* Dismiss it as arbitrary. (This makes sense but runs into problems. Items in advanced physics would probably be incomprehensible to me, but they are certainly reasonable to believe.)
* Assess the level of your intelligence. A very intelligent person should take his ability to understand something as the standard of reasonableness, and dismiss as arbitrary the item that he cannot understand. A less intelligent person might see how authorities treat the item instead, and treat it like they do. (This answer also makes sense but does not really apply to fields like philosophy, where there are no ultimate authorities, and what authorities there are do not agree about much.)
* Study harder. (In some situations this would be the right approach but there are also situations where one has read all the material and does not understand the item in question.)
These are all poor options because they ignore your nature as a human being and thinking person, as well as the nature of the subject you’re trying to understand.
Dismissing something as arbitrary when you don’t even understand the claim that is being made is ludicrous. In this model, you would be using “arbitrary” as an effective “get out of jail free” card to avoid thinking.
Assessing the level of your own intelligence is a massively difficult project, and intelligence has almost nothing to do with WHAT you can understand–just HOW MUCH of it you can deal with at once. People of average intelligence can learn calculus and higher mathematics if it is presented in such a way that takes into account their limitations. They can make judgments based on material that is simplified for an intelligent layman.
Studying harder without making an evaluation on the worth of a given item of knowledge to you, personally, is a waste of time.
The proper thing to do is to assess how important this particular issue is to you, decide how much time you are willing to devote to it, and then seek out avenues that are appropriate given the amount of time/interest you have to spend. If you have little and the issue is not important, the proper action may just be to say “I’m not following this and it isn’t worth my time”, and drop it.
However, in many cases the fact that you don’t understand something is not an indicator of failure on your part but on the part of the person attempting to explain it to you. If you are of at least average intelligence and are confronted by some elaborate bit of hooey, don’t assume that you’re too stupid to understand it and thus it must be profound in its indications. The burden of making their claims comprehensible falls upon the person making those claims. Tell them you’re not interested in their hooey unless they can summarize it well enough that you can grasp the ESSENTIALS of their case. The minute details aren’t what make or break their case, anyway–that’s just the loopholes where they hope to hide themselves.