To Zeus: Thanks so much for those links on carthage. This is why it is always important to have all the facts. I have read in various sources that Carthage was far more commercial than Rome and the greatest commercial civilization of antiquity. Cartheneginan merchants were legendary. However, Carthage gets a bad rap for its early history of human sacrifice which I believe by the time of Hanibal was rarely if ever practiced. I have often thought about writing Objectivist historian John Lewis what his interpretation of the Punic Wars were. He specializes in the history of antiquity. It seems the war starts over broken treaties and a desire for a hedgemony over the western Medeteranian. So the motives seem bad on both ends. But Hanibal stayed on the Italian penninsula for close to 20 years and through his military victories he killed one out of every four Italian men of fighting age. He supposedly had a deep hatred for Romans. The Romans therefore feared for their very lives and in their minds were fighting for survival. The fate of the vanquished was brutal in ancient times. So I really don’t know who to praise and who to condemn. It may not be that simple.
The third Punic war on the other hand which resulted in the total destruction of Carthage always seemed to me excessive. Cato the elder’s famous ‘Carthago Delende Est’ and the war which resulted has received many differing historical treatments. It has been praised as an example of a necessary pre-emptive strike (which is relevant in our day and age). It has also been treated as the start of Roman imperialistic expansionism as they destroyed the Greek City Corinth in the very same year (146 BC). I’m all for pre-empitve attacks but to my knowledge, Carthage was no longer a threat at that time and they were such a productive nation. I honestly don’t know.
Anyway, thanks again to Zeus for doing some research. To me, Roman history is a fascinating subject, especially since there are so many parallels with America.