are the same, therefore, all with which we are left is ‘survival’. ‘Qua man’ is too contextual for anything other than individual/particular considerations.