Thoughts on defending Rand against this attack?

Thesweetscience,

You wrote: But, to try and create more Objectivists is a worthy goal."

Objectivism can stand on its own. To conceal the fact that Objectivism rejects religious faith to “lure 'em in” is distasteful and also ultimately disrespectful of those you are trying to “convert”.

Mr. Speicher is simply not doing what you wish to do to others: candy-coat truth. I guess it does seem fitting that those who advocate hiding the blunt truth are themselves unable to accept truth unless it is cloaked with nice words.

Thesweetscience,

You wrote: But, to try and create more Objectivists is a worthy goal."

Objectivism can stand on its own. To conceal the fact that Objectivism rejects religious faith to “lure 'em in” is distasteful and also ultimately disrespectful of those you are trying to “convert”.

Mr. Speicher is simply not doing what you wish to do to others: candy-coat truth. I guess it does seem fitting that those who advocate hiding the blunt truth are themselves unable to accept truth unless it is cloaked with nice words.

Sherlock, remember the context of the question that was asked of me. “Does one have to be an atheist to be an Objectivist”

I take the term atheist to be a person who does not believe in “god”. I think a person CAN believe in a creator and still be an Objectivist.

If the question had been can a person have “religious faith” and still be an Objectivist? I would have definately answered no.

I still believe in the strictest sense my answer to him is correct. It may be a technicality, but it is still correct.

I think a person CAN believe in a creator and still be an objectivist.

Why? Based on what proof? Faith and “feeling” that the universe could not have been created any other way?

Thesweetscience,

You’ve got to be kidding. To pretend that to be an atheist, one cannot believe in God but still can believe in a “creator” is simply ludicrous. You are indulging in semantics, and not very effective semantics at that. No, a person most emphatically can NOT believe in a “creator” and still be an Objectivist (which, by the way, you have been asked to capitalize before—please do so). I don’t think you understand Objectivism at all if you think this.

By the way, I just went there and found that there have been quite a few more posts. I haven’t read them yet, but I hope you will be more careful in what you say before responding.

Objectivism can stand on its own. To conceal the fact that Objectivism rejects religious faith to “lure 'em in” is distasteful and also ultimately disrespectful of those you are trying to “convert”.

Mr. Speicher is simply not doing what you wish to do to others: candy-coat truth. I guess it does seem fitting that those who advocate hiding the blunt truth are themselves unable to accept truth unless it is cloaked with nice words.

Agreed. Being direct is always better. If what you are saying is persuasive and true, eventually the individuals who have the potential to be swayed, will be. If not, too bad for them.

To answer your original question: how do you argue against such people?, in terms of method, I would say:

  1. keep to the original points

  2. know when to stop

For example, the poster that started you off, “dan”, is just a twit. No prettier way to put it. With someone like that, I would not worry about speaking to them but would simply attempt to set the record straight, which is what you did. It is very helpful to present the alternative viewpoint, and how Objectivism helped you personally. You never know who may be affected also as a result of your support. “dan” will never going to come around to your viewpoint, so you should consider your job done once you have spoken your mind, and you realize you are not making any logical headway.

The poster “Jean” seems like a world-weary pragmatist. They are familiar with Rand but still don’t get it. What can you say to someone like that? Again, just set the record straight and when you’ve done that, you’ve done all you can.

Thesweetscience,

You’ve got to be kidding. To pretend that to be an atheist, one cannot believe in God but still can believe in a “creator” is simply ludicrous. You are indulging in semantics, and not very effective semantics at that. No, a person most emphatically can NOT believe in a “creator” and still be an Objectivist (which, by the way, you have been asked to capitalize before—please do so). I don’t think you understand Objectivism at all if you think this.

By the way, I just went there and found that there have been quite a few more posts. I haven’t read them yet, but I hope you will be more careful in what you say before responding.

I have re-read my last post and unless I am going blind I did capitalize correctly.

And I did NOT say that a person can be an atheist and still believe in a creator either.

So maybe you are reading posts by someone else or living in another universe because I didnt say or do either of the two things you just accused me of.

Objectivism can stand on its own. To conceal the fact that Objectivism rejects religious faith to “lure 'em in” is distasteful and also ultimately disrespectful of those you are trying to “convert”.

Not to mention how disrespectful such an approach is to the one who created the philosophy – Ayn Rand. The last thing Objectivism needs is naive and ignorant proselytizers. The hope for the future lies not with “converting” the mystics, but in appealing to the best and the brightest with concern for rationality and values. Sure, it is possible, though unusual, for deeply religious folk to discover and embrace Objectivism, but even then it is only those few who already have a foot-hold on reality. I have told the story here of my young friend Don, a Hasidic Jew with whom I shared a great interest in talking about ideas. Don eventually read Atlas Shrugged and shed his religious trappings, but only because I never pulled any punches and always let him know where I and the philosophy stood.

