The Sacrifice of the Individual for the Nation

I know this is an Objectivist forum. I myself have missed over Objectivism for a while, and have read Atlas Shrugged, The Fountainhead, Anthem, and I’m currently ~35% through The Virtue of Selfishness, as well as reading other assorted Objectivist literature. Atlas Shrugged is one of my favorite books, although I’m sure Rand would denounce me for hypocrisy for not understanding it and asking this question. So much of it appeals to me logically, but the point comes when, in both my own mental discussions and with friends, one is forced to ponder that under Objectivism a single person cannot morally be sacrificed for millions to live. I also don’t understand why individual rights can’t add. Any clarification on this would be helpful. For the sake of an airtight philosophy, I will try to disprove it, though. Thanks!

Objectivism does not say you should not sacrifice your life for a nation, provided that it is your rational choice and you are not forced to. In some circumstances, those who value freedom not only for themselves but for others would find overwhelming reasons to do so. Each person must live by their own rational judgement, and for many, including myself, in Australia, where I live, my belief in the Australian spirit of mateship and a fair go would necessitate voluntarily joining the military or military-related endeavours if we were invaded, etc.

Many things people think Ayn Rand was against, she was not, as long as it was each individual’s rational choice and did not violate others’ ability to live their lives by their rational choices.

I do not believe she said a person can’t sacrifice themselves, nor am I hear to equivocate over the nature of selfishness. This doesn’t address either of my issues, although they were quite poorly put. I’m trying to edit my post, but it appears I can’t now. Such is life. Either way, here are my still unanswered dilemmas. Under Objectivism, the State cannot sacrifice an individual even if their death would save millions. If the State knew with absolute certainty that a larger state would kill their small state of a million people unless they killed one innocent person, Objectivism claims it is immoral to kill that person. That does not seem rational, feasible, or just. Furthermore, as kind of a more abstract question, Objectivism argues against the idea of Collectivized rights, stating they are impossible and that rights themselves are only possess only for the individual. Why can’t individual rights add up?

1 Like

Thanks for responding!

1 Like

The “adding up” objection treats rights as a collective pool of claims. On Objectivism, a right is a principle governing how each person may be treated: it bars others from initiating force against an individual, and it does not become stronger by multiplying the number of people who benefit. If the state kills an innocent person, it commits murder even if an aggressor threatens millions; the aggressor is responsible for the threat, and institutionalizing an exception would undercut the very rights that protect everyone. Voluntary sacrifice is different from state coercion.

I already said I know all this. You saying this is what Objectivism is, but not proving it means nothing. I don’t care if it rejects it, unless it proves it.