Over at JREF, the scientific skeptics forum, a poster (Dinwar) is doing a great job of responding to critics of Objectivism. His first entry in the thread called “A Natural Disaster in Galt’s Gulch” is one of 12 posts on the thread:
Quote: Keep in mind most of what I know about Objectivism comes from a friend’s college dorm mate who used it as a pretext to steal all his stuff and never clean up. Basically a “because you allow me to get away with this I will continue to do it” sort of excuse. It still makes me angry.
So what you’re saying is that Mr. Thompson is your ideal Objectivist.
To put it more clearly: that wasn’t Objectivism. That was someone lying about Objectivism. O’ism views the Supermen in the same light as any other moocher–that is to say, as more or less the physical embodyment of evil. Rand’s heros actually all make the opposite mistake: they take on TOO MUCH responsibility, not too little.
I’m an Objectivist. Yet I’ve fought floods and fires, helping save property that’s not my own. I did it for my own selfish reasons (no damn river is going to defeate ME, and I love my father). I also used to help clean up after parties (I really, REALLY don’t like cleaning up stale beer when I’m hung over). I’d much rather live in a society where I can ask my neighbor for help than one where I can’t, and am demonstrably willing to put my life on the line to establish such a society. THAT is an Objectivist view of the world: this is what I want, and this is how much I’m willing to pay.
He also does very well in this thread (A Philosophy Professor discusses Ayn Rand in his ethics class) starting with post #5