I am a former student of the Dominican order, as some here already know, and an advocate of a modified version of Thomism. Like Objectivism, this philosophical/theological viewpoint draws a good deal of inspiration from Aristotle, but there are some notable differences in most of the 5 branches of philosophy that are obviously noteworthy. As someone who has also studied Objectivism, particularly it’s Epistemology and how it applies to education, I have also been a bit influenced by it though clearly the topic of debate here is one area where I do not agree with the philosophy.
The question up for discussion is “The existence of God” in the context of metaphysics and epistemology. Does God exist or not, and what are the proofs that we can reference? As this debate was prompted by an off-topic discussion in another forum, I will make my claim by answering the last post on that discussion by MisterSwig, whom may wish to engage in this debate, although I am interested in getting any and every view on this. His post reads:
You’re operating upon the false assumption that the universe has a source.
“Universe” is merely a name for the imagined sum or collection of every individual thing that exists. It is not an actual thing in reality that has a source. It is a name for the collection of every thing that exists–stars, planets, comets, moons, animals, people, etc. These are the things which we lump together under the concept “existents” and collectively call “the universe.” It’s a difficult concept to grasp, but it is similar to the concept “society.” Society is not something that exists in reality as an individual thing. It designates a collection of things–people. Likewise, universe designates a collection of things–every existent that exists.
Now, if you want to speak of the “source” of any actual existent, then go ahead and pick one and offer a theory about it. I’d love to hear a rational argument for why God is the source of the Earth or the Sun, which are things that actually exist.
- I agree that this is an accurate description for the way one would categorize any potential phenomena existing beyond our current reference of study, absent an encounter visive the senses, the imagination is clearly active in the process. However, imagination has been proven to be a catalyst in advancing the process of knowledge and study, so the fact that the imagination is involved alone does not necessitate a disproof of a theoretical existent, it merely denotes that this particular entity “may or may not” exist.
I also agree that the existence of multiple dimensions is also an error that arises from thinking of the “universe” implies something other than the full extent of metaphysical existence. The issue comes up in the context of “Reality” versus “Universe”, and I will now provide an arguement meant for any others wishing to enter the discussion, just so I can be clear to them as to where I stand.
These two words are not synonymous in terms of definitions in the dictionary, nor are they considered synonymous in any thesaurus that I have read in my lifetime. So I will now present their various defintions to save time going back and forth to Dictionary.com or any other similar site.
Universe
1. All matter and energy, including the earth, the galaxies, and the contents of intergalactic space, regarded as a whole.
2. The earth together with all its inhabitants and created things, the human race.
3. The sphere or realm in which something exists or takes place.
Reality
1. The quality or state of being actual or true.
2. One, such as a person, an entity, or an event, that is actual: “the weight of history and political realities” (Benno C. Schmidt, Jr.).
3. The totality of all things possessing actuality, existence, or essence.
4. That which exists objectively and in fact: Your observations do not seem to be about reality.
Many Christian apologists uphold that God exists both inside and outside the universe, which I personally think is an error. It is more a matter of “if God created what we now percieve as the universe, both in terms of speculation and actual categorization” then it must have existed before such a thing occurred. Technically if we assume heaven to be a real place, it would fall under the bounds of the universe and would exist in a non-material form.
Now to the issue of the universe, there is the issue not only of material objects and entities, but also of energy. The Second Law of Thermodynamics states that the amount of energy in a system that is available to do work is decreasing. As this applies to the complete universe, the tendency of systems existing within is to move towards chaos, not order. This can be seen in all observable phenomena, including the life-span of a human being. If the universe is seen as eternal, then by this standard, it should be completely dead and all the universe should be a mess replete with unorganized inanimate objects and random energy. If this standard is incorrect, and the Second Law of Thermal Dynamics is at error, what is the correct explanation of order versus chaos in the universe?
(I apologize for any details that seem unneccesary to our particular discussion MisterSwig, I just wanted to be sure that my topic is understood by everyone reading it)
- The theory of evolution states that all life on earth originated from inanimate matter, and thus proceeds to categorize nature based on observable material phenomena. There is no contradiction between this and my beliefs about the way science should be approached. Furthermore, man is described in Genesis as originating as dust, which is not in contradiction with the inanimate matter theory. The only difference between them is that Genesis does not contain the specific naturalistic explanation of what components of what is refered to as dust (ergo elements) and thus it is clearly not sufficient for scientific study, and in the field of science should be treated as an obsolete predecesor of evolution. The point of contention is the assertion that naturalistic categorizations which improve upon the more generalized reference that man originated from dust neccessitate that God does not exist or did not cause the process. It would, however, be accurate to describe anyone whom openly attacks evolution as being evil as irrational, and I share your sentiments on such Christians. Thus you could describe me as a proponent of Theistic Evolution.
As far as the Sun and the consequence of planet earth’s formation goes, the " it happened on it’s own" explanation to how or why the energy that makes up the Sun organizes itself in such a way as to allow for the conditions that makes Earth, or any other planet of similar make up that may exist, is not sufficient by virtue of the 2nd Law of Thermal Dynamics. If the tendency of a star is to burn out, why do new stars continue to form.
If the tendency of an object is to do something, and it does something else that would seem contrary to that tendency, the issue must clearly be addressed. The belief that God takes an active role in the organization of existents is a leap of faith, but I have seen no other explanation that sufficiently explains the following phenomena.
-
The organization of existents.
-
The re-organization and utilization of energy in spite of a tendency towards chaos.
-
The fact that human beings are capable of imagining things that either do not exist or have not been observed with the senses. (Note: this does not imply spontaneous thought independent of experience, but the ability to alter observed phenomena in one’s mind to create new imaginary phenomena.)
-
The ability of man alone to philosophize.