God help us from the proselytizers who do not grasp the philosophy themselves, attempting to “save” others just like a good Christian should. If “Thesweetscience” is really concerned about creating a better world, he should put his effort into trying to understand the philsophy instead of trying to “convert” others.

I have re-read my last post and unless I am going blind I did capitalize correctly.

But you have failed to acknowledge that you did so as an edit after the post had already been made. Many of us, Sherlock most likely included, get email updates showing the posts made[*]. My copy of your post shows that you did not capitalize Objectivism, but corrected it later with an edit, after the fact. There is nothing wrong with editing that post per se, except hiding that fact to make it appear otherwise.

[*]Others may respond between the time the post is initially made and the time it is edited.

Thesweetscience,

You wrote: “And I did NOT say that a person can be an atheist and still believe in a creator either.”

This is what you wrote: “I take the term atheist to be a person who does not believe in “god”. I think a person CAN believe in a creator and still be an Objectivist.”

Semantics, pure semantics.

As for the capitalization, I apologize if I was wrong. I may have seen an earlier post while scrolling through. Mea culpa.

Ahh, so I wasn’t going blind either: you edited your post and then chose to accuse me of “reading posts by someone else or living in another universe”. That’s rather tasteless, and deceptive to boot.

Ahh, so I wasn’t going blind either: you edited your post and then chose to accuse me of  “reading posts by someone else or living in another universe”. That’s rather tasteless, and deceptive to boot.

The only think I edited was the word “god” which I UNcapitalized. It is not semantics, you misread what I wrote. I never said or meant that one can be an atheist and believe that there is a creator. Didn’t say it and I don’t believe it.

You can attack anything that I say that is wrong, just not things I didn’t say. Especially when I agree completely that it would be untrue to say “A person can be an atheist and still believe in a creator” I find that to be as idiotic as you do.

The only think I edited was the word “god” which I UNcapitalized.

This is not true. The word “god” was not capitalized in the original post, nor was the word “objectivist.” You went back and changed “objectivist” to “Objectivist” and did nothing to the word “god” at all. This can be clearly verified by anyone who was sent the original post, which I still have on my computer, and comparing it to the post now on the forum, which you can no longer change. Again, there is nothing wrong with editing within the time allowed to edit after posting, unless you choose not to acknowledge the fact of doing so while condeming another for something you did.

Here is a copy of the original post, just as it was sent to me by the forum. Anyone can check it themselves against the one currently on the forum.

****************************************************************

Thesweetscience has just posted a reply to a topic that you have subscribed to titled “Defending Ayn Rand against attacks”.


QUOTE(Sherlock @ Jan 7 2005, 12:07 AM)Thesweetscience,

You wrote: But, to try and create more Objectivists is a worthy goal."

Objectivism can stand on its own. To conceal the fact that Objectivism rejects religious faith to “lure 'em in” is distasteful and also ultimately disrespectful of those you are trying to “convert”.

Mr. Speicher is simply not doing what you wish to do to others: candy-coat truth. I guess it does seem fitting that those who advocate hiding the blunt truth are themselves unable to accept truth unless it is cloaked with nice words.


Sherlock, remember the context of the question that was asked of me. “Does one have to be an atheist to be an Objectivist”

I take the term atheist to be a person who does not believe in “god”. I think a person CAN believe in a creator and still be an objectivist.

If the question had been can a person have “religious faith” and still be an Objectivist? I would have definately answered no.

I still believe in the strictest sense my answer to him is correct. It may be a technicality, but it is still correct.


The topic can be found here:

http://forum.ObjectivismOnline.com/index.p…view=getnewpost

************************************************************

Thesweetscience,

You apparently don’t have a problem with deceiving “converts”, nor do you have a problem with attempting to deceive us over a trivial matter such as this. I don’t see the point in continuing a conversation with someone who does not value honesty.

Adios.

I take the term atheist to be a person who does not believe in “god”. I think a person CAN believe in a creator and still be an Objectivist.

If the question had been can a person have “religious faith” and still be an Objectivist?  I would have definately answered no.

How does one believe in a “creator” without having faith, religious or otherwise? To believe in something means there is a lack of certainty. If you have certainty, then you have knowledge, not belief. Objectivists really don’t tend to be “believers”. They tend to be “knowers” or “not knowers”.

Thesweetscience,

You apparently don’t have a problem with deceiving “converts”, nor do you have a problem with attempting to deceive us over a trivial matter such as this. I don’t see the point in continuing a conversation with someone who does not value honesty.

Adios.

