The Space-time Continuum

In an earlier thread on space and time, I wrote the following (trying, in my ignorance, to formulate a definition):

"Metaphysically, entites are space; epistemologically, entities are spacial. Time is the measurement of the spacial relationship between entities.

…

Time is an abstract (i.e., conceptual) expression of one kind of relationship (motion) between entities. Spacial relationships determine temporal ones. Both are epistemological, not metaphysical, in nature because both are abstract concepts defining relationships (and their measurements) between entities in reality."

Halley responded that he still had a gripe with my formulation: “Relationships between objects are metaphysical.”

Okay, I see that point.

Then y_feldblum stated that:

“Spacial relationships and temporal ones do not depend on each other. I fact, spatial and temporal relationships are merely the two aspects of a single more fundamental relationship, the spacetime interval… Interval means distance between - but here it’s neither spacial distance nor temporal distance but both at once. Just as extent in any one direction is not an existent, but all three directions of exten taken together are, so all three are not, but all three plus time are.”

For reasons I won’t go into, I didn’t go back to the thread after Richard Halley’s post. I’m creating a new thread because I’m interested in clearing up my concepts.

I don’t understand what y_feldblum means, though I’ve heard the term “spacetime continuum” used in popular science-fiction.

Can someone explain to me: 1) The Objectivist definition of space and time (I’ve never heard it defined), and 2) what is meant by the term spacetime interval.

I don’t think there is an “Objectivist” definition of space and time; questions pertainng to the nature of these entities would lie within the field of physics, not philosophy. The space-time interval is a concept from the scientific theory of special relativity. Im sure someone else would be able to recommend you an introductory level book on the subject if you’re interested.

Can someone explain to me: 1) The Objectivist definition of space and time (I’ve never heard it defined), and 2) what is meant by the term spacetime interval.

Both space and time are relationships among things, not things in themselves. In philosophy we speak of space as the distance between (implied or real) entities, without consideration of the nature of that which lies in between. We abstract away the properties of that which exists between the entities whose distance in space we measure. Time is a change in relationship among processes or entities. It is, in effect, a measure of motion or changes in state.

Spacetime is a concept of physics, not philosophy. Specifically, in relativity, spacetime is a mathematical abstraction, not a thing. It is like a coordinate system – a collection of points – no different in principle from any other coordinate system used in classical physics. In mathematics one may establish coordinates with any number of dimensions, but that does not imply that such dimensions physically exist together.

An economic model might create a 4-dimensional space where the coordinates are supply, demand, profit, and year. This set of points can be given certain mathematical properties, such as a topology or differential relationships – this entire collection is called a manifold. By analyzing mathematically what occurs in this manifold, some prediction may be made as to real world behavior. There is no implication, however, that supply, demand, profit, and year all physically exist as dimensions together within the model: the manifold is just a mathematical abstraction.

Likewise in relativity a mathematical space is created, one which has coordinates with three spatial dimensions and one for time. Certain properties are given to this collection of points, including, in general relativity, a topological feature of curvature – the topology of special relativity is flat. By mathematically analyzing the relationships within this spacetime manifold, predictions of real world behavior are made.

The spacetime manifold of relativity is simply a higher-level mathematical abstraction, with no implication that the manifold itself, and its properties, such as curvature, physically exist in the real world. It is, in effect, a concept of method, and a highly useful one at that.

As to the “spacetime interval,” I wrote a short paper on that, explaining it in detail, yet in non-technical terms. Later I will see if I can easily post it here. If not, just send me your email address (mine is below) and I will email it to you.

Janet, here is the little article on the spacetime interval that I mentioned earlier.

From: Stephen Speicher

Here on HBL I have advocated the valid use of spacetime--as a
mathematical abstraction--in a rational theory of relativity. The
purpose of this post is to concretize, by example, some of the
abstract ideas that were previously discussed, and to demonstrate
the objective nature of the spacetime interval.  Everything is
presented in the simplest of terms, and no mathematics beyond
grade-school level is required. There is nothing radically new in
this presentation and, in fact, I have stolen bits and pieces
from various authors.  This is a simple concept, presented with
simple examples, in the simplest possible way I could conceive.

To begin with, we should be clear what is meant by the distance
between two points in standard Euclidean geometry. Figure 1 shows
an X-Y coordinate system with the origin at (0,0), and a point
located at position (x,y). The distance d is the hypotenuse of a
right triangle with one side being of length x, and the other
side of length y.


