The only think I edited was the word “god” which I UNcapitalized.
This is not true. The word “god” was not capitalized in the original post, nor was the word “objectivist.” You went back and changed “objectivist” to “Objectivist” and did nothing to the word “god” at all. This can be clearly verified by anyone who was sent the original post, which I still have on my computer, and comparing it to the post now on the forum, which you can no longer change. Again, there is nothing wrong with editing within the time allowed to edit after posting, unless you choose not to acknowledge the fact of doing so while condeming another for something you did.
Here is a copy of the original post, just as it was sent to me by the forum. Anyone can check it themselves against the one currently on the forum.
****************************************************************
Thesweetscience has just posted a reply to a topic that you have subscribed to titled “Defending Ayn Rand against attacks”.
QUOTE(Sherlock @ Jan 7 2005, 12:07 AM)Thesweetscience,
You wrote: But, to try and create more Objectivists is a worthy goal."
Objectivism can stand on its own. To conceal the fact that Objectivism rejects religious faith to “lure 'em in” is distasteful and also ultimately disrespectful of those you are trying to “convert”.
Mr. Speicher is simply not doing what you wish to do to others: candy-coat truth. I guess it does seem fitting that those who advocate hiding the blunt truth are themselves unable to accept truth unless it is cloaked with nice words.
Sherlock, remember the context of the question that was asked of me. “Does one have to be an atheist to be an Objectivist”
I take the term atheist to be a person who does not believe in “god”. I think a person CAN believe in a creator and still be an objectivist.
If the question had been can a person have “religious faith” and still be an Objectivist? I would have definately answered no.
I still believe in the strictest sense my answer to him is correct. It may be a technicality, but it is still correct.
The topic can be found here:
http://forum.ObjectivismOnline.com/index.p…view=getnewpost
************************************************************