The Roman Republic

To Zeus: Thanks so much for those links on carthage. This is why it is always important to have all the facts. I have read in various sources that Carthage was far more commercial than Rome and the greatest commercial civilization of antiquity. Cartheneginan merchants were legendary. However, Carthage gets a bad rap for its early history of human sacrifice which I believe by the time of Hanibal was rarely if ever practiced. I have often thought about writing Objectivist historian John Lewis what his interpretation of the Punic Wars were. He specializes in the history of antiquity. It seems the war starts over broken treaties and a desire for a hedgemony over the western Medeteranian. So the motives seem bad on both ends. But Hanibal stayed on the Italian penninsula for close to 20 years and through his military victories he killed one out of every four Italian men of fighting age. He supposedly had a deep hatred for Romans. The Romans therefore feared for their very lives and in their minds were fighting for survival. The fate of the vanquished was brutal in ancient times. So I really don’t know who to praise and who to condemn. It may not be that simple.

The third Punic war on the other hand which resulted in the total destruction of Carthage always seemed to me excessive. Cato the elder’s famous ‘Carthago Delende Est’ and the war which resulted has received many differing historical treatments. It has been praised as an example of a necessary pre-emptive strike (which is relevant in our day and age). It has also been treated as the start of Roman imperialistic expansionism as they destroyed the Greek City Corinth in the very same year (146 BC). I’m all for pre-empitve attacks but to my knowledge, Carthage was no longer a threat at that time and they were such a productive nation. I honestly don’t know.

Anyway, thanks again to Zeus for doing some research. To me, Roman history is a fascinating subject, especially since there are so many parallels with America.

Now this guy I’m argueing with said that Caeser was positive for individual rights because began to limit slavery and he expanded citizenship. Whereas Cicero he claims never spoke out against Slavery.

First thing: I have heard and read a number of solid historians say that there was no challenge to the institution of slavery on philosophical grounds in the ancient world. There were many slave revolts (ie Spartacus), but there was no challenge to the institution. So to use that against Cicero is unfair. Even Aristotle wrote a defense of the institution although there is debate as to exactly what he meant when he used the term ‘slave’. There was no abolitionist or civil rights movement in 44 BC. While I have read that the Ceasers did extend Roman Citizenry to more of the Latin peoples, I believe they did this partially for pragmatic purposes; to placate angry mobs of latin non-citizens and to obtain a bigger population from which to draw forth legionaires for the Roman army (I actually believe much of the expanded citizenry dates back to the times of Mara). So this argument against Cicero and for Ceaser seems week to me.

Second: I think a mistake can be made to judge Rome as simply ‘Republic’ versus ‘Empire’. The problem with the republic was that it was so corrupt. It also had a huge class warfare issue that it was never able to resolve. The republic had actually been in decline for close to 80 years by the time you get to the 1st Triumverate (The period in Roman history know as the ‘military dynasts’). There had been a mini civil war between the Plabeans and the Patricians and there had been the coup by the despotic tyrant Sulla (who killed Ceaser’s uncle I believe). So there were major systemic problems with the republican structure by the time of Cicero and Ceaser. Historians will always tell you that after Julius Ceaser and especially after Agustus, the Roman world was far better administered and far less corrupt. Thats why I said in an earlier post that these men did benefit Rome but they did so on a foundation of quicksand. They established an empire based on the rule of a single man and a large corruptable beauracracy. It took four centuries, but these failings eventually swallowed Rome.

Again, as I said, it is very difficult to arrive at a propper moral evaluation of many historical figures (especially ancient) because there are so many factors that have to be analyzed. But that being said, Cicero’s legacy as the quotes provided by CICEROSC showed is one of the defense of liberty and rights. I don’t see how the same could be said for Ceaser.

To Zeus: Thanks so much for those links on carthage. This is why it is always important to have all the facts. I have read in various sources that Carthage was far more commercial than Rome and the greatest commercial civilization of antiquity. Cartheneginan merchants were legendary. However, Carthage gets a bad rap for its early history of human sacrifice which I believe by the time of Hanibal was rarely if ever practiced. I have often thought about writing Objectivist historian John Lewis what his interpretation of the Punic Wars were. He specializes in the history of antiquity. It seems the war starts over broken treaties and a desire for a hedgemony over the western Medeteranian. So the motives seem bad on both ends. But Hanibal stayed on the Italian penninsula for close to 20 years and through his military victories he killed one out of every four Italian men of fighting age. He supposedly had a deep hatred for Romans. The Romans therefore feared for their very lives and in their minds were fighting for survival. The fate of the vanquished was brutal in ancient times. So I really don’t know who to praise and who to condemn. It may not be that simple.

The third Punic war on the other hand which resulted in the total destruction of Carthage always seemed to me excessive. Cato the elder’s famous ‘Carthago Delende Est’ and the war which resulted has received many differing historical treatments. It has been praised as an example of a necessary pre-emptive strike (which is relevant in our day and age). It has also been treated as the start of Roman imperialistic expansionism as they destroyed the Greek City Corinth in the very same year (146 BC). I’m all for pre-empitve attacks but to my knowledge, Carthage was no longer a threat at that time and they were such a productive nation. I honestly don’t know.

Anyway, thanks again to Zeus for doing some research. To me, Roman history is a fascinating subject, especially since there are so many parallels with America.

No problem, Argive99, the pleasure is mine. Thank you for the information on this thread.

He also said that since voting is not a right what rights did Caeser take away?

Both the voting and the slavery comments are simply out of context. Caesar was no more interested in abolishing the institution of slavery than he was flying to the moon. He was interested in consolidating his power against the Senate and the middle classes by increasing the numbers and influence of those who would oppose them – nothing more, nothing less.

Is the Democratic party the party of individual freedom because they want to add to the voting roles every felon and every illiterate they can find?