                  Figure 1.
                  ---------


                Y
                ^          
                |          (x,y)
                |          /|
                |         / |
                |        /  |
                |       /   |
                |    d /    |
                |     /     |
                |    /     y|
                |   /       |
                |  /        |
                | /         |
                |/     x    |
                ----------------------> X
              (0,0)




Using the Pythagorean theorem, the distance d^2 = x^2 + y^2. This
is the distance formula in Euclidean geometry, and for a
3-dimensional space it generalizes to:

         d^2 = x^2 + y^2 + z^2


This distance formula represents an invariant quantity, meaning
that the distance d is an objective value which will not change
due to whatever means we use to measure it--all will agree on the
quantity. So, for instance, if the x-y-d relationship were
located some other place in the coordinate system, rather than
beginning at the origin, or if a different kind of coordinate
system were used, such as a radial system using a radius and an
angle for the coordinate axes, the distance d would still remain
the same--it is an objective invariant quantity.

In general, since there is no reason to restrict distances to
begin at the origin, the x, y, and z distances are usually
expressed as the difference between the starting and ending
points, i.e., x2 - x1, y2 - y1, and z2- z1.  For short, we will
express those differences as dx, dy, and dz.  The distance
formula is then:

         d^2 = dx^2 + dy^2 +dz^2

There are two other concepts we should be familiar with; one we
would not ordinarily conceive of but which upon reflection will
make perfect sense, is the idea of light-time travel. The speed
of light, ususally referred to as c, is approximately 300 million
meters per second. With this value for c, we can easily determine
that light travels 1 meter in approximately 3.3 nanoseconds
(billionths of a second). We can then define a unit of time as
being 1 meter of light-travel time, or just meter of time. In
addition, the usual units for speed are meters per second, but
with time measured in meters of light-travel time, the speed
becomes meters of distance, per meter of time.  For simplicity,
we will use B (Greek beta) instead of meters per meter, so that
for light, which travels a 1 meter distance in 1 meter of
light-travel time, B_light = 1. Then, for everything else, which
has a velocity (v) that is some fraction of the speed of light,
B = v/c.

Fundamental to relativity is the concept of an event, which is
specified not only by a location where something happens, but
also by a time of occurrence. An event is idealized, in the sense
that in reality the turning on of a flashlight, or the explosion
of a firecracker, occurs over an extended region, and over an
extended period of time. An event, then, is idealized in that we
isolate a specific location at a specific time, which is then
associated with the event.

We can specify an event as a point in space, at an instant in
time, and uniquely characterize an event with four numbers: three
are required for its spatial location (such as x, y, and z), and
one for its time of occurrence (t).   The mathematical
abstraction of all such events--of all that occurred in the past,
of all that are occurring now, of all that will occur in the
future--is what we refer to as spacetime. In mathematical terms,
the precise specification of spacetime is that spacetime is a
four-dimensional manifold, which simply means it is a
mathematical space which requires four numbers to characterize an
event.

As advance motivation for our example, consider the following. In
a 1910 paper, Einstein stated the following principle:

  "The _laws governing natural phenomena are independent
   of the state of motion of the coordinate system with
   respect to which the phenomena are observed, provided
   that this system is not in accelerated motion_."

This is known as the Principle of Relativity, and it basically
says that the laws of physics are the same in every inertial
(non-accelerated) reference frame.  What it does _not_ say,
however, is that the distance between two events must be the same
when measured from two different frames, nor does it say that the
time between two events must be the same in different frames.
Contrary to our intuitive sense based on our experiences
traveling at low velocities, in general, observers in motion will
not agree on observed and measured quantities for lengths and
times, as well as other physical quantities such as momentum and
force. The physical laws are the same, but the measured physical
quantities will differ between observers. The one exception to
this principle is the speed of light, which experiment has
repeatedly shown to be a constant value, c, in all reference
frames. (This fact is a postulate in Einstein's Special
Relativity, but it is given physical meaning in Lewis Little's
Theory of Elementaty Waves.)