To be completely fair, I think it possible that rather than being deceitful he is just not remembering which word he actually changed. However, considering the deceit he proudly proclaimed in “converting” mystics towards Objectivism by concealing the philosophy and “finessing” them, without any further evidence I too would opt for dishonesty in this instance, rather than misremembrance.

To Thesweetscience,

In Objectivism, there is no room for god - ANY god. Objectivism is atheistic from its deepest fundamentals to its greatest abstractions. What you are trying to do - explaining someone that Objectivists will accept god if it be logically explained and proven to exist - is incorrect at the very least. There is no “journey” to be taken when “converting” to Objectivism - you learn and understand Objectivism and that’s all there is to it. Just like you would have learned any other science. Reading “The Fountainhead” will not suffice.

For your further reading, if you are really interested in Objectivism and wish to learn its principles, I would suggest Leonard Peikoff’s “Objectivism: The Philosophy of Ayn Rand.” It’s book 6 of “The Ayn Rand Library” and you can find it on Amazon. It explains Objectivism in sufficient detail for an average reader and I think that reading it will set some things straight in your thinking - that is, IF you choose to understand what it says.

To others,

Of all the people, you should know that man is not born omniscient. After being fed false philosophies for a lifetime, it is easily conceivable that one will be completely confused by Objectivism and its use of reason and logic. Not everyone knows what it means to hold life as one’s standard of value and what consequences it has. Things like this have to be learned and you all choose to ignore that fact. Instead of recognizing this man’s good sense of life (which he has shown through his admiration of The Fountainhead and his reaction to the attack on it), you choose to ignore that and expect him to discuss with you the most complex concepts of Objectivism as if he held them with utmost clarity. And instead of referring him to further reading, you whip him for not knowing and thinking wrong. It’s like a teacher beating up a first grade student because he can’t integrate.

To others,

…

Things like this have to be learned and you all choose to ignore that fact. Instead of recognizing this man’s good sense of life (which he has shown through his admiration of The Fountainhead and his reaction to the attack on it), you choose to ignore that and expect him to discuss with you the most complex concepts of Objectivism as if he held them with utmost clarity. And instead of referring him to further reading, you whip him for not knowing and thinking wrong. It’s like a teacher beating up a first grade student because he can’t integrate.

This is a rather pointed charge. If you are going to accuse people of choosing to ignore facts, you should be specific as to whom you are accusing, and you should have facts yourself to prove that was their choice.

I have read through this thread and I have noticed “others” have been helpful to TSS. Those who have been critical of him have been critical of his deceptive means for “converting” people to Objectivism. Deception is still considered to be wrong by those “false philosphies” and by first graders so that offers no defense. One need not know the most complex concepts of Objectivism to understand that deception is wrong.

My suggestion would be to support your charge or retract your accusation to “others”.

To others,

Of all the people, you should know that man is not born omniscient. After being fed false philosophies for a lifetime, it is easily conceivable that one will be completely confused by Objectivism and its use of reason and logic. Not everyone knows what it means to hold life as one’s standard of value and what consequences it has. Things like this have to be learned and you all choose to ignore that fact. Instead of recognizing this man’s good sense of life (which he has shown through his admiration of The Fountainhead and his reaction to the attack on it), you choose to ignore that and expect him to discuss with you the most complex concepts of Objectivism as if he held them with utmost clarity. And instead of referring him to further reading, you whip him for not knowing and thinking wrong. It’s like a teacher beating up a first grade student because he can’t integrate.

I agree; sometimes I cringe when I see the “greeting” that some newcomers get when they say something wrong. But I can’t change that, so I just try to be as constructive as possible, within the context of their views.

I agree; sometimes I cringe when I see the “greeting” that some newcomers get when they say something wrong.[…]

Let me see if I have understood this situation correctly.

  1. Source addressed Thesweetscience, then he addressed “others” without any delimiting qualification.

  2. He accused them of various failures and even dishonesty (evasion, choosing to ignore).

  3. Because I have posted in this thread and because I am not Thesweetscience, I am one of the “others.”

  4. You agree with source’s attack.

Are you then accusing me of failures and dishonesty? If so, please present your evidence. If not, please either make your charge specific – naming individuals and posts – or withdraw your blanket condemnation.

Is my point relevant to this thread? I think so because it may be instructive to Thesweetscience, whose basic, underlying question – How should one deal with religious people? – is a good one, even if his recent approach was fundamentally flawed.

I just went to that site, having a little time to spare. Wow, that conversation just kept going and going.

Inspector, let me very respectfully suggest that you refrain from personal attacks. It does great harm to your arguments, and it’s not necessary.

I don’t feel qualified to respond myself, and I appreciate that you’re taking a lot of time (!!) doing this, but I think it would be wise not to indulge in name-calling.