Isn’t in republic the head of the state elected by the people. In Rome too, the head of the state was elected by people, or just by the nobles?

Isn’t in republic the head of the state elected by the people. In Rome too, the head of the state was elected by people, or just by the nobles?

In Republican Rome there were two heads of state which were called ‘consuls’. I believe they were elected by both the senate and the assembly. They served for one year. Any major issue (ie going to war) required unanamity, both had to agree. In times of crisis, Rome would enstate a ‘dictator’, which had total power for a limited time; ie 6 months or untill the crisis ended.

This was used during the war with Hanibal when the legendary Quintus Fabius Maximus was elected Dictator to deal with the Cartheneginian threat. It was also used even more famously during the war with the Celts in roughly 300 BC when Rome itself was overrun and the citizens were forced to flee. A dictator named Cincinatus was elected to deal with the Celts. He was a great general who was retired and living and working on his farm as a farmer. (He is also the inspiration behind Maximus in the movie ‘Gladiator’) He came out of retirement, defeated the Celts and returned to his farm before his reign as dictator ended. He actually renounced power. It is no suprise that Cincinatus was loved by George Washington who was a member of the ‘Cincinatus club’, especially after he retired.

The Romans were smart enough to know that in crisis situations sometimes consensus rule is not practical and leadership should be in the hands of one strong willed man. Thus the dictator, which is the origin of our word today, although the term has come to mean the wielding of and total abuse of absolute power.

Isn’t in republic the head of the state elected by the people. In Rome too, the head of the state was elected by people, or just by the nobles?

Also, it would be incorrect to take comments in favor of Cicero and Republican Rome as implying that they were faultless paragons of Objectivism. They certainly had their faults, but I like to think it is a characteristic of being objective that when one position is 98% correct, and another position is 5% correct, the objective thing to do is praise the one that is 98% right, rather than focusing primarily on its 2% errors and applauding the 95% wrong position.

To focus on Cicero’s faults as equivalent in importance to his virtues would be analogous to Ayn Rand’s example of including a blister in a painting a beautiful woman. The resulting distortion says much more about the person who is making it than it does about the subject.

Was Cicero the first person to recognize “natural law”?

Was Cicero the first person to recognize “natural law”?

This is actually a fascinating subject which I am about to study right now. What I can say is that many scholars place the origins of natural law with the Greek Stoic school of philosophy of which Cicero was very influenced by. The Stoics were the leading philosophical school for much of Roman History although all four of the major Greek schools of philosophy had their influence.

The four schools, by the way, were recognized by the Roman Emporer Marcus Aurileus when he endowed four chairs I believe in Athens recognizing each of the four schools; the Platonists, the Peripitetics (Aristoteleans), the Stoics, and the Epicurians. The Greko/Roman moralists of the Imperial period were an eclectic mix of these four schools with an emphasis on Stoicism. Aristoteleanism was present but was not the dominant thought system. If it were, history might have gone differently.

Is it true that Marcus Aurileus like the movie Gladiator depicts tryed to restore the Republic?

Is it true that Marcus Aurileus like the movie Gladiator depicts tryed to restore the Republic?

No. There is no attempt to restore the Republic made at any time after its fall. Aurileus was the last of what has come to be known as ‘The Five Great’ Emporers of the 2nd century AD. He originally shared power with his brother Lucius Verus as co-emporer before his brother died. He is known as being merciful for this as he could easily have had his brother killed. He was a great administrator and the Empire functioned smoothly under his reign. However, it is with his son, Comodus, that Rome starts its decent. Comodus is, I believe, one of the first of what is know as the “idiosyncratic emporers”.

Although, to be accurate, Rome would redefine itself at least three or four more times before it falls, and then its ‘fall’ is really only in the west as the eastern empire lived on.

Carthage was a very wealthy trade city, with a decent constitution. But the moral fiber of its people was very lacking, whereas, as Polybius shows, Romans were quite the opposite at the time.

Btw, Carthaginians still practiced human sacrifice even in Hannibal’s time - child sacrifice, to be specific. Many child bones have been found at what is believed to be a temple of Baal, their version of Zeus. The city was a wreck during the Punic Wars, torn by competition of a handful of extremely powerful families and in perrenial conflicts with its mercenaries. Thus Hannibal did not get reinforcements when he was in Italy because an opposing family prevented it. Plus, as Polybius says, Carthaginian citizens were almost never called up for war, and were effeminate and shifty in contrast to the hardy Romans.

Rome was the model for America in more than one way. First, the actual government institutions closely mirror those of Roman Republic (see electoral college, for example, and govt. buildings’ architecture and names, such as Capitol Hill). Second, the Roman people were a model for the American people to follow - hence the Founding Fathers’ dream of a country of farmers who own their small plots of land but come together in defense of liberty. Modern revisionists often make fun of this dream as pathetic and naiive, as it might seem to those born after the Industrial Revolution. But for those living in pre-Industrial Enlightenment, it was a noble idea indeed.

A trade republic such as Rhodes and Carthage might have been impressive to the Founding Fathers, but an agrarian society of hardy small farmers was their true ideal. Originally America was brimming with Rome-worship: look at the name Cinncinati, a “city of men as virtuous as Cinncinatus”. Mildly ironic huh?

Oh and I can go on forever about the Roman institution of dictatorship, something that is without equal in the ancient world, as far as I know. To have a fully electoral government, and then to be able to give it up and place one’s lives and hopes in one man’s hands, when incredible emergencies came up, is a sign of a pretty remarkable people. Moreover, men chosen as dictators have never violated their power, in 400 years of Republic’s existence, despite the fact that their power was absolute, and they could legally kill anyone and steal anything they wished. A sign of remarkable people indeed.

<FC: moved to History forum>