In order to present a concrete example, we first require a means
of determining the location and time of any given event. It will
be instructive to devise a three-dimensional coordinate system
(essentially a framework for a cube) where the building blocks in
each dimension are interconnected sticks, each a meter in length.
At every three-dimensional intersection of these meter sticks, we
will attach a clock, which has been calibrated in meters of
light-travel time. This means that the unit of time between each
tick of the clock represents what we have called one meter of
time. Let us further assume that we have devised a way to
precisely synchronize all of these clocks, in such a manner that
they are not subject to changes as they are moved to their
various positions.

In such a framework we can determine the position of an event as
the location of its closest clock, and the time of the event will
be recorded by that clock.  If we require any greater degree of
accuracy, we can always reduce each building stick to some
fraction of a meter (with a corresponding clock-tick reduction),
as small as necessary.  For our example, we will need two
identical frameworks; one framework we will call our laboratory
frame, and the other framework, which will be in uniform motion
relative to the laboratory frame, we will call our rocket frame.

To further simplify our example, we will assume that the rocket
frame is traveling in one of the three perpendicular directions
of our X-Y-Z coordinate system, say X. It should be clear by
visualizing both of these frames being coincident in spacetime at
a point when they overlap, that the Y and Z coordinates of each
frame will always remain coincident, since the rocket frame is
only traveling, relative to the laboratory frame, in the X
direction.  We may, therefore, remove consideration of the Y and
Z directions from our example, noting that, in general, this will
of course not be the case.

We are interested now in analyzing the occurrence of two events,
say event A and event Z. Event A is the emission of a flash of
light, and event Z is the reception of the light, after
reflection by some means (the details of the light source,
reflection, and reception are not important, it is the overall
concept we are interested in). The light source is in the
laboratory frame, located at its origin (x=y=z=t=0) while the
reflector is on the rocket clock just one meter above the rocket
frame origin.

Assume the rocket travels so that it is coincident with the
laboratory frame just as event A occurs, i.e., the rocket and
laboratory origins overlap just as the light is emitted. Figure 2
shows what is observed in the laboratory frame, and Figure 3
shows the rocket frame observation of the events. A and Z
represent the emission and reception events, and R shows the
reflector on the rocket. For both the laboratory and rocket
frames, event A occurs at the origin, zero coordinates.



         FIGURE 2. Light path in laboratory frame
         ----------------------------------------


          |                            |
         -O--------------R-------------O-
          |             /\             |
          |            /  \            |
          |           /    \           |
          |          /      \          |
          |         /        \         |
          |        /          \        |
 1 meter  |       /            \       |
          |      /              \      |
          |     /                \     |
          |    /                  \    |
          |   /                    \   |
          |  /                      \  |
          | /                        \ |
          |/                          \|
 EVENT A -O----------------------------O- EVENT Z
          |        dx = 1 meter        |
                 




Since the rocket is traveling and the relector is attached to it,
the light will reflect back to the laboratory frame after the
rocket has moved some distance, so that the reception of the
light will be separated from the emission point. For our example
we will assume the speed of the rocket is such that the reflector
R is exactly midway between the laboratory 1 meter sticks at the
time that the light reaches it. If we follow the path of the
light in this laboratory frame, we see it is the hypotenuse of a
right triangle from event A to the reflector R.  Using the
Pythagorean theorem, the hypotenuse length is given by:

   length^2 = 1^2 +(1/2)^2 meters^2

or
   length = sqrt[1 + (1/2)^2] meters

Since the hypotenuse from the reflector R to the reception point
Z is the same relationship as calculated above, the total length
of the light path, in the laboratory frame is:

   total_length_laboratory = 2 * sqrt[1 + (1/2)^2] meters
                           
     "           "         = 2.236 meters




         FIGURE 3. Light path in rocket frame
         ------------------------------------



|---|                                  |\
|   -----------------------------------  \
|                                         \
|                                          \
|                                           \
|          |                            |    \
|         -R----------------------------O-    \
|          |                            |      \
|          |                            |       \    
|          |                            |        \
|          |                            |         \
|          |                            |          \
|          |                            |           \
| 1 meter  |                            |            \
|          |                            |            /
|          |                            |           /
|          |                            |          /
|          |                            |         /
|          |                            |        /
|          |                            |       /
|          |                            |      /
| EVENT A -O----------------------------O-    /
|   and    |                            |    /
| EVENT Z                                   /
|                                          /
|                                         /
|   ____________________________________ /
|---|                                  |/


For the rocket frame, the reception event, Z, is at the same
location as the emission event, A. The length of the light path,
then, is 1 meter from A to R, plus 1 meter from R to Z. The total
length of the light path, in the rocket frame is:

   total_length_rocket = 2 meters

This calculation was for the path length traveled by the light,
in meters; therefore it represents the time between event A,
emission, and event Z, reception, in meters of light-travel time.
Clearly then, the rocket time observation was less than the
laboratory observation, 2 meters for the rocket frame as compared
to 2.236 meters for the laboratory frame. In addition, the
observed distance between event A and event Z is also different
between the two frames. The rocket frame sees events A and Z
occurring at the same point in spacetime, whereas the laboratory
frame measures a 1 meter separation between the two events.

