Tibet

I was wondering what gives a group of people the right to form their own country - especially if the new country is supposed to be situated in lands currently owned by an existing country.

In Tibet’s case they would be seceding from an autocratic government, only to form a theocracy. Would that be morally justified?

Does it really matter? We are talking about the lesser of two evils. Thats still evil. There are no other points to consider on the issue really.

I remember watching a Penn and Teller episode about Tibet where they bring up this issue.

Does it really matter? We are talking about the lesser of two evils. Thats still evil. There are no other points to consider on the issue really.

I remember watching a Penn and Teller episode about Tibet where they bring up this issue.

It is astonishing to watch: P&T Bullshit Holier Than Thou Part 1 ( while the highlight has to be Gandhi using the N-word, The Dalai Lama and Mother Theresa are also featured)

Does it really matter? We are talking about the lesser of two evils.

Are you really sure on that? Chinese government at least doesn’t steal peasant’s children to serve at monasteries. For the whole lifetime…

Does it really matter? We are talking about the lesser of two evils. Thats still evil. There are no other points to consider on the issue really.

You only (rationally) consider an issue if you want to make a choice. Were I a Tibetan, my choices would be more vivid: should I resist the continued imposition of the Red Chinese dictatorship? is the alternative the reinstatement of an equally brutal Tibetan-run religious dictatorship? What in fact were the rights violations of the lamocracy, and how does that compare with the Chinese invasion and subjugation of Tibet. The primary consideration for a Tibetan is – what is best for my life given reality and the rights violations that I suffer from.

As an American, the outcome of those events does not directly affect me one way or the other, but it matters which thing I advocate. Can I advocate maintaining the Red Chinese dictatorship? Absolutely not. Can I argue that Red China rules Tibet by right? Absolutely not? Do I believe that expelling the occupying forces would result in the imposition of an equally brutal religious dictatorship? Absolutely not. Do I believe that – with the reds expelled – Tibet would magically become a rational utopia, superior to America? Absolutely not. What I advocate for Tibet and what Tibetans are actually faced with are quite different things. My choices are not limited to two immoral forms of government. Their choice is rather limited, and it does matter what form of immoral government you actually work to eliminate, knowing what the alternative is.

It matters to the Tibetans, yes. Certainly it matters to the priestly class who want to take their country back and exploit thier people futher, with muscle and mind. By what right do the Tibetans have to their own land when the history is taken into consideration? The Chinese have built roads, infrastructure and modernized Tibet in many ways. They have also done atrocious things to the indigineous people’s. It’s a mixed bag and the Chinese had no right to take the land, I agree with you on that.

But, the big question now should be, I think, is it possible in reality for Tibet to be under the control of Tibetans again? Is China ever going to give Tibet back to its people? I think the rational answer given the possibilities is, no. So what can be done by Tibetans for Tibet as it is now? I think Tibetans should be focused on bettering themselves and their own living standards under their current government.

Thats my two cents anyway.

With Texas, it would be much more amicable. Or less.

I could see us seceding because of some stupid gun law. :frowning:

You would be surprised how many states have tried or are trying to secede since the Civil War. There is a movement in Texas to secede and there is also a movement in northern Michigan to secede.

You would be surprised how many states have tried or are trying to secede since the Civil War. There is a movement in Texas to secede and there is also a movement in northern Michigan to secede.

Actually, with Texas, it doesn’t surprise me. We already act like we’re better than the rest of the country, lol.