This then is part of what we sought to demonstrate, namely that
the spatial separation between events and the time difference
between events is not, in general, observed to be the same
between reference frames in relative uniform motion.  We may ask,
however, is there an invariant quantity which is preserved across
different frames in this spacetime formulation, much as the
distance formula represents an invariant quantity in Euclidean
geometry? The answer is yes, there is such an invariant quantity
in spacetime, the spacetime interval, and the form of that
quantity is very similar to the form of the distance formula. The
spacetime interval is expressed as:


  (interval)^2 = dt^2 - dx^2 - dy^2 - dz^2

The difference in sign between the time t, and the spatial
coordinates x, y, and z, reflects the different character, the
different nature between these elements of spacetime. Physically,
they illustrate, and quantify, the different 'mix' of time and
space for different frames of reference. What the spacetime
interval does, what its quantity represents, is an objective
physical quantity that is invariant across frames--an objective
fact that all observers agree upon.

By using the values we calculated for dt and dx (for simplicity
we have assumed dy and dz are zero) in the spacetime interval
formula, we find:

   laboratory_interval = sqrt[2.236^2 - 1^2] = 2 meters

   rocket_interval = sqrt[2^ - 0^2] = 2 meters

So the laboratory interval = rocket interval = 2 meters; we have
agreement.

This example was devised to make the calculations simple, but the
principles it illustrates apply in general. We can even look a
little more carefully at the form of our expressions to get a
sense of the dependence of the result on the relative speed of
the frames. When we calculated the path length of the light in
the laboratory frame, we arrived at the expression:

     2 * sqrt[1 + (1/2)^2] meters

The '1' in the '1/2' represents the distance separating events A
and Z in the laboratory frame. In our example this value was made
to be what it was for ease of calculation. In general the event
separation distance will be dependent upon the speed of the
rocket, and the expression would be:

     2 * sqrt[1 + (dx/2)^2] meters

The slower the speed of the rocket, the smaller the value of dx,
and the closer the expression will reflect our ordinary
experience. The faster the rocket speed, the larger the distance
dx, and the longer the path length of light, which means the
longer the light-travel time. This is a relativistic effect which
increases at greater and greater speed, approaching the speed of
light.  Recall that when we measure meters of light time,
B_light = 1, whereas all others are expressed as a fraction of
light-speed, B = v/c. A somewhat more detailed analysis would
reveal the meaning of this expression, and its connection to the
famous Lorentz transformations. In addition, there are a wealth
of insights to be gleaned by analyzing spacetime diagrams, which
are a means of graphically representing spacetime events.  We can
leave such analyses for another post, if there is interest in
further exploration.[/code]

Thank you so much for posting the paper for me, Stephen. Now I would ask for another favor: would you please send it to me in an email? With webtv, I’m not able to print one highlighted portion of a page, but must print the whole thread in order to get the one post I want. (I’m not able to highlight one particular section, which is why I cannot use the QUOTE function on the forum – very frustrating!) Ink for my printer is very expensive and so very precious; I hate to waste any on what I don’t need.

If you don’t mind, please send it to [email protected]. If you do mind, it won’t bother me in any way. What I’m asking, after all, is a favor. :wink: You’ve already been very generous with your time.

Your paper stirred up quite a chemical cocktail in my brain! Whatever scant knowledge of (even elementary) math I once had has long faded away from lack of use. It’s going to take me a while to work my way through your explanation, but I’ve already gotten enough that I know it will be worth it. I can see that I’ve got to refresh my math, though, if I’m to truly understand. Lots to work on and I’m excited about it. Thank you again.

Janet, I just forwarded the post, as it appeared here, to your email address. If you have any questions feel free to ask them here, or in private email if you prefer.

I got it. Thank you.

I got it. Thank you.